卵泡冲洗增加获卵数:一项随机对照试验
这项前瞻性单中心随机对照试验纳入105例ICSI取卵患者,将每例患者的卵巢随机分配至卵泡冲洗或单次抽吸。卵泡冲洗组获卵数显著多于单次抽吸组,取卵率也显著更高,但取卵时间显著延长,而卵母细胞成熟率、受精率和第2天优质胚胎率无显著差异。
要点
- 卵泡冲洗组获卵数中位数显著高于单次抽吸组(5 vs 2,P<0.001)。
- 卵泡冲洗组取卵率显著高于单次抽吸组(88.9% vs 45.5%,P<0.001)。
- 两组间成熟率、受精率及第2天优质胚胎率无显著差异。
核心结论
- 卵泡冲洗较单次抽吸显著增加获卵数,且不依赖于卵巢反应类型。
- 这是首个提示卵泡冲洗增加获卵数的随机对照试验,但结果需在未来研究中使用相同流速的条件下确认。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性单中心随机对照试验,2022年7月至12月纳入105例因ICSI行取卵的患者,年龄<43岁,BMI 18-35 kg/m2,涵盖低、正常、高所有卵巢反应类型。
- 取卵日将每例患者的卵巢随机分配至单次抽吸或卵泡冲洗,使用计算机生成的随机化列表,患者仅能入组一次。
- 所有卵泡均使用同一16G双腔针抽吸,抽吸压力恒定190 mmHg,流速0.42 ml/s;冲洗组若初始抽吸未获卵丘-卵母细胞复合体(COC),则冲洗至获卵,最多5次。
主要发现
- 所有患者中,卵泡冲洗组获卵数中位数显著多于单次抽吸组[5(7)vs 2(3),P<0.001];高反应组[9(3)vs 5(4),P<0.001]、正常反应组[5(2)vs 2(3),P<0.001]和低反应组[1(1)vs 1(1),P<0.001]均显著更多。
- 低反应患者中,冲洗组5.7%的卵巢未获卵,单次抽吸组为42.8%(P<0.001)。
- 所有患者中,卵泡冲洗组取卵率显著高于单次抽吸组[88.9%(25.0)vs 45.5%(37.5),P<0.001];高反应组[81.8%(15.9)vs 45.5%(22.2),P<0.001]、正常反应组[85.7%(28.6)vs 40.0%(30.0),P<0.001]和低反应组[100%(0)vs 50.0%(100),P<0.001]均显著更高。
- 成熟率[85.2%(30.8)vs 100%(33.3),P=0.78]、受精率[76.4%(50)vs 83.3%(50),P=0.42]及第2天优质胚胎比例[83.3%(40)vs 100%(50),P=0.62]两组间无显著差异;不同卵巢反应类型患者中上述变量亦无差异。
- 所有患者中,卵泡冲洗组取卵时间显著长于单次抽吸组[248 s(332)vs 135 s(164)];高反应组[464 s(225)vs 237 s(89),P<0.001]、正常反应组[248 s(108)vs 141 s(95),P<0.001]和低反应组[64 s(59)vs 48 s(10),P<0.001]均显著延长。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为卵泡冲洗在优化取卵中起重要作用。
- 作者指出这些结果需在未来研究中使用相同流速的条件下确认。
局限性
- 研究设计虽能更准确评估卵泡冲洗对获卵数的真实效应,但无法评估其对妊娠概率的作用。
- 结果需在未来研究中使用相同流速的条件下确认。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Does follicular flushing increase the number of cumulus-oocyte complexes (COCs) retrieved compared to single aspiration? SUMMARY ANSWER: Follicular flushing significantly increases the number of COCs retrieved compared to single aspiration. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: On the basis of published meta-analyses, follicular flushing does not seem to increase the number of oocytes retrieved, the probability of clinical pregnancy, or that of live birth and has been associated with an increase in the duration of oocyte retrieval. It should be noted, however, that all the eligible randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in these meta-analyses have randomized patients into either single aspiration or follicular flushing. This study design might not allow the detection of the true effect of follicular flushing. Despite randomization, this might still be obscured, to an extent, by heterogeneity in patients, stimulation characteristics, and differences in the oocyte retrieval procedure. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: A prospective, single centre, RCT, including 105 patients was performed between July and December 2022. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Eligible patients were those undergoing oocyte retrieval for ICSI, aged <43 years, with BMI 18-35 kg/m2. Patients with all types of ovarian response (low-normal-high), as assessed on the day of triggering final oocyte maturation, were included. Random allocation of the ovaries of each patient to either single aspiration or follicular flushing was performed on the day of oocyte retrieval, using a computer-generated randomization list. Patients could enter the study only once. All follicles from ovaries allocated to either follicular flushing or single aspiration, were aspirated by the same 16G double lumen needle, with a constant aspiration pressure of 190 mmHg, resulting in flow rate of 0.42 ml/s. In the ovaries allocated to the follicular