阴道或腹部宫颈环扎术后宫颈长度纵向变化:一项随机比较
本研究为Vaginal Randomised Intervention of Cerclage试验的计划分析,纳入78例既往阴道环扎失败孕妇,随机接受低阴道、高阴道或腹部环扎。腹部环扎在维持宫颈长度上优于低阴道环扎(P=.008)和高阴道环扎(P=.001)。宫颈长度对<32周自发性早产有极好预测价值(ROC曲线0.92)。
要点
- 腹部环扎在14至26周监测期内维持宫颈长度优于低阴道和高阴道环扎(P=.008和P=.001)。
- 低阴道环扎者12周宫颈缩短13.2 mm(95%CI -21.7至-4.7;P=.002),高阴道环扎者缩短20 mm(95%CI -33.1至-7.4;P=.002)。
- 孕前腹部环扎者孕22周后宫颈长度显著长于孕期环扎者(48.5 mm vs 39.6 mm;P=.039)。
核心结论
- 在既往阴道环扎失败的妇女中,下次妊娠接受阴道环扎者宫颈随时间漏斗化和缩短,而接受腹部环扎者宫颈长度得以保持。
- 孕前进行的腹部环扎比孕期进行的腹部环扎宫颈长度更长。
- 宫颈长度在本队列中是<32周自发性早产的极好预测指标。
- 研究结果可能解释腹部环扎的获益机制,即其高位放置更好地维持了宫颈内口水平的结构完整性。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为Vaginal Randomised Intervention of Cerclage试验的计划分析,该试验为随机对照试验,比较腹部环扎或高阴道环扎与低阴道环扎。
- 纳入78例有既往环扎失败史并接受纵向宫颈长度评估的妇女(占分析队列的70%),其中25例(32%)随机分至低阴道环扎,26例(33%)至高阴道环扎,27例(35%)至腹部环扎。
- 采用广义估计方程(最大似然随机效应估计)比较特定孕周宫颈长度随时间及组间变化,并比较孕前与孕期腹部环扎者宫颈长度,探索宫颈长度对<32周自发性早产的预测准确性。
主要发现
- 腹部环扎在监测期(妊娠14至26周)维持宫颈长度优于低阴道环扎(P=.008)和高阴道环扎(P=.001)(+0.08 mm/周,95%CI -0.40至0.22;P=.580)。
- 12周监测期结束时,腹部环扎者宫颈长度平均长1.8 mm(+1.8 mm;95%CI -7.89至4.30;P=.564)。
- 高阴道环扎在预防宫颈缩短方面不优于低宫颈环扎;低阴道环扎者12周宫颈缩短13.2 mm(95%CI -21.7至-4.7;P=.002),高阴道环扎者12周缩短20 mm(95%CI -33.1至-7.4;P=.002)。
- 孕前腹部环扎者宫颈长度长于孕期环扎者,此差异在妊娠22周后显著(48.5 mm vs 39.6 mm;P=.039)。
- 总体而言,宫颈长度是<32周自发性早产的极好预测指标(受试者工作特征曲线0.92;95%CI 0.82-1.00)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cervical cerclage has been shown to reduce the risk of recurrent spontaneous preterm birth in a high-risk patient population; however, the mechanism is not well understood. Transabdominal cerclage is superior to low and high vaginal cerclage in reducing early spontaneous preterm birth and fetal loss in women with previous failed vaginal cerclage. Cervical length measurements are commonly used to monitor high-risk women and may explain the mechanism of success. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to evaluate the rate of change in longitudinal cervical length after randomized placement of low transvaginal, high transvaginal, or transabdominal cerclage in women with a previous failed vaginal cerclage. STUDY DESIGN: This was a planned analysis of longitudinal transvaginal ultrasound cervical length measurements from patients enrolled in the Vaginal Randomised Intervention of Cerclage trial, a randomized controlled trial comparing transabdominal cerclage or high transvaginal cerclage with low transvaginal cerclage. Cervical length measurements at specific gestational ages were compared over time and between groups, using generalized estimating equations fitted using the maximum-likelihood random-effects estimator. In addition, cervical length measurements were compared in women with transabdominal cerclage placed before and during pregnancy. The diagnostic accuracy of cervical length as a predictor of spontaneous preterm birth at <32 weeks of gestation was explored. RESULTS: This study included 78 women who underwent longitudinal cervical length assessment (70% of the analyzed cohort) with a history of failed cerclage, of whom 25 (32%) were randomized to low transvaginal cerclage, 26 (33%) to high transvaginal cerclage, and 27 (35%) to transabdominal cerclage. Abdominal cerclage was superior to low (P=.008) and high (P=.001) vaginal cerclage at maintaining cervical length over the surveillance period (14 to 26 weeks of gestation) (+0.08 mm/week, 95% confidence interval, -0.40 to 0.22; P=.580). On average, the cervical length was 1.8 mm longer by the end of the 12-week surveillance period in women with transabdominal cerclage (+1.8 mm; 95% confidence interval, -7.89 to 4.30; P=.564). High vaginal cerclage was no better than low cervical cerclage in the prevention of cervical shortening; the cervix shortened by 13.2 mm over 12 weeks in those with low vaginal cerclage (95% confidence interval, -21.7 to -4.7; P=.002) and by 20 mm over 12 weeks in those with high vaginal cerclage (95% confidence interval, -33.1 to -7.4; P=.002). Preconception transabdominal cerclage resulted in a longer cervix than those performed during pregnancy; this difference was significant after 22 weeks of gestation (48.5 mm vs 39.6 mm; P=.039). Overall, cervical length was an excellent predictor of spontaneous preterm birth at <32 weeks of gestation (receiver operating characteristic curve, 0.92; 95% confidence interval, 0.82-1.00). CONCLUSION: In women with a previous failed cervical cerclage, in the next pregnancy, the cervical length in women treated with vaginal cerclage funneled and shortened over time, whereas there was preservation of cervical length in women who receive transabdominal cerclage. Cervical length remained longer in transabdominal procedures performed before pregnancy than in transabdominal procedures performed during pregnancy. Overall, cervical length was an excellent predictor of spontaneous preterm birth in our cohort. Our findings may explain the mechanism of benefit for transabdominal cerclage, with its high placement better maintaining the structural integrity of the cervix at the level of the internal os.
引用
- Ridout AE, Carter J, Seed PT, et al. Longitudinal change in cervical length following vaginal or abdominal cervical cerclage: a randomized comparison. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2023. PMID: 37146686. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2023.100987
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。