腹腔镜子宫峡部环扎术与McDonald环扎术治疗子宫颈机能不全的母胎结局比较
回顾性分析2010年1月至2020年12月中山大学附属第一医院221例子宫颈机能不全孕妇,按术式及McDonald环扎术史分为MC组54例、有MC史LCC组28例、无MC史LCC组129例。三组活产环扎成功率无显著差异,MC组剖宫产率及费用显著更低,但绒毛膜羊膜炎或宫内感染及胎膜早破发生率显著更高。作者建议CI孕妇首选MC,MC失败者可考虑LCC。
要点
- MC组、有MC史LCC组、无MC史LCC组活产环扎成功率分别为94.4%、82.1%、93.8%,差异无统计学意义(P=0.059)。
- MC组剖宫产率41.2%显著低于有MC史LCC组100.0%和无MC史LCC组100.0%(P<0.001)。
- MC组绒毛膜羊膜炎或宫内感染15.7%、胎膜早破23.5%,均显著高于两LCC组(P均<0.001)。
核心结论
- MC和LCC均为治疗CI的有效方式,两者获活产环扎成功率相近。
- MC具有剖宫产率低、经济、易操作的优势。
- 作者建议CI孕妇首选MC,对于MC失败者可考虑LCC。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性 trial,于中山大学附属第一医院2010年1月至2020年12月开展。
- 共221例行预防性子宫颈环扎术孕妇,按术式及是否有MC史分为MC组(n=54)、有MC史LCC组(n=28)、无MC史LCC组(n=129)。
- 比较三组一般临床资料、妊娠合并症及并发症、妊娠结局。
主要发现
- 妊娠期行子宫颈环扎术比例:MC组100.0%(54/54)vs 有MC史LCC组7.1%(2/28)vs 无MC史LCC组27.1%(35/129),P<0.001。
- 环扎术指征中妊娠中晚期流产史占比:MC组75.9%(41/54)vs 有MC史LCC组89.3%(25/28)vs 无MC史LCC组84.5%(109/129),三组指征占比比较P=0.003。
- 活产环扎成功率:MC组94.4%(51/54)vs 有MC史LCC组82.1%(23/28)vs 无MC史LCC组93.8%(121/129),χ2=5.649,P=0.059。
- 剖宫产率:MC组41.2%(21/51)vs 有MC史LCC组100.0%(23/23)vs 无MC史LCC组100.0%(121/121),P<0.001。
- 环扎术费用中位数:MC组12 169元 vs 有MC史LCC组26 438元 vs 无MC史LCC组27 783元,P<0.001;MC组低于两LCC组。
关键数值与推荐
- 胎位异常发生率:MC组7.8%(4/51)vs 有MC史LCC组17.4%(4/23)vs 无MC史LCC组19.8%(24/121),P均>0.05。
- 胎盘植入发生率:MC组5.9%(3/51)vs 有MC史LCC组13.0%(3/23)vs 无MC史LCC组11.6%(14/121),P均>0.05。
- 子宫破裂发生率:MC组0 vs 有MC史LCC组4.3%(1/23)vs 无MC史LCC组5.8%(7/121),P均>0.05。
- 绒毛膜羊膜炎或宫内感染发生率:MC组15.7%(8/51)vs 有MC史LCC组0 vs 无MC史LCC组0.8%(1/121),P均<0.001。
- 胎膜早破发生率:MC组23.5%(12/51)vs 有MC史LCC组4.3%(1/23)vs 无MC史LCC组0,P均<0.001。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议CI孕妇首选MC,对于MC失败者可考虑LCC。
- 新生儿出生体重、新生儿窒息及转入新生儿重症监护病房比例三组比较差异均无统计学意义(P均>0.05)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To compare the maternal and fetal outcomes of women with cervical insufficiency (CI) undergoing McDonald cerclage (MC) and laparoscopic cervicoisthmic cerclage (LCC), so as to provide evidence for the selection of cerclage methods. Methods: A retrospective trial was carried out in the First Affiliated Hospital of Sun Yat-sen University from January 2010 to December 2020. A total of 221 women who underwent the prophylactic cerclage were divided into MC group (n=54), LCC with MC history group (n=28) and LCC without MC history group (n=129) by the mode of operation and whether the pregnant women who underwent LCC had MC history. General clinical data, pregnancy complications and pregnancy outcomes were compared between the three groups. Results: (1) General clinical data: the proportion of women accepted cervical cerclage during pregnancy in MC group, LCC with MC history group and LCC without MC history group were 100.0% (54/54), 7.1% (2/28) and 27.1% (35/129), respectively (P<0.001). The indications of the three groups showed statistical significance (P=0.003), and the main indication was the history of abortion in the second and third trimester [75.9% (41/54) vs 89.3% (25/28) vs 84.5% (109/129)]. (2) Pregnancy complications: the incidence of abnormal fetal position [7.8% (4/51) vs 17.4% (4/23) vs 19.8% (24/121)], placenta accrete [5.9% (3/51) vs 13.0% (3/23) vs 11.6% (14/121)], uterine