文献速递产科母胎医学

剖宫产决策中的种族偏倚

Racial bias in cesarean decision-making.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM · 2023-03-14

本研究通过在线调查,向产科提供者呈现两个II类胎心监护图形的临床情景,患者种族随机为黑人或白人。总体未发现剖宫产决策的显著种族偏倚,但在一例有剖宫产史的情景中,年龄<40岁和临床经验<10年的提供者在第一个决策点对黑人患者更常选择剖宫产。

要点

  • 在线调查共726名参与者,情景中患者种族随机为黑人或白人。
  • 总体样本未发现剖宫产决策的显著种族偏倚。
  • 有剖宫产史情景中,年龄<40岁和<10年经验的提供者在第一个决策点对黑人患者更常选择剖宫产。

核心结论

  • 年轻和临床经验较少的提供者在产程早期第一个决策点对黑人患者表现出剖宫产决策的种族偏倚,随着产程进展偏倚消失,无剖宫产史情景中未发现偏倚。

研究设计与样本

  • 在线调查研究,包含2个II类胎心监护图形的分娩患者临床情景,患者种族随机为黑人和白人,情景其他内容相同。
  • 参与者在每个情景的3个决策点选择继续产程或行剖宫产,并匿名报告自身人口学特征。
  • 调查通过电子邮件、邮件列表和社交媒体分发给产科提供者,共726名参与者。

主要发现

  • 总体样本未发现剖宫产决策的显著种族偏倚。
  • 在有剖宫产史的情景中,年龄<40岁的提供者(n=322;P=.01)在第一个决策点对黑人患者选择剖宫产的比例高于白人患者。
  • 在有剖宫产史的情景中,临床经验<10年的提供者(n=239;P=.050)在第一个决策点对黑人患者选择剖宫产的比例高于白人患者。
  • 在有剖宫产史的情景中,随着产程进展,黑人患者和白人患者的剖宫产率趋于均衡。

临床怎么用

  • 作者认为这种偏倚可能是提供者培训中使用母胎医学单位网络剖宫产后阴道分娩计算器的结果,该计算器于2007年开发并广泛用于估计剖宫产后阴道分娩成功概率,直到2021年6月才移除种族作为预测因素。
  • 作者建议未来研究应调查这一改变后偏倚是否持续存在,并关注针对这些发现的干预措施。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Category II fetal heart tracing noted during continuous external fetal monitoring is a frequent indication for cesarean delivery in the United States despite its somewhat subjective interpretation. Black patients have higher rates of cesarean delivery and higher rates for this indication. Racial bias in clinical decision-making has been demonstrated throughout medicine, including in obstetrics. OBJECTIVE: We sought to examine if racial bias affects providers' decisions about cesarean delivery for an indication of category II fetal heart tracings. STUDY DESIGN: We constructed an online survey study consisting of 2 clinical scenarios of patients in labor with category II tracings. Patient race was randomized to Black and White; the vignettes were otherwise identical. Participants had the option to continue with labor or to proceed with a cesarean delivery at 3 decision points in each scenario. Participants reported their own demographics anonymously. This survey was distributed to obstetrical providers via email, listserv, and social media. Data were analyzed using chi-square tests at each decision point in the overall sample and in subgroup analyses by various participant demographics. RESULTS: A total of 726 participants contributed to the study. We did not find significant racial bias in cesarean delivery decision-making overall. However, in a scenario of a patient with a previous cesarean delivery, Fisher's exact tests showed that providers <40 years old (n=322; P=.01) and those with <10 years of experience (n=239; P=.050) opted for a cesarean delivery for Black patients more frequently than for White patients at the first decision point. As labor progressed in this scenario, the rates of cesarean delivery equalized across patient race. CONCLUSION: Younger providers and those with fewer years of clinical experience demonstrated racial bias in cesarean delivery decision-making at the first decision point early in labor. Providers did not show racial bias as labor progressed, nor in the scenario with a patient without a previous cesarean delivery. This bias may be the consequence of provider training with the Maternal-Fetal Medicine Unit Network Vaginal Birth After Cesarean Calculator, developed in 2007, and widely used to estimate the probability of successful vaginal birth after a cesarean delivery. This calculator used race as a predictive factor until it was removed in June 2021. Future studies should investigate if this bias persists following this change, while also focusing on interventions to address these findings.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Edwards SE, Class QA, Ford CE, et al. Racial bias in cesarean decision-making. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2023. PMID: 36921720. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2023.100927

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。