「2021 AAGL子宫内膜异位症分类」的外部验证:一项回顾性队列研究
本研究在澳大利亚悉尼的多中心回顾性纳入317例患者,由3名独立观察者分配AAGL手术分期(1-4期)和手术复杂度(A-D级),以验证AAGL分期系统对手术复杂度的预测能力并与rASRM分期比较。AAGL分期与rASRM预测AAGL级别的加权kappa均为0.48,低于参考论文的0.62,各期预测对应级别的敏感度和特异度表现不一,AAGL系统外部验证表现不佳且未优于rASRM,结果提示该系统不可推广。
要点
- AAGL分期与rASRM预测AAGL手术级别的加权kappa均为0.48,两者无差异。
- AAGL分期1期预测A级敏感度98.5%、特异度64.3%;2期预测B级敏感度31.2%、特异度90.5%。
- 3期预测C级敏感度12.3%、特异度94.1%;4期预测D级敏感度95.65%、特异度88.10%。
核心结论
- AAGL分期与AAGL手术复杂度之间为弱至中度一致性。
- 在本外部验证中,AAGL系统在所有关键指标上表现不如参考论文,也未像参考论文那样优于rASRM。
- 结果提示该系统不可推广。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性诊断准确性研究,在澳大利亚悉尼的多中心开展。
- 共317例患者(2016年1月至2021年10月)纳入最终分析。
- 由3名独立观察者分配AAGL手术分期(1-4期)作为指数试验,手术复杂度水平(A-D级)作为参考标准,最终分析采用3名观察者中最准确者的结果。
主要发现
- AAGL分期与rASRM预测AAGL级别的总体加权kappa分别为0.48和0.48(无差异)。
- 该一致性弱于参考论文报告的加权kappa 0.62。
- 1期预测A级的敏感度98.5%、特异度64.3%、阳性预测值66.3%、阴性预测值98.3%。
- 2期预测B级的敏感度31.2%、特异度90.5%、阳性预测值27.0%、阴性预测值92.1%。
- 3期预测C级的敏感度12.3%、特异度94.1%、阳性预测值59.3%、阴性预测值60.7%;4期预测D级的敏感度95.65%、特异度88.10%、阳性预测值38.60%、阴性预测值99.62%。
关键数值与推荐
- A vs B/C/D(切点9)的ROC曲线下面积为0.87。
- A/B vs C/D(切点16)的ROC曲线下面积为0.78。
- A/B/C vs D(切点22)的ROC曲线下面积为0.94。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: Externally validate the American Association of Gynecologic Laparoscopists (AAGL) staging system against surgical complexity and compare diagnostic accuracy with revised American Society for Reproductive Medicine (rASRM) stage, as was done in original publication. DESIGN: Retrospective, diagnostic accuracy study. SETTING: Multicenter (Sydney, Australia). PATIENTS: A total of 317 patients (January 2016-October 2021) were used in the final analysis. INTERVENTIONS: A database of patients with coded surgical data was analyzed. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Three independent observers assigned an AAGL surgical stage (1-4) as the index test and surgical complexity level (A-D) as the reference standard. Results from the most accurate of the 3 observers were used in the final analysis. The weighted kappa score for the overall performance of AAGL stage and rASRM to predict AAGL level was 0.48 and 0.48, respectively (no difference). This represents weaker agreement with AAGL level than was observed in the reference paper, which reported a weighted kappa of 0.62. Diagnostic accuracy (sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, and negative predictive value) for stage 1 to predict level A was 98.5%, 64.3%, 66.3%, and 98.3%; stage 2 to predict level B 31.2%, 90.5%, 27.0%, and 92.1 %; stage 3 to predict level C 12.3%, 94.1%, 59.3%, and 60.7%; stage 4 to predict level D 95.65%, 88.10%, 38.60%, and 99.62%. Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve for A vs B/C/D (cut point 9) was 0.87, A/B vs C/D (cut point 16) was 0.78, and A/B/C vs D (cut point 22) was 0.94. CONCLUSION: There was weak to moderate agreement between AAGL stage and AAGL surgical complexity level. Across all key indicators, the AAGL system did not perform as well in this external validation, nor did it outperform rASRM as it did in the reference paper. Results suggest the system is not generalizable.
引用
- Mak J, Eathorne A, Leonardi M, et al. External Validation of the "2021 AAGL Endometriosis Classification": A Retrospective Cohort Study. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 36621635. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2022.12.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。