「做」亲属关系:异性恋父母通过供精受孕体验非遗传性亲职
研究对13对荷兰异性恋夫妇(男方不育、通过供精受孕)在2018年9月至2019年1月进行深度半结构化访谈,用主题分析探讨其如何协商非遗传性亲职与亲属关系。父母通过「做」亲属关系来协调遗传与环境的重要性,多数认为遗传对亲职体验和亲子联结不重要,但重视遗传用于制造父子相似性及确保同胞间完整遗传关系。结论提示咨询时应考虑这些矛盾。
要点
- 多数父母认为遗传对亲职体验和亲子联结不重要。
- 多数父母重视遗传用于制造父子相似性及确保同胞间完整遗传关系。
- 部分男性因供精者与孩子的遗传联系而担忧其未来角色及自身非遗传父亲地位。
核心结论
- 父母在供精受孕中体验遗传作用的多种矛盾,并以不同方式「做」亲属关系。
- 咨询计划供精受孕的准父母时应考虑这些方面。
研究设计与样本
- 定性深度半结构化访谈研究,于2018年9月至2019年1月进行。
- 纳入13对荷兰异性恋夫妇(男方不育、通过供精受孕获得孩子)的双方伴侣。
- 访谈问题基于文献和供精受孕领域专家的临床经验。
- 访谈转录后采用主题分析。
主要发现
- 所有父母通过「做」亲属关系来协商非遗传性亲职,权衡遗传与环境在供精受孕和非遗传性亲职中的重要性。
- 多数父母认为遗传对体验亲职、与孩子建立联结及供精者未来理想角色不重要。
- 多数父母认为遗传对制造父子相似性及希望所有孩子使用同一供精者以确保他们之间完整遗传关系重要。
- 基于供精者与孩子的遗传联系,部分男性担忧供精者在孩子未来生活中的角色及其对自身非遗传父亲地位的影响。
- 少数女性认为遗传与供精者可能遗传的疾病相关。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,在咨询计划供精受孕的准父母时需考虑父母在遗传作用上的多种矛盾及「做」亲属关系的不同方式。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: How do Dutch heterosexual parents who achieved parenthood through donor conception navigate non-genetic parenthood and kinship? DESIGN: A qualitative in-depth semi-structured interview study was performed between September 2018 and January 2019 with both partners of 13 Dutch heterosexual couples where the male partner suffered from infertility and who conceived a child with the help of a sperm donor. Interview questions were based on literature and clinical experiences of experts in the field of donor conception. Interviews were transcribed and analysed using thematic analysis. RESULTS: All parents navigated non-genetic parenthood through 'doing' kinship: they negotiated the importance of nature versus nurture with regards to donor conception and non-genetic parenthood. Most parents perceived genetics as irrelevant for experiencing parenthood, bonding with their children and the preferred role of the donor in their future lives. Yet most of them found genetics relevant for generating similarities between the father and the child, and for wanting the same donor for all their children to ensure a full genetic relation among them. Additionally, based on the donor's genetic bond with the child, some men were anxious about the donor's role in the child's future life and the consequences for their position as a non-genetic father. A few women perceived genetics as relevant in terms of possible inherited illnesses from the donor. CONCLUSIONS: Parents experienced several ambiguities regarding the role of genetics in donor conception and navigated 'doing' kinship in various ways. These aspects need to be taken into consideration during the counselling of prospective parents planning to conceive with donor conception.
引用
- Siermann M, Visser M, Schrijvers A, et al. 'Doing' kinship: heterosexual parents' experiences of non-genetic parenthood through donor conception. Reprod Biomed Online. 2022. PMID: 36270931. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2022.09.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。