心血管相关孕产妇死亡的时机与可预防性
法国2007至2015年回顾性描述性研究,纳入93例心血管相关孕产妇死亡,其中心脏病70例、血管病23例。超过三分之二死亡发生于无已知心血管疾病的女性,心脏病例中60.7%可预防,血管病例中无已知疾病者47.4%可预防,可预防因素因疾病部位和孕前是否已知而异。
要点
- 心脏病死亡中60.7%可预防,主要因素为已知心脏病女性缺乏多学科孕前和产前保健。
- 无已知心脏病者死亡可预防因素主要与院前急救不足相关,尤其低估严重性和呼吸困难评估不足。
- 无已知血管病者47.4%死亡可预防,主要与急性剧烈胸腹痛的错误或延迟诊断和处理相关。
核心结论
- 大多数归因于心脏或血管疾病的孕产妇死亡可能可以预防,可预防因素因心脏或血管部位及孕前是否已知而异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性描述性研究,纳入法国2007至2015年妊娠期间或妊娠结束后1年内因心血管疾病导致的所有孕产妇死亡,通过全国永久性强化孕产妇死亡监测系统(ENCMM)识别。
- 共103例女性死于心脏或血管疾病,对应孕产妇死亡比为1.4/10万活产(95%CI 1.1-1.7)。
- 对93例有保密调查数据的孕产妇死亡进行分析,其中心脏病70例、血管病23例,按全国专家委员会评估分为四组。
主要发现
- 超过三分之二的死亡发生于无已知既存心脏或血管疾病的女性。
- 70例心脏病死亡中60.7%可预防,主要可预防因素为已知心脏病女性缺乏多学科孕前和产前保健。
- 无已知既存心脏病者中,可预防因素主要与急性事件院前急救不足相关,尤其低估严重性和呼吸困难评估不足。
- 23例血管病死亡中3例有既往已知疾病;无已知血管病者中47.4%死亡可预防,可预防因素主要与妊娠女性急性剧烈胸痛或腹痛的错误或延迟诊断和处理相关。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To describe the clinical profile, management, and potential preventability of maternal cardiovascular deaths. METHODS: We conducted a retrospective, descriptive study of all maternal deaths resulting from a cardiovascular disease during pregnancy or up to 1 year after the end of pregnancy in France from 2007 to 2015. Deaths were identified through the nationwide permanent enhanced maternal mortality surveillance system (ENCMM [Enquête Nationale Confidentielle sur les Morts Maternelles]). Women were classified into four groups based on the assessment of the national experts committee: those who died of a cardiac condition and those who died of a vascular condition and, within these two groups, whether the condition was known before the acute event. Maternal characteristics, clinical features and components of suboptimal care, and preventability factors, which were assessed with a standard evaluation form, were described among those four groups. RESULTS: During the 9-year period, 103 women died of cardiac or vascular disease, which corresponds to a maternal mortality ratio from these conditions of 1.4 per 100,000 live births (95% CI 1.1-1.7). Analyses were conducted on 93 maternal deaths resulting from cardiac (n=70) and vascular (n=23) disease with available data from confidential inquiry. More than two thirds of these deaths occurred in women with no known pre-existing cardiac or vascular condition. Among the 70 deaths resulting from a cardiac condition, 60.7% were preventable, and the main preventability factor was a lack of multidisciplinary prepregnancy and prenatal care for women with a known cardiac disease. For those with no known pre-existing cardiac condition, preventability factors were related mostly to inadequate prehospital care of the acute event, in particular an underestimation of the severity and inadequate investigation of the dyspnea. Among the 23 women who died of a vascular disease, three had previously known conditions. For women with no previously known vascular condition, 47.4% of deaths were preventable, and preventability factors were related mostly to wrong or delayed diagnosis and management of acute intense chest or abdominal pain in a pregnant woman. CONCLUSION: Most maternal deaths attributable to cardiac or vascular diseases were potentially preventable. The preventability factors varied according to the cardiac or vascular site and whether the condition was known before pregnancy. A more granular understanding of the cause and related risk factors for maternal mortality is crucial to identify relevant opportunities for improving care and training health care professionals.
引用
- Diguisto C, Choinier PM, Saucedo M, et al. Timing and Preventability of Cardiovascular-Related Maternal Death. Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 37141627. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000005176
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。