早期和晚期双胎输血综合征管理的共识方案:德尔菲研究
本研究通过四轮德尔菲法在国际专家小组中构建早期(16周前及16-18周)和晚期(26周后)双胎输血综合征(TTTS)管理的结构化专家共识。共邀请122名专家,53名(43.4%)参与,其中75.5%完成全部四轮。共识认为,选择性病例最早可在15周行胎儿镜激光光凝术(FLP),可考虑至28周;16-18周的管理应根据多普勒发现个体化。
要点
- 选择性病例最早可在妊娠15周提供FLP,可考虑至28周。
- 妊娠16-18周之间,管理应根据多普勒发现个体化。
- 该共识方案应由操作者根据其经验和具体病例需求酌情修改。
核心结论
- 专家小组就早期和晚期TTTS的共识治疗方案达成一致。
- 该方案应由操作者根据其经验和具体病例需求酌情修改。
- 该方案应提升未来研究质量、指导临床实践并改善患者照护。
研究设计与样本
- 德尔菲研究:在国际专家小组中进行四轮在线匿名调查。
- 共邀请122名符合纳入标准的专家,53名(43.4%)同意参与,其中75.5%完成全部四轮。
- 第一轮由核心专家组回答关于早期和晚期TTTS适应证、时机和治疗方式的开放式问题。
- 第二、三轮参与者对每条陈述按Likert量表(1分完全不同意;5分完全同意)评分并提出建议或修改。
- 中位评分为5分且无修改建议的陈述被接受为共识;中位评分≤3分的陈述从德尔菲过程中剔除;中位评分为4分的陈述根据建议修改后在下一轮重新考虑。
主要发现
- 就早期和晚期TTTS的最佳管理达成了共识。
- 选择性病例最早可在妊娠15周提供FLP,可考虑至28周。
- 妊娠16-18周之间,管理应根据多普勒发现个体化。
关键数值与推荐
- FLP可最早在妊娠15周为选择性病例提供,可考虑至28周。
- 妊娠16-18周之间,管理应根据多普勒发现个体化。
- 共识定义:中位评分5分且无修改建议,或最后一轮同意率>70%且无修改建议。
临床怎么用
- 该共识方案应由操作者根据其经验和具体病例需求酌情修改。
- 该方案应指导临床实践并改善患者照护。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Fetoscopic laser photocoagulation (FLP) is a well-established treatment for twin-twin transfusion syndrome (TTTS) between 16 and 26 weeks' gestation. High-quality evidence and guidelines regarding the optimal clinical management of very early (prior to 16 weeks), early (between 16 and 18 weeks) and late (after 26 weeks) TTTS are lacking. The aim of this study was to construct a structured expert-based clinical consensus for the management of early and late TTTS. METHODS: A Delphi procedure was conducted among an international panel of experts. Participants were chosen based on their clinical expertise, affiliation and relevant publications. A four-round Delphi survey was conducted using an online platform and responses were collected anonymously. In the first round, a core group of experts was asked to answer open-ended questions regarding the indications, timing and modes of treatment for early and late TTTS. In the second and third rounds, participants were asked to grade each statement on a Likert scale (1, completely disagree; 5, completely agree) and to add any suggestions or modifications. At the end of each round, the median score for each statement was calculated. Statements with a median grade of 5 without suggestions for change were accepted as the consensus. Statements with a median grade of 3 or less were excluded from the Delphi process. Statements with a median grade of 4 were modified according to suggestions and reconsidered in the next round. In the last round, participants were asked to agree or disagree with the statements, and those with more than 70% agreement without suggestions for change were considered the consensus. RESULTS: A total of 122 experts met the inclusion criteria and were invited to participate, of whom 53 (43.4%) agreed to take part in the study. Of those, 75.5% completed all four rounds. A consensus on the optimal management of early and late TTTS was obtained. FLP can be offered as early as 15 weeks' gestation for selected cases, and can be considered up to 28 weeks. Between 16 and 18 weeks, management should be tailored according to Doppler findings. CONCLUSIONS: A consensus-based treatment protocol for early and late TTTS was agreed upon by a panel of experts. This protocol should be modified at the discretion of the operator, according to their experience and the specific demands of each case. This should advance the quality of future studies, guide clinical practice and improve patient care. © 2023 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Krispin E, Javinani A, Odibo A, et al. Consensus protocol for management of early and late twin-twin transfusion syndrome: Delphi study. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2024. PMID: 37553800. doi:10.1002/uog.27446
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。