rupture [0 vs 4.3% (1/23) vs 5.8% (7/121)] in the MC group were all lower than those in LCC with MC history and LCC without MC history groups. However, there were no statistical significances (all P>0.05). Intrauterine inflammation or chorioamnionitis [15.7% (8/51) vs 0 vs 0.8% (1/121)] and premature rupture of membrane [23.5% (12/51) vs 4.3% (1/23) vs 0] were both significantly higher in MC group than those in LCC with MC history and LCC without MC history groups (all P<0.001). (3) Pregnancy outcomes: the cesarean section rate was significantly lower in MC group (41.2%, 21/51) than that in LCC with MC history group (100.0%, 23/23) and LCC without MC history group (100.0%, 121/121; P<0.001). MC group was associated with lower expenditure than LCC with MC history and LCC without MC history groups (12 169 vs 26 438 vs 27 783 yuan, P<0.001). The success rates of live birth cerclage did not differ significantly in MC (94.4%, 51/54), LCC with MC history (82.1%, 23/28) and LCC without MC history (93.8%, 121/129) groups (χ2=5.649, P=0.059). There was no significant difference in neonatal intensive care unit occupancy, neonatal birth weight and neonatal asphyxia between the three groups (all P>0.05). Conclusions: Both LCC and MC are the treatment choice for women with CI, which may get similar liver birth. However, MC has the advantages of low cesarean section rate, economical and easy operation. Therefore, MC is recommended as the first choice for CI patients, and LCC is for women with failed MC. 目的: 比较McDonald子宫颈环扎术(MC)与腹腔镜子宫峡部环扎术(LCC)治疗子宫颈机能不全(CI)的围产结局,为CI孕妇行子宫颈环扎术手术方式的选择提供依据。 方法: 回顾性分析2010年1月至2020年12月于中山大学附属第一医院分娩的行子宫颈环扎术孕妇211例,根据术式、行LCC孕妇是否有MC史分为MC组(54例)、有MC史LCC组(28例)、无MC史LCC组(129例)。比较3组孕妇的一般临床资料、妊娠合并症及并发症、妊娠结局。 结果: (1)一般临床资料:MC组、有MC史LCC组和无MC史LCC组孕妇于妊娠期行子宫颈环扎术的比例分别为100.0%(54/54)、7.1%(2/28)、27.1%(35/129),3组比较,差异有统计学意义(P<0.001);3组的环扎术指征占比比较,差异有统计学意义(P=0.003),但最主要的环扎术指征均为妊娠中晚期流产史[分别为75.9%(41/54)、89.3%(25/28)、84.5%(109/129)]。MC组、有MC史LCC组及无MC史LCC组获活产环扎成功率分别为94.4%(51/54)、82.1%(23/28)、93.8%(121/129),3组比较,差异无统计学意义(χ2=5.649;P=0.059)。(2)环扎成功孕妇(195例)的妊娠合并症及并发症:与MC组孕妇比较,有MC史LCC组和无MC史LCC组孕妇胎位异常[分别为7.8%(4/51)、17.4%(4/23)和19.8%(24/121)]、胎盘植入[分别为5.9%(3/51)、13.0%(3/23)和11.6%(14/121)、子宫破裂[分别为0、4.3%(1/23)和5.8%(7/121)]的发生率均较高,但分别比较,差异均无统计学意义(P均>0.05)。MC组孕妇绒毛膜羊膜炎或宫内感染(15.7%,8/51)、胎膜早破(23.5%,12/51)的发生率均高于有MC史LCC组[分别为0、4.3%(1/23)]和无MC史LCC组[分别为0.8%(1/121)、0],分别比较,差异均有统计学意义(P均<0.001)。(3)妊娠结局:MC组孕妇的剖宫产率[41.2%(21/51)]显著低于有MC史LCC组[100.0%(23/23)]和无MC史LCC组[100.0%(121/121);P<0.001];其环扎术费用均显著低于有MC史LCC组和无MC史LCC组(中位数分别为12 169、26 438、27 783元;P<0.001)。3组的新生儿出生体重及新生儿窒息、转入新生儿重症监护病房的比例分别比较,差异均无统计学意义(P均>0.05)。 结论: MC和LCC均为治疗CI的有效方式,两者的获活产环扎成功率相近。但MC具有剖宫产率低、经济、易操作的优势。CI孕妇建议首选MC,对于MC失败者可考虑LCC。.
引用
- Deng SQ, Wei YJ, Liang YC, et al. [Comparison of maternal-fetal outcomes between laparoscopic cervicoisthmic cerclage and McDonald cerclage in women with cervical insufficiency]. Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi. 2023. PMID: 36776002. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112141-20220908-00569
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。