不同生长曲线对出生体重预测的影响:产科超声与磁共振成像的比较
本研究基于前瞻性、单中心、盲法队列研究数据再分析,比较磁共振成像与超声在36+0/7至36+6/7周预测出生体重≥95百分位的表现,使用INTERGROWTH-21st、世界卫生组织和胎儿医学基金会三种生长曲线。共2378名孕妇纳入最终分析。磁共振成像预测大于胎龄儿的敏感性显著高于超声,但特异性略低;预测小于胎龄儿时敏感性显著低于超声,而特异性和阳性预测值显著更高。
要点
- 磁共振成像预测出生体重>95百分位的敏感性在三种生长曲线下均显著高于超声,但特异性略低。
- 磁共振成像预测出生体重<10百分位的敏感性在INTERGROWTH-21st和胎儿医学基金会曲线下显著低于超声。
- 磁共振成像预测出生体重<10百分位的特异性和阳性预测值在三种曲线下均显著高于超声。
核心结论
- 在三种生长曲线下,磁共振成像预测大于胎龄儿的敏感性优于超声,预测小于胎龄儿的敏感性劣于超声;特异性则相反。
研究设计与样本
- 数据来自前瞻性、单中心、盲法队列研究的再分析,比较磁共振成像与超声在36+0/7至36+6/7周预测出生体重≥95百分位的表现。
- 共2378名孕妇纳入最终分析,超声和磁共振成像检查的中位孕周为36+3/7周,分娩中位孕周为39+3/7周,中位出生体重为3380克。
主要发现
- 出生体重<5th和<10th百分位的发生率在胎儿医学基金会曲线最高、INTERGROWTH-21st曲线最低;>90th和>95th百分位的发生率在胎儿医学基金会曲线最低、INTERGROWTH-21st曲线最高。
- 磁共振成像预测出生体重>95th百分位的敏感性在三种生长曲线下均显著高于超声,但特异性略低于超声。
- 磁共振成像预测出生体重<10th百分位的敏感性在INTERGROWTH-21st和胎儿医学基金会曲线下显著低于超声,而特异性和阳性预测值在三种曲线下均显著高于超声。
- 预测出生体重>90th百分位的结果与>95th百分位相近,预测<5th百分位的结果与<10th百分位相近。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The estimation of fetal weight by fetal magnetic resonance imaging is a simple and rapid method with a high sensitivity in predicting birthweight in comparison with ultrasound. Several national and international growth charts are currently in use, but there is substantial heterogeneity among these charts due to variations in the selected populations from which they were derived, in methodologies, and in statistical analysis of data. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to compare the performance of magnetic resonance imaging and ultrasound for the prediction of birthweight using 3 commonly used fetal growth charts: the INTERGROWTH-21st Project, World Health Organization, and Fetal Medicine Foundation charts. STUDY DESIGN: Data derived from a prospective, single-center, blinded cohort study that compared the performance of magnetic resonance imaging and ultrasound between 36+0/7 and 36+6/7 weeks of gestation for the prediction of birthweight ≥95th percentile were reanalyzed. Estimated fetal weight was categorized as above or below the 5th, 10th, 90th, and 95th percentile according to the 3 growth charts. Birthweight was similarly categorized according to the birthweight standards of each chart. The performances of ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging for the prediction of birthweight <5th, <10th, >90th, and >95th percentile using the different growth charts were compared. Data were analyzed with R software, version 4.1.2. The comparison of sensitivity and specificity was done using McNemar and exact binomial tests. P values <.05 were considered statistically significant. RESULTS: A total of 2378 women were eligible for final analysis. Ultrasound and magnetic resonance imaging were performed at a median gestational age of 36+3/7 weeks, delivery occurred at a median gestational age of 39+3/7 weeks, and median birthweight was 3380 g. The incidences of birthweight <5th and <10th percentiles were highest with the Fetal Medicine Foundation chart and lowest with the INTERGROWTH-21st chart, whereas the incidences of birthweight >90th and >95th percentiles were lowest with the Fetal Medicine Foundation chart and highest with the INTERGROWTH-21st chart. The sensitivity of magnetic resonance imaging with an estimated fetal weight >95th percentile in the prediction of birthweight >95th percentile was significantly higher than that of ultrasound across the 3 growth charts; however, its specificity was slightly lower than that of ultrasound. In contrast, the sensitivity of magnetic resonance imaging with an estimated fetal weight <10th percentile for predicting birthweight <10th percentile was significantly lower than that of ultrasound in the INTERGROWTH-21st and Fetal Medicine Foundation charts, whereas the specificity and positive predictive value of magnetic resonance imaging were significantly higher than those of ultrasound for all 3 charts. Findings for the prediction of birthweight >90th percentile were close to those of birthweight >95th percentile, and findings for the prediction of birthweight <5th percentile were close to those of birthweight <10th percentile. CONCLUSION: The sensitivity of magnetic resonance imaging is superior to that of ultrasound for the prediction of large for gestational age fetuses and inferior to that of ultrasound for the prediction of small for gestational age fetuses across the 3 different growth charts. The reverse is true for the specificity of magnetic resonance imaging in comparison with that of ultrasound.
引用
- Badr DA, Cannie MM, Kadji C, et al. The impact of different growth charts on birthweight prediction: obstetrical ultrasound vs magnetic resonance imaging. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2023. PMID: 37574047. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2023.101123
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。