探究妇产科患者护理疼痛再评估依从性中的差异
该回顾性队列研究分析2017年9月至2021年3月一家大型学术医院10774例妇产科患者的76984次疼痛再评估 encounters,发现黑人及白人患者总体不依从比例无显著差异(8.1% vs 8.2%),但良性亚专科妇科手术和母胎医学部内差异显著,体重指数≥35 kg/m2、非西班牙裔/拉丁裔、≥65岁、医疗保险及子宫切除术患者不依从比例更高,2020年3月后良性亚专科妇科不依从比例升高。
要点
- 黑人及白人患者总体疼痛再评估不依从比例无显著差异(8.1% vs 8.2%)。
- 良性亚专科妇科手术不依从比例黑人患者14.9% vs 白人患者10.70%(P=.03)。
- 母胎医学部不依从比例黑人患者9.5% vs 白人患者8.3%(P=.04)。
核心结论
- 围手术期床旁护理存在显著的种族、民族、年龄、手术方式和体重指数相关差异,尤其见于良性亚专科妇科服务。
- 妇科肿瘤黑人患者护理不依从水平较低,可能与本院一名妇科肿瘤执业护士协调术后患者护理有关。
- 2020年3月后良性亚专科妇科服务不依从比例升高。
- 本研究未设计确立因果关系,可能 contributing 因素包括对疼痛体验的隐性或显性偏见、病房疼痛管理差异及医护人员倦怠等。
- 本研究显示需要在患者护理所有界面持续调查医疗差异,并在质量改进框架内利用可操作指标切实改善患者结局。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性队列研究,纳入2017年9月至2021年3月一家大型学术医院10774例妇产科患者的76984次疼痛再评估 encounters,数据来自 Tableau: Quality, Safety and Risk Prevention 平台。
- 按患者种族分析各服务线不依从比例,并进行排除既非黑人亦非白人患者的敏感性分析。
- 次要结局按民族、体重指数、年龄、语言、手术和保险分析。
- 按2020年3月前后时间分层分析大流行和社会政治影响。
- 连续变量采用 Wilcoxon 秩和检验,分类变量采用卡方检验,多变量逻辑回归分析(P<.05)。
主要发现
- 全部妇产科患者中,黑人 vs 白人疼痛再评估不依从比例无显著差异(8.1% vs 8.2%)。
- 良性亚专科妇科手术(微创妇科手术+泌尿妇科)不依从比例黑人患者14.9% vs 白人患者10.70%(P=.03)。
- 母胎医学部不依从比例黑人患者9.5% vs 白人患者8.3%(P=.04)。
- 妇科肿瘤黑人患者不依从比例低于白人患者(5.6% vs 10.4%;P<.01),多变量分析校正体重指数、年龄、保险、时间线、手术类型和护士数量后差异持续存在。
- 良性亚专科妇科中体重指数≥35 kg/m2患者不依从比例17.9% vs 10.4%(P<.01);非西班牙裔/拉丁裔(P=.03)、≥65岁(P<.01)、医疗保险(P<.01)及子宫切除术(P<.01)患者不依从比例更高。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 本研究未设计确立因果关系。
- 本研究显示需要在患者护理所有界面持续调查医疗差异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Racial and socioeconomic disparities, exacerbated during the COVID-19 pandemic and surrounding socio-political polarization, affect access to, delivery of, and patient perception of healthcare. Perioperatively, the bedside nurse carries the greatest responsibility of direct care, which includes pain reassessment, a metric tracked for compliance. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to critically assess disparities in obstetrics and gynecology perioperative care and how these have changed since March 2020 using nursing pain reassessment compliance within a quality improvement framework. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective cohort of 76,984 pain reassessment encounters from 10,774 obstetrics and gynecology patients at a large, academic hospital from September 2017 to March 2021 was obtained from Tableau: Quality, Safety and Risk Prevention platform. Noncompliance proportions were analyzed by patient race across service lines; a sensitivity analysis was performed excluding patients who were of neither Black nor White race. Secondary outcomes included analysis by patient ethnicity, body mass index, age, language, procedure, and insurance. Additional analyses were performed by temporally stratifying patients into pre- and post-March 2020 cohorts to investigate potential pandemic and sociopolitical effects on healthcare disparities. Continuous variables were assessed with Wilcoxon rank test, categorical variables were assessed with chi-squared test, and multivariable logistic regression analyses were performed (P<.05). RESULTS: Noncompliance proportions of pain reassessment did not differ significantly between Black and White patients as an aggregate of all obstetrics and gynecology patients (8.1% vs 8.2%), but greater differences were found within the divisions of Benign Subspecialty Gynecologic Surgery (Minimally Invasive Gynecologic Surgery + Urogynecology) (14.9% vs 10.70%; P=.03) and Maternal Fetal Medicine (9.5% vs 8.3%; P=.04). Black patients admitted to Gynecologic Oncology experienced lower noncompliance proportions than White patients (5.6% vs 10.4%; P<.01). These differences persisted after adjustment for body mass index, age, insurance, timeline, procedure type, and number of nurses attending to each patient with multivariable analyses. Noncompliance proportions were higher for patients with body mass index ≥35 kg/m2 within Benign Subspecialty Gynecology (17.9% vs 10.4%; P<.01). Non-Hispanic/Latino patients (P=.03), those ≥65 years (P<.01), those with Medicare (P<.01), and those who underwent hysterectomy (P<.01) also experienced greater noncompliance proportions. Aggregate noncompliance proportions differed slightly pre- and post-March 2020; this trend was seen across all service lines except Midwifery and was significant for Benign Subspecialty Gynecology after multivariable analysis (odds ratio, 1.41; 95% confidence interval, 1.02-1.93; P=.04). Though increases in noncompliance proportions were seen for non-White patients after March 2020, this was not statistically significant. CONCLUSION: Significant race, ethnicity, age, procedure, and body mass index-based disparities were identified in the delivery of perioperative bedside care, especially for those admitted to Benign Subspecialty Gynecologic Services. Conversely, Black patients admitted to Gynecologic Oncology experienced lower levels of nursing noncompliance. This may be in part be related to the actions of a Gynecologic Oncology nurse practioner at our institution who helps coordinate care for the division's postoperative patients. Noncompliance proportions increased after March 2020 within Benign Subspecialty Gynecologic Services. Although this study was not designed to establish causation, possible contributing factors include implicit or explicit biases regarding pain experience across race, body mass index, age, or surgical indication, discrepancies in pain management across hospital units, and downstream effects of healthcare worker burnout, understaffing, increased use of travelers, or sociopolitical polarization since March 2020. This study demonstrates the need for ongoing investigation of healthcare disparities at all interfaces of patient care and provides a way forward for tangible improvement of patient-directed outcomes by utilizing an actionable metric within a quality improvement framework.
引用
- Holt EW, Murarka SM, Zhao Z, et al. Investigating disparities in compliance of nursing pain reassessment for obstetrics and gynecology patients. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37330130. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2023.06.027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。