评估佛罗里达州医院在低风险剖宫产指标上的差异
该研究基于佛罗里达州2016至2019年活产数据,比较5种低风险剖宫产率计算指标(基于风险方法与数据来源)的医院间差异。结果显示,仅用医院出院数据的指标因纳入经产妇而明显低估低风险剖宫产率,而基于出生证明的未产、足月、单胎、头位指标与链接数据指标结果相近。
要点
- 仅用医院出院数据的指标因纳入经产妇而明显低估低风险剖宫产率。
- 基于出生证明的未产、足月、单胎、头位指标与链接数据指标结果相近。
- 同一数据来源内各指标率相似,其中母胎医学会指标率最低。
核心结论
- 基于出生证明的未产、足月、单胎、头位指标对低风险剖宫产率的监测较为准确,可为佛罗里达州医院提供及时评估。
- 同一数据来源内各指标率相似,其中母胎医学会指标率最低。
- 仅用医院出院数据的指标因纳入经产妇而明显低估低风险剖宫产率,应谨慎解读。
研究设计与样本
- 基于佛罗里达州2016至2019年活产的人群研究,比较5种低风险剖宫产率计算方法。
- 分析使用链接出生证明数据与住院医院出院数据。
- 5种指标为:未产、足月、单胎、头位出生证明;链接的联合委员会;链接的母胎医学会;医院出院联合委员会;医院出院母胎医学会。
主要发现
- 医院低风险剖宫产率中位数从出生证明的未产、足月、单胎、头位30.7%降至链接联合委员会29.1%,医院出院母胎医学会18.1%。
- 按新生儿重症监护病房级别分层趋势相似,II级在多数指标中中位数最高(出生证明32.7%、链接联合委员会31.4%、链接母胎医学会31.1%、医院出院母胎医学会19.3%),但III级医院出院联合委员会为20.0%。
- 链接指标与医院出院指标之间低风险剖宫产率差距较大,但随医院率升高而缩小。
关键数值与推荐
- 医院低风险剖宫产率中位数:出生证明未产、足月、单胎、头位30.7%;链接联合委员会29.1%;医院出院母胎医学会29.2%?原文写‘Society for Maternal Fetal Medicine hospital discharge 29.2%’,但后文又写18.1%,原文此处表述有矛盾,照录原文数值。
- 医院低风险剖宫产率中位数:医院出院联合委员会19.4%;医院出院母胎医学会18.1%。
临床怎么用
- 原文结论指出,基于出生证明的未产、足月、单胎、头位指标对低风险剖宫产率监测较为准确,可供佛罗里达州医院使用。
- 原文结论指出,仅用医院出院数据的指标因纳入经产妇而明显低估率,应谨慎解读。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Unnecessary cesarean deliveries lead to increased maternal and neonatal morbidities and mortalities. In 2020, Florida had a cesarean delivery rate of 35.9%, the third highest in the nation. An effective quality improvement strategy to reduce overall cesarean delivery rates is to decrease primary cesarean deliveries in low-risk births (nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex). Of note, 3 nationally accepted hospital measures of low-risk cesarean delivery rates include the nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex; Joint Commission; and Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine metrics. Comparing metrics is necessary because accurate and timely measurement is essential to support multihospital quality improvement efforts to reduce low-risk cesarean delivery rates and improve the quality of maternal care. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess differences in hospital low-risk cesarean delivery rates in Florida using 5 different metrics of low-risk cesarean delivery rate based on (1) risk methodology, nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex; Joint Commission; and Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine metrics, and (2) data source, linked birth certificate and hospital discharge records and hospital discharge records only. STUDY DESIGN: This was a population-based study of live Florida births from 2016 to 2019 to compare 5 approaches to calculating low-risk cesarean delivery rates. Analyses were performed using linked birth certificate data and inpatient hospital discharge data. The 5 low-risk cesarean delivery measures were defined as follows: nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex birth certificate; Joint Commission-linked used Joint Commission exclusions; Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine-linked used Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine exclusions; Joint Commission hospital discharge with Joint Commission exclusions; and Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine hospital discharge with Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine exclusions. Nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex birth certificate was based on data from birth certificates and not using linked hospital discharge data. Designated as nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex, it does not exclude other high-risk conditions. The second and third measures (Joint Commission-linked used Joint Commission exclusions and Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine-linked used Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine exclusions) use data elements from the full-linked dataset to designate nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex and excluded several high-risk conditions. The last 2 measures (Joint Commission hospital discharge with Joint Commission exclusions; and Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine hospital discharge with Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine exclusions) were based on data from hospital discharge data only and not using linked birth certificate data. These measures generally reflect term, singleton, and vertex because parity could not be assessed adequately on hospital discharge data. Hospital differences between these 5 measures were calculated overall and by neonatal intensive care unit level. RESULTS: Overall, the median of hospital low-risk cesarean rates decreased across the measures, from NTSV-BC 30.7%, to Joint Commission linked 29.1%, and Society for Maternal Fetal Medicine hospital discharge 29.2% with a large decrease to Joint Commission hospital discharge 19.4% and Society for Maternal Fetal Medicine hospital discharge 18.1%. A similar trend was seen by neonatal intensive care unit level. For each of the measures, level II had the highest median low-risk cesarean rates (nulliparous. term, singleton, vertex birth certificate) 32.7%, Joint Commission linked (31.4%), Society for Maternal Fetal Medicine linked: 31.1%, Society for Maternal Fetal Medicine hospital discharge 19.3%), except for level III Joint Commission hospital discharge (20.0%). A comparison of the median number of low-risk births overall and by neonatal intensive care unit level showed a decreasing number across the linked and hospital discharge measures. Again, a wide gap in low-risk cesarean delivery rates was identified between linked measures and hospital discharge measures. However, this gap narrowed as hospital rates increased. CONCLUSION: Quality monitoring of low-risk cesarean delivery rates measured by the nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex metric using the birth certificate was fairly accurate and provided timely assessment for use by Florida hospitals. The nulliparous, term, singleton, vertex birth certificate rates were comparable with low-risk metrics using the linked data source. Overall, metrics used within the same data source had similar rates, with the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine metric having the lowest rates. Across data sources, metrics using hospital discharge data only resulted in substantially underestimated rates because of the inclusion of multiparous women and should be interpreted with caution.
引用
- Obure R, Reid CN, Salemi JL, et al. Assessing hospital differences in low-risk cesarean delivery metrics in Florida. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37321284. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2023.06.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。