flushing group, if a COC was not recovered in the initial aspirate of each follicle, follicular flushing was performed until a COC was retrieved, up to a maximum of five times. The primary outcome measure was the number of COCs retrieved. Secondary outcomes were oocyte recovery rate, oocyte maturation rate, fertilization rate, and rate of good quality embryos on Day 2. Values are expressed as a median (inter-quartile range). MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Significantly more COCs were retrieved in the follicular flushing as compared to the single aspiration group in all patients [5 (7) vs 2 (3), P < 0.001, respectively], as well as in patients with high [9 (3) vs 5 (4), P < 0.001, respectively], normal [5 (2) vs 2 (3), P < 0.001, respectively] and low [1 (1) vs 1 (1), P < 0.001, respectively] ovarian response. In patients with low ovarian response, no COCs were retrieved in 5.7% of the ovaries in the flushing group vs 42.8% of the ovaries in the single aspiration group (P < 0.001). The oocyte retrieval rate was significantly higher in the follicular flushing vs the single aspiration group, in all patients [88.9% (25.0) vs 45.5% (37.5), P < 0.001, respectively], as well as in patients with high [81.8% (15.9) vs 45.5% (22.2), P < 0.001, respectively], normal [85.7% (28.6) vs 40.0% (30.0), P < 0.001, respectively], and low [100% (0) vs 50.0% (100), P < 0.001, respectively] ovarian response. No significant difference was observed regarding maturation rate [85.2% (30.8) vs 100% (33.3), P = 0.78], fertilization rate [76.4% (50) vs 83.3% (50) P = 0.42], and the proportion of good quality embryos on Day 2 [83.3% (40) vs 100% (50), P = 0.62]. Similarly, no differences in the above variables were observed in patients with different types of ovarian response. Follicular flushing as compared to single aspiration was associated with a significant increase in the duration of oocyte retrieval in all patients [248 s (332) vs 135 s (164), respectively], as well as in patients with high [464 s (225) vs 237 s (89), P < 0.001, respectively], normal [248 s (108) vs 141 s (95), P < 0.001, respectively], and low [64 s (59) vs 48 s (10), P < 0.001, respectively] ovarian response. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: Although the current study design allows for a more accurate evaluation of the true effect of follicular flushing on the number of COCs retrieved, it does not permit the evaluation of its role on the probability of pregnancy. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: This is the first RCT to suggest that follicular flushing increases the number of COCs retrieved compared to single aspiration, independently of ovarian response. This implies that follicular flushing plays an important role in the optimization of oocyte retrieval. These results, however, need to be confirmed in future studies, in which an equal flow rate should be used during oocyte retrieval. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): No external funding was obtained for this study. There are no conflicts of interest to declare. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: NCT05473455. TRIAL REGISTRATION DATE: 15 July 2022. DATE OF FIRST PATIENT’S ENROLMENT: 27 July 2022.
引用
- Lainas GT, Lainas TG, Makris AA, et al. Follicular flushing increases the number of oocytes retrieved: a randomized controlled trial. Hum Reprod. 2023. PMID: 37632249. doi:10.1093/humrep/dead169
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。