剖宫产中的噪声:对产房手术室噪声环境的综合分析及视觉警报降噪方案评估
该研究对2021年2月15日至8月26日期间的剖宫产进行干预前后观察性研究,各纳入156例。所有剖宫产中位声压为61.8 dBA,使用视觉警报后中位噪声降低0.7 dBA(P<.001),但未达到可察觉的3 dB变化,也未减少惊跳事件。
要点
- 剖宫产中位噪声为61.8 dBA,常处于影响沟通和专注的水平,并高于世界卫生组织推荐的安全水平。
- 视觉警报使中位噪声从61.8 dBA降至61.1 dBA(P<.001),但未达临床可察觉的3 dB变化。
- 视觉警报未减少惊跳事件,单独使用视觉警报不太可能是满意的降噪策略。
核心结论
- 剖宫产中记录的噪声强度常处于影响沟通和专注的水平,并高于世界卫生组织推荐的安全水平。
- 尽管噪声降低了0.7 dBA,但该降低未达到可察觉的3 dB变化,也未减少惊跳事件。
- 剖宫产期间单独使用视觉警报不太可能是满意的降噪策略。
研究设计与样本
- 研究为2021年2月15日至2021年8月26日期间开展的干预前后观察性研究,评估引入视觉警报降噪系统前后的剖宫产噪声水平。
- 每个研究阶段各纳入156例。
- 通过声级计分析总体病例中位分贝水平及手术相关阶段的时间段。
- 通过回顾性分析检测能引起人类惊跳反应的噪声快速增加事件(惊跳事件),并量化基线和按病例类型分析频率。
- 中位噪声水平以中位数(四分位距)表示,数据采用非参数双尾检验进行时间段和病例特征间比较。
主要发现
- 所有剖宫产的中位声压为61.8(58.8-65.9)dBA(中位数[四分位距])。
- 全案例时间段中位dBA在新生儿重症监护团队在场时为62.1(60.5-63.9),入住新生儿重症监护病房时为62.0(60.4-63.9),5分钟Apgar评分<7时为62.2(61.1-64.3),多胎妊娠时为62.6(62.0-64.2),术中输卵管绝育时为62.8(61.5-65.1),均显著更高。
- 使用视觉警报与中位噪声水平降低0.7 dBA相关,从61.8(60.6-63.5)降至61.1(59.8-63.7)dBA(P<.001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Cesarean delivery is the most common major surgery worldwide. Noise in healthcare settings leads to impaired communication and concentration, and stress among healthcare providers. Limited information is available about noise at cesarean delivery. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to achieve a comprehensive analysis of noise that occurs during cesarean deliveries. Sound level meters are used to determine baseline noise levels and to describe the frequency of acute noise generated during a cesarean delivery that will cause a human startle response. Secondarily, we aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of a visual alarm system in mitigating excessive noise. STUDY DESIGN: We completed a preintervention/postintervention observational study of noise levels during cesarean deliveries before and after introduction of a visual alarm system for noise mitigation between February 15, 2021 and August 26, 2021. There were 156 cases included from each study period. Sound pressure levels were analyzed by overall case median decibel levels and by time epoch for relevant phases of the operation. Rapid increases in noise events capable of causing a human startle response, "startle events," were detected by retrospective analysis, with quantification for baselines and analysis of frequency by case type. Median noise levels with interquartile ranges are presented. Data are compared between epochs and case characteristics with nonparametric 2-tailed testing. RESULTS: The median acoustic pressure for all cesarean deliveries was 61.8 (58.8-65.9) (median [interquartile range]) dBA (A-weighted decibels). The median dBA for the full case time period was significantly higher in cases with neonatal intensive care unit team presence (62.1 [60.5-63.9]), admission to the neonatal intensive care unit (62.0 [60.4-63.9]), 5-minute Apgar score <7 (62.2 [61.1-64.3]), multiple gestations (62.6 [62.0-64.2]), and intraoperative tubal sterilization (62.8 [61.5-65.1]). The use of visual alarms was associated with a statistically significant reduction of median noise level by 0.7 dBA, from 61.8 (60.6-63.5) to 61.1 (59.8-63.7) dBA (P<.001). CONCLUSION: The noise intensities recorded during cesarean deliveries were commonly at levels that affect communication and concentration, and above the safe levels recommended by the World Health Organization. Although noise was reduced by 0.7 dBA, the reduction was not clinically significant in reaching a discernible amount (a 3-dB change) or in reducing "startle events." Isolated use of visual alarms during cesarean deliveries is unlikely to be a satisfactory noise mitigation strategy.
引用
- Whitham MD, Casali JG, Smith GK, et al. Noise in cesarean deliveries: a comprehensive analysis of noise environments in the Labor and Delivery operating room and evaluation of a visual alarm noise abatement program. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2023. PMID: 36781121. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2023.100887
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。