斋月禁食与妊娠:产科医生循证指南
本文对斋月禁食与妊娠或母胎结局的已发表研究进行针对性文献综述,总体发现禁食对新生儿出生体重或早产几乎无临床显著影响,对分娩方式数据矛盾,主要与孕妇疲劳、脱水症状及体重增长轻微减少相关,证据质量受禁食定义、研究规模设计与混杂因素影响,并为产科医生提供咨询框架。
要点
- 禁食对新生儿出生体重或早产几乎无临床显著影响。
- 禁食主要与孕妇疲劳、脱水症状及体重增长轻微减少相关。
- 禁食可能影响部分产前胎儿检测指标,包括无应激试验、羊水水平和生物物理评分。
核心结论
- 总体发现禁食对新生儿出生体重或早产几乎无临床显著影响。
- 禁食与分娩方式的数据存在矛盾,与妊娠期糖尿病的关联数据矛盾,与孕妇高血压的数据不足。
- 关于禁食对子代长期影响,现有文献提示可能的不良影响,但需要更多数据。
研究设计与样本
- 对已发表的斋月禁食与妊娠或母胎结局研究进行针对性文献综述。
- 证据质量受禁食定义变异、研究规模与设计及潜在混杂因素的负面影响。
主要发现
- 禁食主要与孕妇疲劳、脱水症状及体重增长轻微减少相关。
- 禁食可能影响部分产前胎儿检测指标,包括无应激试验、较低的羊水水平和较低的生物物理评分。
- 禁食与妊娠期糖尿病的关联数据矛盾,与孕妇高血压的数据不足。
- 禁食对子代长期影响现有文献提示可能的不良影响,但需要更多数据。
临床怎么用
- 产科医生应准备讨论现有数据的细微差别,同时展示文化与宗教意识和敏感性,以建立信任关系。
- 提供者应让患者参与共享决策过程,提供包括局限性在内的细微证据回顾和基于临床经验与患者病史的个体化建议。
- 若某些患者选择妊娠期间禁食,提供者应提供医学建议、更密切观察和支持,以减少禁食期间的伤害和困难。
局限性
- 证据质量受禁食定义变异、研究规模与设计及潜在混杂因素的负面影响。
- 关于禁食对子代长期影响,现有文献提示可能的不良影响,但需要更多数据。
- 与妊娠期糖尿病的关联数据矛盾,与孕妇高血压的数据不足。
- 禁食与分娩方式的数据存在矛盾。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Pregnant Muslim women may be religiously exempt from fasting during the Islamic month of Ramadan, especially if there is concern for undue hardship or harm to maternal or fetal health. However, several studies demonstrate that most women still choose to fast during pregnancy and avoid discussing fasting with their providers. A targeted literature review of published studies on fasting during Ramadan and pregnancy or maternal and fetal outcomes was performed. We generally found little to no clinically significant effect of fasting on neonatal birthweight or preterm delivery. Conflicting data exist on fasting and mode of delivery. Fasting during Ramadan has been mainly associated with signs and symptoms of maternal fatigue and dehydration, with a minimal decrease in weight gain. There is conflicting data regarding the association with gestational diabetes mellitus and insufficient data on maternal hypertension. Fasting may affect some antenatal fetal testing indices, including nonstress tests, lower amniotic fluid levels, and lower biophysical profile scores. Current literature on the long-term effects of fasting on offspring suggests possible adverse effects, but more data are required. The quality of evidence was negatively impacted by the variation in defining "fasting during Ramadan" in pregnancy, study size and design, and potential confounders. Therefore, in counseling patients, obstetricians should be prepared to discuss the nuances in the existing data while demonstrating cultural and religious awareness and sensitivity to foster a trusting relationship between patient and provider. We provide a framework for obstetricians and other prenatal care providers to aid in that effort and supplemental materials to encourage patients to seek clinical advice on fasting. Providers should engage patients in a shared decision-making process and offer them a nuanced review of the evidence (including limitations) and individualized recommendations based on clinical experience and patient history. Finally, should certain patients choose to fast while pregnant, providers should offer medical recommendations, closer observation, and support to reduce harm and hardship while fasting.
引用
- Shahawy S, Al Kassab L, Rattani A, et al. Ramadan fasting and pregnancy: an evidence-based guide for the obstetrician. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 36940770. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2023.03.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。