爱尔兰胎儿异常诊断与终止妊娠:2019年堕胎服务实施后的服务评估
该回顾性服务评估分析了2019至2021年间两家三级妇幼医院胎儿医学科中139例重大胎儿异常妊娠,其中83例(59.7%)在本地终止妊娠,56例(40.3%)因不符合法律标准而前往国外(主要为英国)终止妊娠。本地终止妊娠最常见的指征为18三体(30.1%),而旅行的主要原因为21三体(53.6%)。作者认为仅限于致死性诊断的立法难以实施,需多学科投入,并可能限制重大胎儿异常妊娠的服务。
要点
- 139例重大胎儿异常妊娠中,59.7%在爱尔兰本地终止,40.3%前往国外终止。
- 本地终止妊娠均经胎儿医学多学科会议讨论,而旅行组仅34%经讨论。
- 本地终止最常见指征为18三体(30.1%),旅行组主要为21三体(53.6%)。
核心结论
- 仅限于致死性诊断的终止妊娠立法难以实施,需要大量多学科投入,并可能导致重大胎儿异常妊娠的服务受限。
- 研究结果强调立法障碍对胎儿异常堕胎护理的影响,以及需要支持女性获得胎儿异常终止妊娠的政策和服务。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性服务评估,纳入2019年至2021年间两家三级妇幼医院胎儿医学科诊所的妊娠。
- 共139例妊娠符合纳入标准,比较在爱尔兰本地终止妊娠与因不符合法律标准而前往国外终止妊娠的两组患者。
主要发现
- 83例(59.7%)在三级妇幼医院本地终止妊娠,56例(40.3%)前往国外(主要英国)终止妊娠。
- 两组人口学特征、诊断时孕周和分娩时孕周相似。
- 本地终止妊娠病例全部经胎儿医学多学科会议讨论,而旅行组仅34%经讨论。
- 本地终止妊娠最常见指征为18三体(25/83;30.1%),其次为无脑畸形。
- 旅行终止妊娠主要原因为21三体(30/56;53.6%),其次为其他多重结构异常/综合征(本地认为不符合法律标准)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Approximately 3% of pregnancies are diagnosed with a fetal anomaly, of which a proportion is fatal or life-limiting. The introduction of legislation for termination of pregnancy in Ireland in 2019 for conditions "likely to lead to the death of the fetus" made termination of pregnancy for "fatal fetal anomaly" an option for pregnant women in Ireland. OBJECTIVE: This study examined all cases of termination of pregnancy performed for major fetal anomaly over the first 3 years of service implementation, including cases that did not meet the legal criteria, resulting in women traveling outside Ireland for abortion care. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective service evaluation of tertiary fetal medicine clinics in 2 tertiary maternity hospitals between 2019 and 2021 was undertaken. We compared pregnancies of patients diagnosed with fatal fetal anomaly who underwent termination of pregnancy in Ireland with those of patients who did not meet the legal criteria and hence traveled outside Ireland for termination of pregnancy. RESULTS: Overall, 139 pregnancies met the inclusion criteria; 83 (59.7%) patients had termination of pregnancy in the tertiary maternity hospital (local), and 56 (40.3%) traveled abroad, mainly to the United Kingdom. Demographic characteristics were similar between the 2 groups, as was gestation at diagnosis and delivery. All cases where termination of pregnancy was local were discussed at fetal medicine multidisciplinary meetings, as opposed to 34% of cases of patients who ultimately traveled outside Ireland for termination of pregnancy. The most common indication (25/83; 30.1%) for local termination of pregnancy was trisomy 18, followed by anencephaly. Traveling to obtain abortion care was mainly due to diagnosis of trisomy 21 (30/56; 53.6%), followed by other multiple structural anomalies/syndromes deemed locally as not meeting the legal criteria. CONCLUSION: Legislation for termination of pregnancy for fetal anomaly, restricted to fatal diagnoses, is difficult to implement, requires significant multidisciplinary input, and can lead to limited services for pregnancies diagnosed with major fetal anomalies. Our findings emphasize the impact of legislative barriers to abortion care for fetal anomaly and the need for policies and services that support women's access to termination of pregnancy for fetal anomaly.
引用
- Miremberg H, Oduola O, Morrison JJ, et al. Fetal anomaly diagnosis and termination of pregnancy in Ireland: a service evaluation following implementation of abortion services in 2019. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2023. PMID: 37532025. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2023.101111
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。