医疗从业者与产科服务因素对阿拉巴马州种族差异的影响:一项定性研究
本研究对阿拉巴马州20名产科医生、护士、导乐、哺乳顾问、卫生系统管理者及专业组织代表进行关键知情人访谈,采用主题分析法识别医疗从业者与产科服务层面导致种族差异的因素。从业者层面主题包括隐性偏见与显性种族主义、沟通缺乏、文化敏感性不足及临床知识经验差异;服务层面包括可及性差、护理质量与内容不足、连续性缺乏、歧视性机构政策及人员短缺与多样性不足。参与者建议开展偏见培训、改善劳动力种族与跨学科多样性,并采用团体产前保健、差异仪表盘、模拟培训、早期预警标准及协调护理等循证干预。
要点
- 访谈识别从业者层面因素:隐性偏见与显性种族主义、沟通缺乏、文化敏感性不足、临床知识经验差异。
- 服务层面因素包括可及性差、护理质量与内容不足、连续性缺乏、歧视性机构政策及人员短缺与多样性不足。
- 参与者建议偏见培训、改善劳动力多样性及采用团体产前保健、差异仪表盘、模拟培训、早期预警标准、协调护理等策略。
核心结论
- 从医疗从业者和管理者中获得关于产科医疗从业者与产科卫生服务因素如何导致阿拉巴马州孕产妇健康不公平的多元视角,解决这些因素的策略是多方面的。
研究设计与样本
- 对阿拉巴马州为不同种族和族裔患者提供产科护理的产科医生、护士、导乐、哺乳顾问、卫生系统管理者及专业组织代表进行关键知情人访谈,共访谈20名医疗从业者或管理者。
- 访谈指南基于Howell关于严重孕产妇发病和死亡中种族和族裔差异的概念框架制定,采用主题分析法,使用NVivo 12软件对转录文本进行编码和分析,通过开放编码和选择性编码识别与医疗从业者层面和产科服务层面决定因素相关的主题。
主要发现
- 医疗从业者相关主题包括隐性偏见与显性种族主义、沟通缺乏与缺乏积极的医患关系、文化敏感性不足、临床知识和经验差异。
- 产科服务相关主题包括可及性缺乏、护理质量和内容不足、护理连续性缺乏、歧视性机构政策、劳动力短缺和多样性缺乏。
关键数值与推荐
- 参与者建议的策略包括对医疗从业者进行偏见培训、改善产科劳动力中种族和跨学科多样性,以及团体产前保健、差异仪表盘、模拟培训、早期预警标准、协调护理等循证干预。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Black patients are three times more likely to die of pregnancy-related causes than White patients in the United States, and Alabama has the third worst maternal mortality rate in the nation. We sought to identify health care practitioner and maternity service factors contributing to disparities in Alabama, as well as potential strategies to address these contributors. METHODS: We conducted key informant interviews with obstetricians, nurses, doulas, lactation counselors, health system administrators, and representatives of professional organizations who deliver maternity care to racially and ethnically diverse patients in Alabama. The interview guide was developed using Howell's conceptual framework on racial and ethnic disparities in severe maternal morbidity and mortality. Adopting a thematic analysis approach, we coded and analyzed transcripts using NVivo 12 software. Open coding and selective coding were conducted to identify themes related to health care practitioner- and maternity services-level determinants. RESULTS: Overall, 20 health care practitioners or administrators were interviewed. Primary themes related to health care practitioners included implicit bias and explicit racism, lack of communication and lack of positive patient-health care practitioner relationships, lack of cultural sensitivity, and variation in clinical knowledge and experience. Primary themes related to maternity services included lack of accessibility, inadequate quality and content of care, lack of continuity of care, discriminatory facility policies, and workforce shortages and lack of diversity. Strategies suggested by participants to address these factors included bias trainings for health care practitioners, improvements in racial and interdisciplinary diversity in the maternity workforce, and evidence-based interventions such as group prenatal care, disparities dashboards, simulation trainings, early warning signs criteria, and coordinated care. CONCLUSION: We gained diverse perspectives from health care practitioners and administrators on how maternity health care practitioner and maternity health services factors contribute to inequities in maternal health in Alabama. Strategies to address these contributing factors were multifaceted.
引用
- Toluhi AA, Richardson MR, Julian ZI, et al. Contribution of Health Care Practitioner and Maternity Services Factors to Racial Disparities in Alabama: A Qualitative Study. Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37678848. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000005326
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。