产前修复开放性脊柱裂胎儿术前运动水平评估预测出生时运动水平:是时候在咨询中放弃解剖水平了
本研究为观察性研究,纳入2011年3月至2022年5月接受产前修复开放性脊柱裂的单胎妊娠,术前超声评估病变解剖与运动水平,出生时由康复专家评估运动水平。结果显示术前运动水平与出生运动水平中度一致(wκ=0.42),而术前解剖水平与出生运动水平仅轻度一致(wκ=0.07);术前解剖水平越高及术前解剖与运动水平差值越大与运动水平丢失≥2级相关。结论认为产前咨询应采用运动水平而非解剖水平。
要点
- 术前运动水平与出生运动水平中度一致(wκ=0.42;95% CI,0.21-0.63)。
- 术前解剖水平与出生运动水平仅轻度一致(wκ=0.07;95% CI,-0.02-0.15)。
- 术前解剖水平越高及解剖与运动水平差值越大与运动水平丢失≥2级相关。
核心结论
- 产前修复开放性脊柱裂术前胎儿运动水平与出生运动水平中度一致,而术前解剖水平与出生运动水平仅轻度一致。
- 术前与出生评估间运动水平丢失≥2级与更高的术前解剖水平及更大的术前解剖与运动水平差值相关。
- 因此,产前咨询应采用运动水平而非解剖水平。
研究设计与样本
- 观察性研究,纳入2011年3月至2022年5月接受产前修复开放性脊柱裂的单胎妊娠。
- 所有胎儿在孕20-24周行超声评估术前病变运动与解剖水平,产前修复在孕23-26周进行,出生时由康复专家通过体格检查评估运动水平。
- 术前运动与解剖水平在61例胎儿中评估,中位孕周22.7(IQR,21.6-24.4)周;产前修复中位孕周24.6(IQR,23.7-25.7)周;出生运动水平在52例新生儿中评估,9例因失访或胎儿丢失被排除。
主要发现
- 术前运动水平与出生运动水平中度一致(wκ=0.42;95% CI,0.21-0.63),中位差异为0(IQR,-2至9)级。
- 术前解剖水平与出生运动水平仅轻度一致(wκ=0.07;95% CI,-0.02-0.15)。
- 术前解剖水平越高(OR,0.59(95% CI,0.35-0.98);P=0.04)及术前解剖与运动水平差值越大(OR,1.85(95% CI,1.12-3.06);P=0.017)与运动水平丢失≥2级相关。
- 其他评估的超声、手术相关或新生儿变量均与运动水平丢失≥2级无显著关联。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,产前咨询应采用运动水平而非解剖水平。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: First, to investigate the correlation between prenatal presurgery anatomical and motor levels of the lesion with motor level at birth in cases undergoing prenatal repair of open spina bifida and, second, to identify factors leading to a loss of two or more motor levels between the presurgery and postnatal assessments. METHODS: This was an observational study of singleton pregnancies undergoing prenatal repair of open spina bifida, conducted between March 2011 and May 2022. All fetuses underwent an ultrasound assessment at 20-24 weeks of gestation to determine the motor and anatomical levels of the lesion before surgery. The anatomical level of the lesion was defined as the highest open posterior vertebral arch. The motor level was determined by systematic observation of the lower limb movements and was defined as the most distal active muscle present. Prenatal repair was performed at 23-26 weeks. At birth, motor level was assessed by a rehabilitation specialist by physical examination. Cases of intrauterine death or termination of pregnancy and those delivered at other sites were excluded from the neonatal assessment. The agreement between presurgery motor level and motor level at birth, and between presurgery anatomical level and motor level at birth, was assessed using the weighted kappa index (wκ). Logistic regression analysis was used to assess factors leading to a loss of two or more motor levels between the presurgery and postnatal assessments. RESULTS: Presurgery motor and anatomical levels were assessed in 61 fetuses at a median gestational age of 22.7 (interquartile range (IQR), 21.6-24.4) weeks. Prenatal repair was performed at a median gestational age of 24.6 (IQR, 23.7-25.7) weeks. Motor level at birth was assessed in 52 neonates after exclusion of nine fetuses due to loss to follow-up or fetal loss. There was moderate agreement between presurgery motor level and motor level at birth (wκ = 0.42; 95% CI, 0.21-0.63), with a median difference of 0 (IQR, -2 to 9) levels. Factors leading to a loss of two or more motor levels between the presurgery ultrasound assessment and postnatal examination were higher presurgery anatomical level (odds ratio (OR), 0.59 (95% CI, 0.35-0.98); P = 0.04) and larger difference between the anatomical and motor levels before surgery (OR, 1.85 (95% CI, 1.12-3.06); P = 0.017). None of the other ultrasound, surgery-related or neonatal variables assessed was associated significantly with a loss of two or more motor levels. There was slight agreement between the presurgery anatomical level of the lesion and motor level at birth (wκ = 0.07; 95% CI, -0.02 to 0.15). CONCLUSIONS: There is moderate agreement between fetal motor level of the lesion before prenatal repair of open spina bifida and motor level at birth, as opposed to only slight agreement between presurgery anatomical level and motor level at birth. A loss of two or more motor levels between the presurgery and postnatal assessments is associated with a higher presurgery anatomical level and with a larger difference between the presurgery anatomical and motor levels. Consequently, motor level, rather than the anatomical level, should be used for prenatal counseling. © 2023 The Authors. Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Maiz N, Arévalo S, García-Manau P, et al. Presurgery motor level assessment for prediction of motor level at birth in fetuses undergoing prenatal repair of open spina bifida: time to abandon anatomical level in counseling. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 36807360. doi:10.1002/uog.26180
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。