TOTAL试验结果是否改变了母胎医学专家的态度与实践
该横断面调查在第19届世界胎儿医学大会的105名参会者中,探讨TOTAL试验后母胎医学专家对胎儿镜下腔内气管封堵术(FETO)治疗左侧和右侧先天性膈疝(LCDH、RCDH)的观点与实践。82%的受访者同意产前可可靠预测LCDH的新生儿存活;多数受访者为严重LCDH(97%)和RCDH(79%)提供FETO,但仅59%为中度LCDH提供。结论认为受访者对严重LCDH的FETO风险获益比明确且一致提供,但对中度LCDH和严重RCDH则不然,然而不向父母提供FETO选项被视为心理负担。
要点
- 82%的受访者同意产前可可靠预测LCDH的新生儿存活。
- 97%为严重LCDH、79%为严重RCDH提供FETO,仅59%为中度LCDH提供。
- 58%的受访者认为不为中度LCDH提供FETO会是父母的心理负担。
核心结论
- 受访者认为严重LCDH的FETO风险获益比明确并一致提供FETO,但对中度LCDH和严重RCDH则不然。
- 不向父母提供FETO选项被视为心理负担。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面知识、态度与实践调查,对象为第19届世界胎儿医学大会的105名参会者。
主要发现
- 82%的受访者同意产前可可靠预测LCDH的新生儿存活。
- 认为FETO对严重LCDH的 exact 风险与获益不明确的受访者较少(16%),但对中度LCDH(57%)和严重RCDH(45%)约半数不确定。
- 多数受访者为严重LCDH(97%)和RCDH(79%)提供FETO,但仅59%为中度LCDH提供。
- 58%的受访者表示不为中度LCDH提供FETO会是父母的心理负担。
关键数值与推荐
- 82%同意产前可可靠预测LCDH的新生儿存活。
- 16%认为FETO对严重LCDH的 exact 风险与获益不明确,57%对中度LCDH不确定,45%对严重RCDH不确定。
- 97%为严重LCDH提供FETO,79%为RCDH提供,59%为中度LCDH提供。
- 58%认为不为中度LCDH提供FETO是父母的心理负担。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To explore the views and practices of maternal-fetal medicine specialists on offering fetoscopic endoluminal tracheal occlusion (FETO) for left- and right-sided congenital diaphragmatic hernia (LCDH, RCDH) in the post Tracheal Occlusion To Accelerate Lung growth (TOTAL)-trial era. METHOD: Cross-sectional knowledge, attitude and practice survey was conducted among 105 attendees of the 19th World Congress of Fetal Medicine. RESULTS: On average, respondents were knowledgeable about CDH, involved in research, and provided antenatal treatment options. Four out of five (82%) agreed that neonatal survival in LCDH can be reliably predicted in the prenatal period. Few respondents considered the exact risks and benefits of FETO for severe LCDH as being unclear (16%), yet half were uncertain about this for moderate LCDH (57%) and severe RCDH (45%). Most respondents offer FETO for severe LCDH (97%) and RCDH (79%), but only 59% offer it for moderate LCDH. However, half of respondents (58%) stated that not offering FETO for moderate LCDH would be a psychological burden for parents. CONCLUSION: Respondents consider the risk-benefit ratio of FETO for severe LCDH clear and consistently offer FETO, but not for moderate LDCH and severe RCDH. However, not offering the option of FETO to parents was considered a psychological burden.
引用
- Vergote S, Russo FM, Basurto D, et al. Have the results of the TOTAL-trials changed the attitude and practice of maternal-fetal medicine specialists? Prenat Diagn. 2023. PMID: 37357369. doi:10.1002/pd.6403
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。