女性盆底手术后因尿潴留留置导尿管拔除地点(家庭与诊室)的患者满意度评估:一项随机对照试验
本研究纳入78例盆底手术后因尿潴留需留置导尿管的成年女性,随机分为家庭拔管组与诊室拔管组,比较患者满意度。两组满意度中位数均为95分(P=.52),家庭组排尿试验通过率83.8%与诊室组72.5%相似(P=.23),家庭组30天内尿路感染比例8.3%低于诊室组26.3%(P=.04)。
要点
- 家庭拔管与诊室拔管的患者满意度无显著差异,中位评分均为95分(P=.52)。
- 家庭拔管组排尿试验通过率83.8%,诊室拔管组72.5%,差异无统计学意义(P=.23)。
- 家庭拔管组30天内尿路感染比例8.3%,低于诊室拔管组的26.3%(P=.04)。
核心结论
- 在盆底手术后因尿潴留留置导尿管的女性中,家庭拔管与诊室拔管的患者满意度无差异。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验,纳入78例因尿失禁和/或盆腔器官脱垂手术后诊断尿潴留需术后留置导尿管的成年女性,随机分为家庭拔管组(38例,48.7%)与诊室拔管组(40例,51.3%)。
主要发现
- 总体样本年龄中位数60岁(四分位距49-72),阴道分娩次数2次(2-3),体重指数28 kg/m2(24-32)。
- 患者满意度中位数在家庭拔管组为95分(四分位距87-100),诊室拔管组为95分(80-98),组间比较P=.52。
- 排尿试验通过率在家庭拔管组为83.8%,诊室拔管组为72.5%,组间比较P=.23。
- 术后30天内尿路感染比例在家庭拔管组为8.3%,低于诊室拔管组的26.3%(P=.04)。
- 两组均无参与者因排尿不充分而紧急到诊室或医院就诊。
关键数值与推荐
- 家庭拔管组患者出院前学习拔管方法,并携带书面说明、排尿帽和10 mL注射器回家,拔管在出院后2至4天进行,诊室护士于下午电话联系。
- 家庭拔管组以0至10分评估尿流力量,评分为5分视为安全通过排尿试验。
- 诊室拔管组排尿试验为逆行充盈膀胱至患者最大耐受量,最多300 mL,排出量>50%充盈量视为成功。
- 两组排尿试验未通过者均接受导尿管重新插入或诊室自我导尿训练。
- 样本量计算为每组40例,以检测视觉模拟量表满意度10 mm差异,提供80%功效和0.05的α水平,最终样本量考虑10%失访。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Postoperative urinary retention is burdensome for patients. We seek to improve patient satisfaction with the voiding trial process. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to assess patient satisfaction with location of indwelling catheter removal placed for urinary retention after urogynecologic surgery. STUDY DESIGN: All adult women who were diagnosed with urinary retention requiring postoperative indwelling catheter insertion after undergoing surgery for urinary incontinence and/or pelvic organ prolapse were eligible for this randomized controlled study. They were randomly assigned to catheter removal at home or in the office. Those who were randomized to home removal were taught how to remove the catheter before discharge, and were discharged home with written instructions, a voiding hat, and 10-mL syringe. All patients had their catheter removed 2 to 4 days after discharge. Those patients who were allocated to home removal were contacted in the afternoon by the office nurse. Subjects who graded their force of urine stream 5, on a scale of 0 to 10, were considered to have safely passed their voiding trial. For patients randomized to the office removal group, the voiding trial consisted of retrograde filling the bladder to maximum they could tolerate up to 300 mL. Urinating >50% of instilled volume was considered successful. Those who were unsuccessful in either group had catheter reinsertion or self-catheterization training in the office. The primary study outcome was patient satisfaction, measured based on patients' response to a question, "How satisfied were you with the overall removal process of the catheter?" A visual analogue scale was created to assess patient satisfaction and 4 secondary outcomes. A sample size of 40 participants per group were needed to detect a 10 mm difference in satisfaction between groups on the visual analogue scale. This calculation provided 80% power and an alpha of 0.05. The final number accounted for 10% loss to follow up. We compared the baseline characteristics, including urodynamic parameters, relevant perioperative indices, and patient satisfaction between the groups. RESULTS: Of the 78 women enrolled in the study, 38 (48.7%) removed their catheter at home and 40 (51.3%) had an office visit for catheter removal. Median and interquartile range for age, vaginal parity, and body mass index were 60 (49-72) years, 2 (2-3), and 28 (24-32) kg/m2, respectively, in the overall sample. Groups did not differ significantly in age, vaginal parity, body mass index, previous surgical history, or type of concomitant procedures. Patient satisfaction was comparable between the groups, with a median score (interquartile range) of 95 (87-100) in the home catheter removal group and 95 (80-98) in the office catheter removal group (P=.52). Voiding trial pass rate was similar between women who underwent home (83.8%) vs office (72.5%) catheter removal (P=.23). No participants in either group had to emergently come into the office or hospital due to inadequate voiding afterwards. Within 30 days post operatively, a lower proportion of women in the home catheter removal group (8.3%) had urinary tract infection, compared to patients in the office catheter removal group (26.3%) (P=.04). CONCLUSION: In women with urinary retention after urogynecologic surgery, there is no difference in satisfaction concerning the location of indwelling catheter removal when comparing home and office.
引用
- Popiel P, Swallow C, Choi JE, et al. Assessment of patient satisfaction with home vs office indwelling catheter removal placed for urinary retention after female pelvic floor surgery: a randomized controlled trial. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37330128. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2023.06.025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。