文献速递产科

低风险初产妇剖宫产率种族差异的医院层面变异

Hospital-level variation in racial disparities in low-risk nulliparous cesarean delivery rates.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM · 2023-08-28

基于加利福尼亚州2018至2020年1,267,493例活产的横断面研究,分析不同种族/民族初产妇剖宫产率的医院间差异。黑人患者剖宫产率(28.4%)显著高于其他种族且医院间变异更大;比较黑人患者剖宫产率低于与高于23.9%目标的医院,两组设施或患者特征无显著差异。

要点

  • 黑人初产妇剖宫产率为28.4%,显著高于其他种族/民族组,且医院间标准差(7.1)和四分位距(6.5)更大(P<.01)。
  • 黑人患者剖宫产率低的医院组(29家)率为19.9%,高率组(106家)为30.7%,两组设施和患者特征无显著差异。
  • 在未达黑人患者23.9%目标的106家医院中,63家白人患者平均剖宫产率为21.4%,同一医院黑人患者平均为29.5%。

核心结论

  • 黑人患者全州剖宫产率显著更高,且医院间变异明显大于其他种族或民族组。
  • 黑人患者剖宫产率低与高的医院之间设施或患者特征无差异,提示无意识偏见和结构性种族主义可能起重要作用。

研究设计与样本

  • 基于加利福尼亚州2018年至2020年1,267,493例活产的群体横断面研究,使用出生证明数据链接母亲出院记录。
  • 计算全州及各医院年度初产妇足月单胎头位剖宫产率,并按出生证明自我报告的种族/民族分类。
  • 使用对数二项模型估计各 races/ethnic 组2019年较2015年初产妇剖宫产相对危险度及95%置信区间。
  • 比较黑人患者初产妇剖宫产率<23.9%的医院与≥23.9%的医院的设施和患者特征。

主要发现

  • 黑人患者初产妇剖宫产率为28.4%,标准差7.1,四分位距6.5,显著高于其他种族组(P<.01)。
  • 黑人患者低剖宫产率组(29家医院)率为19.9%,高率组(106家医院)为30.7%。
  • 两组在医院特征(所有权、分娩量、新生儿护理级别、助产士分娩比例)和患者特征(年龄、教育、保险、产前保健启动、体重指数、高血压、糖尿病)上无显著差异。
  • 在106家未达黑人患者目标的医院中,63家达白人患者目标,白人患者平均率21.4%,黑人患者平均率29.5%。
  • 未达23.9%目标组的黑人患者中,所有剖宫产指征(产程异常、胎儿担忧(自然临产)、无产程(如巨大儿))率均显著更高。

关键数值与推荐

  • 黑人患者初产妇剖宫产率低率组为19.9%,高率组为30.7%。
  • 未达黑人患者目标的106家医院中,63家白人患者平均剖宫产率为21.4%,黑人患者平均为29.5%。
  • 黑人患者初产妇剖宫产率28.4%,标准差7.1,四分位距6.5(P<.01)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Nationally, rates of cesarean delivery are highest among Black patients compared with other racial/ethnic groups. These observed inequities are a relatively new phenomenon (in the 1980s, cesarean delivery rates among Black patients were lower than average), indicating an opportunity to narrow the gap. Cesarean delivery rates vary greatly among hospitals, masking racial disparities that are unseen when rates are reported in aggregate. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to explore reasons for the current large Black-White disparity in first-birth cesarean delivery rates by first examining the hospital-level variation in first-birth cesarean delivery rates among different racial/ethnic groups. We then identified hospitals that had low first-birth cesarean delivery rates among Black patients and compared them with hospitals with high rates. We sought to identify differences in facility or patient characteristics that could explain the racial disparity. STUDY DESIGN: A population cross-sectional study was performed on 1,267,493 California live births from 2018 through 2020 using birth certificate data linked with maternal patient discharge records. Annual nulliparous term singleton vertex cesarean delivery (first-birth) rates were calculated for the most common racial/ethnic groups statewide and for each hospital. Self-identified race/ethnicity categories as selected on the birth certificate were used. Relative risk and 95% confidence intervals for first-birth cesarean delivery comparing 2019 with 2015 were estimated using a log-binomial model for each racial/ethnic group. Patient and hospital characteristics were compared between hospitals with first-birth cesarean delivery rates <23.9% for Black patients and hospitals with rates ≥23.9% for Black patients. RESULTS: Hospitals with at least 30 nulliparous term singleton vertex Asian, Black, Hispanic, and White patients each were identified. Black patients had a very different distribution, with a significantly higher rate (28.4%) and wider standard deviation (7.1) and interquartile range (6.5) than other racial groups (P<.01). A total of 29 hospitals with a low first-birth cesarean delivery rate among Black patients were identified using the Healthy People 2020 target of 23.9% and compared with 106 hospitals with higher rates. The low-rate group had a cesarean delivery rate of 19.9%, as opposed to 30.7% in the higher-rate group. There were no significant differences between the groups in hospital characteristics (ownership, delivery volume, neonatal level of care, proportion of midwife deliveries) or patient characteristics (age, education, insurance, onset of prenatal care, body mass index, hypertension, diabetes mellitus). Among the 106 hospitals that did not meet the target for Black patients, 63 met it for White patients with a mean rate of 21.4%. In the same hospitals, the mean rate for Black patients was 29.5%. Among Black patients in the group that did not meet the 23.9% target, there were significantly higher rates of all cesarean delivery indications: labor dystocia, fetal concern (spontaneous labor), and no labor (eg, macrosomia), which are all indications with a high degree of subjectivity. CONCLUSION: The statewide cesarean delivery rate of Black patients is significantly higher and has substantially greater hospital variation compared with other racial or ethnic groups. The lack of difference in facility or patient characteristics between hospitals with low cesarean delivery rates among Black patients and those with high rates suggests that unconscious bias and structural racism potentially play important roles in creating these racial differences.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Main EK, Chang SC, Tucker CM, et al. Hospital-level variation in racial disparities in low-risk nulliparous cesarean delivery rates. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2023. PMID: 37648109. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2023.101145

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。