母胎医学专科培训项目主任对首届虚拟面试学员入学后虚拟面试的看法
本研究通过横断面在线调查评估虚拟面试对母胎医学专科培训项目全国住院医师匹配计划结果的影响。80名项目主任(81.6%)回复,虚拟面试与现场面试学员在匹配排名、满足面试期望及项目主任满意度方面无差异,多数项目主任支持继续虚拟面试。
要点
- 虚拟面试与现场面试学员在匹配排名上无差异
- 两类学员在临床能力、技术技能等面试期望上无差异
- 95.8%项目主任对虚拟面试体验评价为符合或好于预期
核心结论
- 母胎医学专科培训项目主任未发现虚拟面试与现场面试学员在全国住院医师匹配计划结果上存在差异,且两类学员在培训第一年满足面试期望方面无差异,多数项目主任认为虚拟面试流程有效并支持继续虚拟面试。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面在线调查,于2021年10月26日通过母胎医学学会发放给所有母胎医学专科培训项目主任,约在首届虚拟面试学员入学4个月后。
- 共98名项目主任中80名(81.6%)回复。
- 项目主任被问及最终现场面试年与首个虚拟面试年之间的全国住院医师匹配计划排名名单信息,并评估第一年培训4个月时对学员的体验与基于虚拟面试的期望及上一届现场面试学员同期体验的比较。
- 对于每年招收超过1名学员的项目,项目主任需针对每年全国住院医师匹配计划排名名单上排名最高的学员回答所有问题。
- 调查数据匿名收集并安全存储,采用描述性统计和双变量分析比较组间差异,所有检验为双侧,显著性水平设为P<.05。
主要发现
- 虚拟面试候选人与现场面试候选人在项目全国住院医师匹配计划排名名单上的匹配学员位置无差异。
- 在匹配流程之外招收内部或外部候选人以及未填满专科培训岗位的项目数量无差异。
- 项目主任报告虚拟面试学员与现场面试学员在满足基于面试的临床能力期望方面无差异(P=.67)。
- 项目主任报告两类学员在满足基于面试的技术技能期望(P=.96)、研究潜力或经验期望(P=.54)、专业素养和团队合作能力期望(P=.72)以及与被部门和专科培训项目兼容性期望(P=.67)方面均无差异。
- 70名(95.8%)项目主任报告虚拟面试体验好于预期、略好于预期或符合预期;未来年份多数项目主任倾向于继续完全虚拟面试(n=41;56.2%)或虚拟与现场面试混合(n=27;37.0%),仅5名(6.9%)希望恢复完全现场面试。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The first class of virtually interviewed maternal-fetal medicine fellows has matriculated into their training programs. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to evaluate the impact of virtual interviews on the outcomes of the National Resident Matching Program within our subspecialty. We assessed maternal-fetal medicine fellowship program directors' experience with their fellows who interviewed virtually as compared with experience with the previous year's fellows who interviewed in-person. In addition, we evaluated program directors' satisfaction with the virtual interview process and their preferred mode of interviewing for future cycles. STUDY DESIGN: A cross-sectional online survey was distributed through the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine to all maternal-fetal medicine fellowship program directors on October 26, 2021, approximately 4 months after the first virtually interviewed fellow matriculated into the training program. Program directors were asked to provide information about their National Resident Matching Program rank list between their final in-person and first virtual years. Program directors were asked to evaluate their experience with their fellow 4 months into the first year of fellowship compared with their expectations based on their virtual interview, and their experience at that same point in fellowship of their last fellow who interviewed in-person. For all questions, in programs with >1 fellow per year, program directors were asked to answer the questions for the fellow ranked highest on their National Resident Matching Program rank list for each year. Survey data were collected anonymously and stored securely. Descriptive statistics and bivariate analyses were performed to compare groups, all tests were 2-sided, and the significance level was set at P<.05. RESULTS: A total of 80 of 98 (81.6%) program directors responded. There was no difference in the position of the matched fellow on the program's National Resident Matching Program rank list between candidates interviewed in-person and candidates interviewed virtually. There was also no difference in the number of programs that took an internal or external candidate outside of the National Resident Matching Program match process or that did not fill their fellowship positions. Program directors reported no difference between fellows interviewed virtually and those interviewed in-person in meeting interview-based performance expectations with regard to clinical capabilities (P=.67), technical skills (P=.96), research potential or experience (P=.54), professionalism and ability to be a team player (P=.72), and compatibility with the division and fellowship program (P=.67). Program directors' overall experience with virtual interviews was favorable: 70 (95.8%) program directors reported that the virtual interview experience was better than expected, slightly better than expected, or as expected. In future years, most program directors favored ongoing exclusively virtual interviewing (n=41; 56.2%) or a hybrid of virtual and in-person interviews (n=27; 37.0%). Only 5 (6.9%) reported a desire to return to exclusively in-person interviewing. CONCLUSION: Maternal-fetal medicine fellowship program directors did not identify a difference in National Resident Matching Program results between fellows interviewed virtually and those interviewed in-person. Furthermore, there was no difference between these fellows in meeting interview-based expectations in the first year of the training program. Most program directors found the virtual interview process to be effective and support ongoing virtual interviews.
引用
- Rhoades JS, Lewkowitz AK, Gyamfi-Bannerman C, et al. Maternal-fetal medicine fellowship program director perspective on virtual interviews following matriculation of the first virtual interview class. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2022. PMID: 35914735. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2022.100699
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。