患者对骶棘韧带子宫固定术或改良曼彻斯特手术的偏好:一项离散选择实验
在荷兰八家医院,对符合初次手术且希望保留子宫的子宫脱垂女性开展标签离散选择实验,共完成137份问卷(1233个选择集)。49%的选择集选骶棘韧带子宫固定术(SH),51%选改良曼彻斯特手术(MM);28%的女性始终选择同一手术。排除该组后分析882个选择集,MM被选53%、SH被选47%,MM偏好可能与标签效应有关。
要点
- 137份离散选择实验(1233个选择集)中,SH被选49%,MM被选51%。
- 39名(28%)女性始终选择同一种手术。
- 排除始终选同一手术者后,MM被选53%、SH被选47%,MM偏好可能与标签效应有关。
核心结论
- 女性对MM或SH的偏好似乎几乎均等,偏好的多样性支持个体化医疗的重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 标签离散选择实验(DCE),在荷兰八家医院开展。
- 研究对象为符合初次手术且希望保留子宫的子宫脱垂女性。
- 问卷属性包括治疗成功(SH水平:84%、89%、94%;MM水平:89%、93%、96%)、性交困难(水平:0%、5%、10%)、宫颈狭窄(水平:1%、6%、11%)和严重臀部疼痛(水平:0%、1%)。
- 每位女性完成九个选择集,数据采用多项logit模型分析。
主要发现
- 共完成137份DCE(1233个选择集),SH被选49%,MM被选51%。
- 39名(28%)女性始终选择同一种手术。
- 排除始终选同一手术者后分析882个选择集,MM被选53%、SH被选47%,MM偏好可能与标签效应有关。
- 选择MM时除标签外,性交困难与决策相关;选择SH时所有属性均与决策相关。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为女性对MM或SH的偏好似乎几乎均等,偏好的多样性支持个体化医疗的重要性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To investigate women's preference for modified Manchester (MM) or sacrospinous hysteropexy (SH) as surgery for uterine prolapse. DESIGN: Labelled discrete choice experiment (DCE). SETTING: Eight Dutch hospitals. POPULATION: Women with uterine prolapse, eligible for primary surgery and preference for uterus preservation. METHODS: DCEs are attribute-based surveys. The two treatment options were labelled as MM and SH. Attributes in this survey were treatment success ( levels SH: 84%, 89%, 94%; levels MM: 89%, 93%, 96%), dyspareunia (levels: 0%, 5%, 10%), cervical stenosis (levels: 1%, 6%, 11%) and severe buttock pain (levels: 0%, 1%). A different combination of attribute levels was used in each choice set. Women completed nine choice sets, making a choice based on attribute levels. Data were analysed in multinomial logit models. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Women's preference for MM or SH. RESULTS: 137 DCEs were completed (1233 choice sets). SH was chosen in 49% of the choice sets, MM in 51%. Of all women, 39 (28%) always chose the same surgery. After exclusion of this group, 882 choice sets were analysed, in which women preferred MM, likely associated with a labelling effect, i.e. description of the procedure, rather than the tested attributes. In that group, MM was chosen in 53% of the choice sets and SH in 47%. When choosing MM, next to the label, dyspareunia was relevant for decision-making. For SH, all attributes were relevant for decision-making. CONCLUSIONS: The preference of women for MM or SH seems almost equally divided. The variety in preference supports the importance of individualised healthcare.
引用
- Schulten SFM, Essers B, Notten KJB, et al. Patient's preference for sacrospinous hysteropexy or modified Manchester operation: A discrete choice experiment. BJOG. 2022. PMID: 36043332. doi:10.1111/1471-0528.17280
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。