疑似宫颈肿瘤女性的宫颈管取样:诊断准确性研究的系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析比较宫颈管刷与宫颈管刮匙在疑似宫颈肿瘤女性中的诊断准确性、不适感和取样不足率。共纳入7项研究(4项诊断队列研究、3项随机临床试验),参考标准为锥切或子宫切除。汇总敏感度刷81% vs 刮匙70%,特异度刷73% vs 刮匙81%,证据质量低;取样不足风险比刮匙vs刷为2.53(95%CI 0.58-11.0;P=.215)。结论认为基于低质量证据,两种方法在诊断准确性、取样不足率和不良反应方面无差异,但女性特征和诊断路径差异限制外部 validity。
要点
- 宫颈管刷汇总敏感度81%(95%CI 48-95),刮匙70%(95%CI 42-89),证据质量低。
- 宫颈管刷汇总特异度73%(95%CI 36-93),刮匙81%(95%CI 56-94),证据质量低。
- 刮匙对比刷取样不足风险比2.53(95%CI 0.58-11.0;P=.215),低确定性证据。
核心结论
- 基于低质量证据,宫颈管刷与宫颈管刮匙在诊断准确性、取样不足率和不良反应方面无差异。
- 女性特征和由此产生的诊断路径差异使外部 validity 有限。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与诊断准确性Meta分析,检索4个文献数据库(2022年6月9日),无日期或语言限制。
- 纳入7项研究:4项诊断队列研究和3项随机临床试验;参考标准为锥切或子宫切除。
- 采用双变量随机效应模型进行诊断准确性Meta分析,使用QUADAS-2评估偏倚风险,GRADE评级证据质量。
主要发现
- 宫颈管刷汇总敏感度81%(95%CI 48-95;799名女性;7项研究;低质量证据);宫颈管刮匙汇总敏感度70%(95%CI 42-89;761名女性;7项研究;低质量证据)。
- 宫颈管刷汇总特异度73%(95%CI 36-93;799名女性;7项研究;低质量证据);宫颈管刮匙汇总特异度81%(95%CI 56-94;761名女性;7项研究;低质量证据)。
- 宫颈管刮匙对比宫颈管刷的取样不足风险比为2.53(95%CI 0.58-11.0;P=.215;低确定性证据)。
- 两项研究报告了患者不适感:一项发现宫颈管刷组不适感更少,另一项发现无差异。
关键数值与推荐
- 汇总敏感度:宫颈管刷81%(95%CI 48-95)vs 宫颈管刮匙70%(95%CI 42-89),证据质量低。
- 汇总特异度:宫颈管刷73%(95%CI 36-93)vs 宫颈管刮匙81%(95%CI 56-94),证据质量低。
- 取样不足风险比:宫颈管刮匙对比宫颈管刷2.53(95%CI 0.58-11.0;P=.215),低确定性证据。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 部分研究在患者选择、流程和时间方面存在高偏倚风险和高适用性关注。
- 证据质量低。
- 女性特征和由此产生的诊断路径差异使外部 validity 有限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Endocervical sampling in women with suspected cervical neoplasia can be performed by either endocervical brush or endocervical curettage. This study aimed to estimate the diagnostic accuracy, discomfort, and number of inadequate samples with either test. DATA SOURCES: Four bibliographic databases were searched on June 9, 2022, with no date or language restrictions. STUDY ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA: We included all diagnostic studies and randomized clinical trials that compared the endocervical brush with endocervical curettage in women with an indication for colposcopy. METHODS: The review protocol was registered on the International Prospective Register of Systematic Reviews (PROSPERO) (CRD42021222406). Two authors independently screened studies, extracted data, performed the risk-of-bias assessment (Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-2), and rated the certainty of the evidence using the Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development, and Evaluation (GRADE) methodology. A meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy was performed using a bivariate random-effects model. RESULTS: We included 7 studies: 4 diagnostic cohort studies and 3 randomized clinical trials. The reference standard was conization or hysterectomy. Risk of bias and concern about applicability were high for some of the studies in patient selection and flow and timing. Overall pooled sensitivity was 81% (95% confidence interval, 48-95; 799 women; 7 studies; low quality of evidence) for endocervical brush and 70% (95% confidence interval, 42-89; 761 women; 7 studies; low quality of evidence) for endocervical curettage. Overall pooled specificity was 73% (95% confidence interval, 36-93; 799 women; 7 studies; low quality of evidence) for endocervical brush and 81% (95% confidence interval, 56-94; 761 women; 7 studies; low quality of evidence) for endocervical curettage. The risk ratio for inadequate samples with endocervical curettage compared with endocervical brush was 2.53 (95% confidence interval, 0.58-11.0; P=.215; low-certainty evidence). Two studies reported on patient discomfort; one found less discomfort in the endocervical brush group, and the other found no difference. CONCLUSION: No difference was found between endocervical brush and endocervical curettage in diagnostic accuracy, inadequate sampling rate, and adverse effects based on low-quality of evidence. Variation in the characteristics of women and the resulting diagnostic pathways make the external validity limited.
引用
- Damkjær M, Laursen JB, Petersen LK, et al. Endocervical sampling in women with suspected cervical neoplasia: a systematic review and meta-analysis of diagnostic test accuracy studies. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2022. PMID: 35934116. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2022.07.036
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。