患者主导的剖宫产后阴道分娩预测计算器应用方式
本研究邀请31名有剖宫产史的多元背景参与者接受访谈并记录产前检查,探讨其在原母胎医学单位剖宫产后阴道分娩(VBAC)计算器(含种族和民族因素)预测分数背景下的决策方式。预测VBAC成功率范围为12%至95%。识别出四个主题:拒绝种族和民族的作用、重新定义失败并发现成功、考虑分娩的身体体验、调整VBAC概率。结论提示数字概率并非对所有患者都重要,黑人和西班牙裔参与者质疑计算器将种族和民族作为风险因素。
要点
- 预测VBAC成功率范围为12%至95%。
- 识别出四种患者主导的概率解读方式。
- 黑人和西班牙裔参与者质疑计算器纳入种族和民族因素。
核心结论
- 数字概率可能并非对所有患者都高度重要,尤其是对VBAC有强烈意愿者。
- 黑人和西班牙裔参与者质疑计算器将种族和民族作为风险因素,并抵制其暗示其身体更难实现阴道分娩的含义。
- 患者主导的评估和解读VBAC概率的方式可能是实现更以人为本、公平咨询的未开发资源。
研究设计与样本
- 邀请有剖宫产史的多元参与者接受访谈并记录产前检查,使用开放式迭代访谈指南,采用批判性和女性主义方法分析主题数据。
- 共31名参与者入组,完成64次访谈,记录14次产前检查。
主要发现
- 参与者自我认同的种族和族裔类别包括:亚裔或南亚裔(2人)、黑人(4人)、西班牙裔(12人)、原住民(1人)、白人(8人)、混血黑人、西班牙裔或亚裔背景(4人)。
- 预测VBAC成功概率范围为12%至95%。
- 识别出四个主题:拒绝种族和民族的作用;重新定义失败并发现成功;考虑分娩的身体体验;调整VBAC概率。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe patient approaches to navigating their probability of a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) within the context of prediction scores generated from the original Maternal-Fetal Medicine Units' VBAC calculator, which incorporated race and ethnicity as one of six risk factors. METHODS: We invited a diverse group of participants with a history of prior cesarean delivery to participate in interviews and have their prenatal visits recorded. Using an open-ended iterative interview guide, we queried and observed these individuals' mode-of-birth decisions in the context of their VBAC calculator scores. We used a critical and feminist approach to analyze thematic data gleaned from interview and visit transcripts. RESULTS: Among the 31 participants who enrolled, their self-identified racial and ethnic categories included: Asian or South Asian (2); Black (4); Hispanic (12); Indigenous (1); White (8); and mixed-Black, -Hispanic, or -Asian background (4). Predicted VBAC success probabilities ranged from 12% to 95%. Participants completed 64 interviews, and 14 prenatal visits were recorded. We identified four themes that demonstrated a range of patient-led approaches to interpreting the probability generated by the VBAC calculator: 1) rejecting the role of race and ethnicity; 2) reframing failure, finding success; 3) factoring the physical experience of labor; and 4) modifying the probability for VBAC. CONCLUSION: Our findings demonstrate that a numeric probability for VBAC may not be highly valued or important to all patients, especially those who have strong intentions for VBAC. Black and Hispanic participants challenged the VBAC calculator's incorporation of race and ethnicity as a risk factor and resisted the implication it produced, especially that their bodies were less capable of achieving a vaginal birth. Our findings suggest that patient-led approaches to assessing and interpreting VBAC probability may be an untapped resource for achieving a more person-centered, equitable approach to counseling.
引用
- Rubashkin N, Asiodu I, Vedam S, et al. Patient-Led Approaches to a Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Delivery Calculator. Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37734092. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000005323
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。