文献速递母胎医学产科

心脏结构异常胎儿的临床特征及多学科团队协作模式对妊娠决策的影响

[Clinical characteristics of cardiac defects fetuses and the impact of multi-disciplinary team cooperation approach on the pregnancy decision making].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi · 2023-01-01

回顾性分析北京大学第一医院2012年1月至2021年6月诊断的400例心脏结构异常胎儿,按单发或多发及是否伴心外异常分为4组。孕妇年龄、诊断孕周、预后分级、伴心外异常、致病性遗传学异常及接受MDT咨询和管理是放弃妊娠的独立影响因素;MDT协作影响妊娠决策,应推荐用于管理。

要点

  • 400例中常见类型为室间隔缺损24.0%、法洛四联症13.0%、主动脉缩窄8.5%、房室隔缺损6.5%。
  • 单发伴心外异常组放弃妊娠率86.1%,高于单发无心外异常组44.3%和多发无心外异常组70.0%。
  • 接受MDT咨询和管理者放弃妊娠率较低:多发无心外异常组74.2% vs 4/11,多发伴心外异常组87.9% vs 1/5。

核心结论

  • 孕妇年龄、诊断孕周、预后分级、伴心外异常、存在致病性遗传学异常及接受MDT咨询和管理是胎儿心脏结构异常妊娠决策的独立影响因素。
  • MDT咨询和管理影响妊娠决策,应推荐用于心脏结构异常胎儿的管理,从而减少不必要的放弃妊娠,改善妊娠结局。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性分析2012年1月至2021年6月于北京大学第一医院诊断的心脏结构异常胎儿400例的临床资料。
  • 按心脏结构异常为单发或多发及是否存在心外异常分为4组:单发无心外异常组122例、多发无心外异常组100例、单发伴心外异常组115例、多发伴心外异常组63例。
  • 采用logistic回归分析胎儿心脏结构异常妊娠决策的影响因素。

