根据Hadlock、INTERGROWTH-21st、WHO和GROW胎儿体重标准评估死产风险与小于胎龄儿:按母亲族裔和体重指数分析
南亚裔妊娠死产率(5.51‰)高于英国欧洲裔(3.89‰)(P<.01),且两组的死产率均随体重指数升高而增加(P<.01)。人群平均标准下南亚裔小于胎龄儿率是英国欧洲裔的2至3倍,而GROW定制标准下两组相似(14.0% vs 13.6%)。
要点
- 南亚裔妊娠死产率5.51‰高于英国欧洲裔3.89‰(P<.01),两组死产率均随体重指数升高而增加(P<.01)。
- 人群平均标准下南亚裔小于胎龄儿率是英国欧洲裔的2至3倍,GROW定制标准下两组相似(14.0% vs 13.6%)。
- 各标准定义的小于胎龄儿病例死产风险均高于非小于胎龄儿病例,风险幅度与小于胎龄儿率呈反向关系。
核心结论
- 在研究的两个族裔组中,母亲体重指数升高伴随死产风险增加,仅定制标准能通过识别更多小于胎龄儿来反映这一趋势。
- 人群平均标准下小于胎龄儿率随体重指数升高而下降,掩盖了高母亲体重指数相关的死产风险增加。
研究设计与样本
- 在2个最大族裔组(英国欧洲裔和南亚裔)、5个体重指数类别及体重指数正常(18.5-25.0 kg/m2)的4个母亲体型组中评估小于胎龄儿出生体重和死产风险。
主要发现
- 死产率(每1000例)南亚裔妊娠为5.51,英国欧洲裔为3.89(P<.01),两组均随体重指数升高而增加(P<.01)。
- 小于胎龄儿率南亚裔 vs 英国欧洲裔:Hadlock标准26.2% vs 12.2%;INTERGROWTH-21st标准12.1% vs 4.9%;WHO标准32.2% vs 16.0%;GROW标准14.0% vs 13.6%。
- 各标准定义的小于胎龄儿病例死产风险均高于非小于胎龄儿病例,风险幅度与小于胎龄儿率呈反向关系。
- 将各标准定义小于胎龄儿的阈值调整使小于胎龄儿率固定为10%时,所有标准的死产风险相似。
- 按体重指数亚组分析,GROW标准的小于胎龄儿率随死产率增加而升高,而Hadlock、INTERGROWTH-21st和WHO标准的小于胎龄儿率随体重指数升高而下降,与死产率的趋势差异有统计学意义(P<.01)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Appropriate growth charts are essential for fetal surveillance, to confirm that growth is proceeding normally and to identify pregnancies that are at risk. Many stillbirths are avoidable through antenatal detection of the small-for-gestational-age fetus. In the absence of an international consensus on which growth chart to use, it is essential that clinical practice reflects outcome-based evidence. OBJECTIVE: This study investigated the performance of 4 internationally used fetal weight standards and their ability to identify stillbirth risk in different ethnic and maternal size groups of a heterogeneous population. STUDY DESIGN: We analyzed routinely collected maternity data from more than 2.2 million pregnancies. Three population-based fetal weight standards (Hadlock, Intergrowth-21st, and World Health Organization) were compared with the customized GROW standard that was adjusted for maternal height, weight, parity, and ethnic origin. Small-for-gestational-age birthweight and stillbirth risk were determined for the 2 largest ethnic groups in our population (British European and South Asian), in 5 body mass index categories, and in 4 maternal size groups with normal body mass index (18.5-25.0 kg/m2). The differences in trend between stillbirth and small-for-gestational-age rates were assessed using the Clogg z test, and differences between stillbirths and body mass index groups were assessed using the chi-square trend test. RESULTS: Stillbirth rates (per 1000) were higher in South Asian pregnancies (5.51) than British-European pregnancies (3.89) (P<.01) and increased in both groups with increasing body mass index (P<.01). Small-for-gestational-age rates were 2 to 3-fold higher for South Asian babies than British European babies according to the population-average standards (Hadlock: 26.2% vs 12.2%; Intergrowth-21st: 12.1% vs 4.9%; World Health Organization: 32.2% vs 16.0%) but were similar by the customized GROW standard (14.0% vs 13.6%). Despite the wide variation, each standard's small-for-gestation-age cases had increased stillbirth risk compared with non-small-for-gestation-age cases, with the magnitude of risk inversely proportional to the rate of cases defined as small for gestational age. All standards had similar stillbirth risk when the small-for-gestation-age rate was fixed at 10% by varying their respective thresholds for defining small for gestational age. When analyzed across body mass index subgroups, the small-for-gestation-age rate according to the GROW standard increased with increasing stillbirth rate, whereas small-for-gestation-age rates according to Hadlock, Intergrowth-21st, and World Health Organization fetal weight standards declined with increasing body mass index, showing a difference in trend (P<.01) to stillbirth rates across body mass index groups. In the normal body mass index subgroup, stillbirth rates showed little variation across maternal size groups; this trend was followed by GROW-based small-for-gestation-age rates, whereas small-for-gestation-age rates defined by each population-average standard declined with increasing maternal size. CONCLUSION: Comparisons between population-average and customized fetal growth charts require examination of how well each standard identifies pregnancies at risk of adverse outcomes within subgroups of any heterogeneous population. In both ethnic groups studied, increasing maternal body mass index was accompanied by increasing stillbirth risk, and this trend was reflected in more pregnancies being identified as small for gestational age only by the customized standard. In contrast, small-for-gestation-age rates fell according to each population-average standard, thereby hiding the increased stillbirth risk associated with high maternal body mass index.
引用
- Gardosi J, Hugh O. Stillbirth risk and smallness for gestational age according to Hadlock, INTERGROWTH-21st, WHO, and GROW fetal weight standards: analysis by maternal ethnicity and body mass index. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37247647. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2023.05.026
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。