文献速递生殖医学

丢弃还是不丢弃,这是一个问题:一项针对117名胚胎学家关于临界质量囊胚临床管理的国际调查

Discard or not discard, that is the question: an international survey across 117 embryologists on the clinical management of borderline quality blastocysts.
PubMed 文献 · Hum Reprod · 2023-01-01

该匿名调查覆盖6个欧洲国家29家IVF中心的117名胚胎学家,评估50个第7天和/或低质量囊胚的处置决策。丢弃决策占38.7%,胚胎学家间一致性仅为一般(Fleiss-k=0.26),仅国家和IVF中心分组与丢弃率相关。

要点

  • 胚胎学家对第7天和/或低质量囊胚的丢弃决策占38.7%。
  • 胚胎学家间一致性仅为一般(Fleiss-k=0.26)。
  • 仅胚胎学家所在国家和IVF中心分组与丢弃率相关。

核心结论

  • 欧洲胚胎学家对第7天胚胎或低质量囊胚的决策不一致,可能带来临床后果,尤其对低预后患者。

研究设计与样本

  • 匿名调查在大型IVF中心网络开展,共117名来自6个欧洲国家29家IVF中心的胚胎学家参与。
  • 胚胎学家随机评估50个第7天和/或低质量囊胚的匿名延时视频,所有周期均行胚胎植入前非整倍体检测。

主要发现

  • 共记录2263(38.7%)次丢弃决策和3587(61.3%)次使用决策,每名胚胎学家丢弃率均值±标准差为39±23%(范围2-90%)。
  • 捷克、葡萄牙和意大利胚胎学家丢弃决策率较低(均值±标准差分别为17±7%、23±14%、27±18%),西班牙居中(37±16%),北欧较高(67±11%)。
  • 胚胎学家间总体一致性为一般(Fleiss-k=0.26)。
  • 每个胚胎的丢弃回答率为37±24%(范围2-87%),仅同胞囊胚数量影响该率。
  • 整倍体与非整倍体临界质量囊胚在两个评分上无差异,但胚胎学家偶然更倾向于丢弃非整倍体囊胚(28.3±21% vs 41.6±24.8%)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文未据此给出推荐。

局限性

  • 调查仅纳入位于欧洲的私立IVF诊所。
  • 关键变量患者就医可及性缺失。
  • 所有参与胚胎学家均属于同一私立IVF诊所网络,公立机构中的胚胎处置决策可能不同。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY QUESTION: Do embryologists from different European countries agree on embryo disposition decisions ('use' or 'discard') about Day 7 (>144 h post-insemination) and/or low-quality blastocysts (LQB; <Gardner's BB) (i.e. borderline quality blastocysts)? SUMMARY ANSWER: The prevalence of 'discard' answers was 38.7%; nevertheless, embryologists' agreement was overall just fair (Fleiss-k = 0.26). WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: The utilization of LQBs and adoption of culture beyond 144 h post-insemination is increasing worldwide. Although morphology and morphokinetics are associated with embryo developmental competence, previous studies demonstrated significant interobserver variability among embryologists regarding embryo quality assessment and disposition decisions for borderline quality blastocysts. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: An anonymous survey was run in a large network of IVF centers. A total of 117 embryologists from 6 European countries and 29 IVF centers filled in the survey. Randomly selected anonymous time-lapse videos of 50 Day 7 and/or LQB whole embryo preimplantation development were assessed by the embryologists. The key information on patients/cycles was provided along with each video. All cycles entailed preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidies. Each embryologist specified whether he/she would have discarded or used ('transfer-fresh'/'cryopreserve'/'biopsy') any embryo. Inter-rater agreement was measured with Fleiss-k. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Examiners were asked about their years of experience, center location, average number of cycles and average maternal age, number of colleagues, and use of time-lapse incubators at their centers. All participants were blinded to artificial intelligence (AI) scores generated by two commercially available software packages, chromosomal diagnosis (all blastocysts were tested for aneuploidies), and clinical outcomes after vitrified-warmed euploid single blastocyst transfer. These data were known only by one embryologist not involved in the survey. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Participants were Italian (40%, N = 47), Spanish (24%, N = 28), Portuguese (5%, N = 6), Czech (5%, N = 6), Swedish (23%, N = 27), and Icelandic (3%, N = 3). In total, 2263 (38.7%) 'discard' and 3587 (61.3%) 'use' decisions were recorded. Czech, Portuguese, and Italian embryologists expressed lower 'discard' decision rates (mean ± SD 17 ± 7%, range 8-24%; 23 ± 14% range 4-46%; and 27 ± 18% range 2-72%, respectively), while Spanish gave intermediate (37 ± 16% range 4-66%) and Nordic gave higher (67 ± 11% range 40-90%) rates. The prevalence of 'discard' answers was 38.7% out of 5850 choices (mean per embryologist: 39 ± 23% range 2-90%). Only embryologists' country and IVF group were associated with this rate. Overall agreement among embryologists was fair (Fleiss-k = 0.26). The prevalence of 'discard' responses per embryo was 37 ± 24% (range 2-87%). Only the number of sibling blastocysts influenced this rate (i.e. the larger the cohort, the higher the inclination to 'discard'). No difference was shown for the two scores between euploid and aneuploid borderline quality blastocysts, while the embryologists were, by chance, more prone to 'discard' the latter (28.3 ± 21% range 9-71% versus 41.6 ± 24.8% range 2-87%, respectively). LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The survey included only private IVF clinics located in Europe. Moreover, a key variable is missing, namely patients' access to care. Indeed, all embryologists involved in the survey were part of the same network of private IVF clinics, while the embryo disposition decisions might be different in a public setting. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Decision-making by European embryologists regarding Day 7 embryos or LQBs is inconsistent with putative clinical consequences, especially in patients with low prognosis. Although the embryologists could make decisions independent from their local regulations, their mindset and clinical background influenced their choices. In the future, AI tools should be trained to assess borderline quality embryos and empowered with cost-effectiveness information to support embryologists' decisions with more objective assessments. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): No external funding was obtained for this study. The authors have no conflict of interest to declare. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.

来源:Hum Reprod,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chiappetta V, Innocenti F, Coticchio G, et al. Discard or not discard, that is the question: an international survey across 117 embryologists on the clinical management of borderline quality blastocysts. Hum Reprod. 2023. PMID: 37649342. doi:10.1093/humrep/dead174

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。