主要发现

  • 400例中常见类型依次为室间隔缺损96例(24.0%,96/400)、法洛四联症52例(13.0%,52/400)、主动脉缩窄34例(8.5%,34/400)、房室隔缺损26例(6.5%,26/400)。
  • 行遗传学检查的204例中检出致病性遗传学异常44例(21.6%,44/204)。
  • 单发伴心外异常组致病性遗传学异常检出率39.3%(24/61)高于单发无心外异常组15.1%(8/53)和多发无心外异常组6.1%(3/49)(P均<0.05)。
  • 单发伴心外异常组放弃妊娠率86.1%(99/115)高于单发无心外异常组44.3%(54/122)和多发无心外异常组70.0%(70/100)(P均<0.05);多发无心外异常组和多发伴心外异常组82.5%(52/63)放弃妊娠率均高于单发无心外异常组(P均<0.05)。
  • 共29例(7.2%,29/400)接受MDT咨询和管理;多发无心外异常组接受MDT者放弃妊娠率74.2%(66/89)低于未接受者4/11,多发伴心外异常组接受MDT者87.9%(51/58)低于未接受者1/5(P均<0.05)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 校正年龄、孕产次、是否进行产前诊断后,孕妇年龄、诊断孕周、预后分级、伴心外异常、存在致病性遗传学异常、接受MDT咨询和管理仍是放弃妊娠的独立影响因素(P均<0.05)。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为,MDT咨询和管理影响妊娠决策,应推荐用于心脏结构异常胎儿的管理,从而减少不必要的放弃妊娠,改善妊娠结局。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To analysis the clinical characteristics of 400 fetuses with heart defects and the impactors of pregnancy decision making, and explore the influence of a multi-disciplinary team (MDT) cooperation approach on it. Methods: Clinical data of 400 fetuses with abnormal cardiac structure diagnosed at Peking University First Hospital from January 2012 to June 2021 were collected, which were divided into 4 groups according to the characteristics of fetal heart defects and the presence of extracardiac abnormalities or not: single cardiac defects without extracardiac abnormalities (122 cases), multiple cardiac defects without extracardiac abnormalities (100 cases), single cardiac defects with extracardiac abnormalities (115 cases), and multiple cardiac defects with extracardiac abnormalities (63 cases). The types of fetal cardiac structural abnormalities and genetic test results, and the detection rate of pathogenic genetic abnormalities, MDT consultation and management situation, and pregnancy decision of fetuses in each group were retrospectively analyzed. A logistics regression was used to analyze the influencing factors of fetal heart defects pregnancy decision. Results: (1) Among the 400 fetal heart defects, the four most common major types were ventricular septal defect 96 (24.0%, 96/400), tetralogy of Fallot 52 (13.0%, 52/400), coarctation of the aorta 34 (8.5%, 34/400), and atrioventricular septal defect 26 (6.5%, 26/400). (2) Among the 204 fetuses undergoing genetic examination, 44 (21.6%, 44/204) pathogenic genetic abnormalities were detected. (3) Detection rate of pathogenic genetic abnormalities (39.3%, 24/61) and pregnancy termination rate (86.1%, 99/115) in the single cardiac defects with extracardiac abnormalities group were significantly higher than those in the single cardiac defects without extracardiac abnormalities group [15.1% (8/53), 44.3% (54/122), respectively] and the multiple cardiac defects without extracardiac abnormalities group [6.1% (3/49), 70.0% (70/100), respectively, both P<0.05], and the pregnancy termination rate in the multiple cardiac defects without extracardiac abnormalities group and the multiple cardiac defects with extracardiac abnormalities group (82.5%,52/63) were significantly higher than that of the single cardiac abnormalities without extracardiac abnormalities group (both P<0.05). (4) After adjusting for age, gravity, parity and performed prenatal diagnosis, maternal age, the diagnosis of gestational age, prognosis grades, co-existence of extracardiac abnormalities, presence of pathogenic genetic abnormalities, and receiving MDT consultation and management were still independent influencing factors of termination of pregnancy of fetuses with cardiac defects (all P<0.05). A total of 29 (7.2%, 29/400) fetal cardiac defects received MDT consultation and management, and compared with those without MDT management, the pregnancy termination rate in the multiple cardiac defects without extracardiac abnormalities group [74.2%(66/89) vs 4/11] and the multiple cardiac defects with extracardiac abnormalities group [87.9%(51/58) vs 1/5] were lower, the differences were statistically significant respectively (all P<0.05). Conclusions: Maternal age, diagnosed gestational age, severity of cardiac defects, extracardiac abnormalities, pathogenic genetic abnormalities and MDT counseling and management are the influencing factors of fetal heart defects pregnancy decision. MDT cooperation approach influences pregnancy decision-making and should be recommended for the management of fetal cardiac defect to reduce unnecessary termination of pregnancy and improve pregnancy outcomes. 目的: 分析心脏结构异常胎儿的临床特点及妊娠决策的影响因素,探讨多学科团队(MDT)协作对其妊娠决策的影响。 方法: 收集2012年1月至2021年6月于北京大学第一医院诊断的心脏结构异常胎儿400例的临床资料,根据胎儿心脏结构异常为单发或多发及是否存在心外异常分为4组:单发无心外异常组(122例),多发无心外异常组(100例),单发伴心外异常组(115例),多发伴心外异常组(63例)。回顾性分析胎儿心脏结构异常类型、遗传学检测结果,比较各组心脏结构异常胎儿的致病性遗传学异常检出率、MDT咨询和管理情况及妊娠决策。采用logistic回归分析胎儿心脏结构异常妊娠决策的影响因素。 结果: (1)400例心脏结构异常胎儿中,常见的4种胎儿心脏结构异常类型依次为室间隔缺损96例(24.0%,96/400)、法洛四联症52例(13.0%,52/400)、主动脉缩窄34例(8.5%,34/400)、房室隔缺损26例(6.5%,26/400)。(2)行遗传学检查的204例胎儿中,共检出致病性遗传学异常44例(21.6%,44/204)。(3)单发伴心外异常组致病性遗传学异常检出率(39.3%,24/61)、放弃妊娠率(86.1%,99/115)均显著高于单发无心外异常组[分别为15.1%(8/53)、44.3%(54/122)]和多发无心外异常组[分别为6.1%(3/49)、70.0%(70/100),P均<0.05],多发无心外异常组和多发伴心外异常组[82.5%(52/63)]的放弃妊娠率均显著高于单发无心外异常组(P均<0.05)。(4)校正年龄、孕产次、是否进行产前诊断因素后,孕妇年龄、诊断孕周、预后分级、伴心外异常、存在致病性遗传学异常、接受MDT咨询和管理仍是胎儿心脏结构异常放弃妊娠的独立影响因素(P均<0.05)。共计29例(7.2%,29/400)心脏结构异常胎儿接受MDT咨询和管理,与组内未接受MDT产前咨询和管理胎儿比较,多发无心外异常组[分别为74.2%(66/89)、4/11]和多发伴心外异常组[分别为87.9%(51/58)、1/5]接受MDT产前咨询和管理者的放弃妊娠率均较低,分别比较,差异均有统计学意义(P均<0.05)。 结论: 孕妇年龄、诊断孕周、预后分级、伴心外异常、有致病性遗传学异常及接受MDT咨询和管理是胎儿心脏结构异常妊娠决策的独立影响因素。MDT咨询和管理影响妊娠决策,应推荐用于心脏结构异常胎儿的管理,从而减少不必要的放弃妊娠,改善妊娠结局。.

来源:Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Li S, Liu Z. [Clinical characteristics of cardiac defects fetuses and the impact of multi-disciplinary team cooperation approach on the pregnancy decision making]. Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi. 2023. PMID: 37217339. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112141-20221205-00740

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。