孕12-13周先天性心脏病的产前检出:假阴性病例的详细分析
该回顾性观察研究分析了意大利热那亚Gaslini儿童医院2015年1月至2021年12月孕早期超声病例,低危组6879例妊娠(7167胎儿)中30例先天性心脏病(CHD),主要CHD筛查敏感度为58.3%;高危组201例中46例CHD,早期胎儿超声心动图敏感度为93.5%。假阴性原因分为人为因素、技术因素和声窗因素,作者建议注意胎儿后脊柱评估、胎儿内脏位置评估时间及彩色/能量多普勒设置个体化。
要点
- 低危妊娠孕早期筛查对主要CHD的敏感度为58.3%(7/12)。
- 高危妊娠早期胎儿超声心动图对CHD的敏感度为93.5%(43/46)。
- 假阴性原因包括人为因素、技术因素和声窗受损。
核心结论
- 低危妊娠早期心脏筛查对主要CHD的敏感度低于60%,部分源于CHD自然史,似乎部分与人为错误和图像质量技术问题有关。
- 假阴性诊断相关因素可分为人为错误、技术因素和声窗受损三类。
- 作者建议:适当评估胎儿后脊柱;在评估胎儿内脏位置时花费足够时间;彩色/能量多普勒设置适应个体病例。
- 对于母体肥胖和双胎妊娠病例,应采用较低的阈值将可疑病例转诊至早期胎儿超声心动图。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性观察研究,分析2015年1月至2021年12月在意大利热那亚Gaslini儿童医院胎儿医学与外科部接受孕早期末超声检查的病例。
- 研究人群包括接受标准孕早期联合筛查的低危妊娠和因联合试验阳性或地区社区医院怀疑胎儿异常而转诊至该单位的高危妊娠。
- 共评估7080例妊娠,其中低危6879例(7167胎儿),高危201例。
主要发现
- 低危组超声孕周12+0至13+6周(头臀长50.1-84.0 mm),高危组11+5至13+6周(头臀长45.1-84.0 mm)。
- 低危组30胎儿患CHD(15例主要和15例次要),患病率4.2/1000(主要CHD 2.1/1000);筛查超声怀疑9/30例CHD(7/15主要CHD)。
- 排除预期不会在筛查视图上检测到的病例后,主要CHD检出7/12例,敏感度58.3%。
- 高危组46胎儿患CHD(44例主要和2例次要),检出43例,早期胎儿超声心动图敏感度93.5%;排除2例不太可能在孕早期筛查中检测到的病例后为97.7%。
- 24例假阴性中11例预期可在筛查视图上发现,人为错误(图像解读和/或扫描方法)涉及全部11例,技术因素(彩色优先(色彩平衡功能)过度和/或平面对齐不正确)存在2例,声窗受损(与母体肥胖和/或双胎妊娠相关)作为协同因素存在5/11例。
关键数值与推荐
- 低危组主要CHD筛查敏感度58.3%(7/12)。
- 高危组早期胎儿超声心动图敏感度93.5%(43/46),排除2例后97.7%。
- 低危组CHD患病率4.2/1000,主要CHD 2.1/1000。
- 假阴性原因分类:人为因素、技术因素、声窗因素。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议:适当评估胎儿后脊柱。
- 作者建议:在评估胎儿内脏位置时花费足够时间。
- 作者建议:彩色/能量多普勒设置适应个体病例。
- 作者建议:对于母体肥胖和双胎妊娠病例,采用较低阈值将可疑病例转诊至早期胎儿超声心动图。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: To report on the early detection of congenital heart disease (CHD) in low- and high-risk populations managed at our hospital; and perform a detailed analysis of false-negative diagnoses, in order to derive possible recommendations on how to reduce their incidence. METHODS: This was a retrospective observational study analyzing cases which underwent an ultrasound examination at the end of the first trimester at the Fetal Medicine and Surgery Unit of Gaslini Children's Hospital, Genoa, Italy, in the period January 2015 to December 2021. The study population included both low-risk pregnancies that underwent standard first-trimester combined screening and high-risk ones referred to our unit because of a positive combined test or suspicion of fetal anomalies raised in a regional community hospital. For each case, the following variables were retrieved and analyzed: number of fetuses, maternal body mass index, gestational age at first-trimester screening, whether the pregnancy was low or high risk, nuchal translucency thickness (normal or > 99th centile), type of CHD, associated extracardiac anomalies, karyotype and pregnancy outcome. For low-risk pregnancies, suspicion of CHD was also recorded. In low-risk cases, sonographic cardiac screening comprised evaluation of the four-chamber view (grayscale and color/power Doppler) and three-vessel-and-trachea view (color/power Doppler). High-risk cases underwent early fetal echocardiography. False-negative cases were categorized according to likely cause of the missed diagnosis, as follows: human factor; technical factor; acoustic-window factor. RESULTS: Gestational age at ultrasound ranged from 12 + 0 to 13 + 6 weeks (crown-rump length (CRL), 50.1-84.0 mm) in the low-risk group and from 11 + 5 to 13 + 6 weeks (CRL, 45.1-84.0 mm) in the high-risk group. Over the 7-year study period, 7080 pregnancies were evaluated in the first trimester. Of these, 6879 (7167 fetuses) were low-risk and 201 were high-risk cases. In the low-risk group, there were 30 fetuses with CHD (including 15 major and 15 minor CHD), yielding a prevalence of 4.2/1000 (2.1/1000 for major CHD). Nine of the 30 CHD cases were suspected at screening ultrasound (7/15 major CHD). Excluding cases in which the CHD would not be expected to be associated with a modification of the screening views and would therefore not be detectable on screening ultrasound, 7/12 cases of major CHD were detected, corresponding to a sensitivity of 58.3%. Among the 201 high-risk cases, there were 46 fetuses with CHD (including 44 major and two minor CHD), of which 43 were detected, corresponding to a sensitivity for early fetal echocardiography of 93.5%, or 97.7% if the two cases that were unlikely to be detectable on first-trimester screening were excluded. Analysis of the 11 (of 24) false-negative cases that would be expected to be picked up on screening views revealed that human error (image interpretation and/or scanning approach) was involved in all 11 cases and technical factors (excessive color priority (color-balance function) and/or incorrect plane alignment) were present in two. There was impairment of the acoustic window (associated with maternal obesity and/or twin gestation) as a cofactor in five of the 11 cases. CONCLUSIONS: The sensitivity for detection of major CHD of early cardiac screening in low-risk pregnancy is under 60%, partly due to the natural history of CHD and, it seems, partly relating to human error and technical issues with image quality. Factors associated with false-negative diagnoses may be categorized into three types: human error, technical factors and acoustic-window impairment. We recommend: appropriate assessment with fetal posterior spine; that sufficient time is spent on assessment of the fetal situs; and that color/power Doppler settings are adapted to the individual case. A lower threshold for referring doubtful cases for early fetal echocardiography should be adopted in cases of maternal obesity and in twin gestation. © 2022 The Authors. Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Bottelli L, Franzè V, Tuo G, et al. Prenatal detection of congenital heart disease at 12-13 gestational weeks: detailed analysis of false-negative cases. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 36240512. doi:10.1002/uog.26094
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。