以细胞学分流用于HPV初筛的替代策略
基于芬兰随机HPV筛查试验数据,事后构建五种HPV筛查联合细胞学分流算法、一种无分流HPV筛查算法和一种细胞学筛查算法,比较其灵敏度与特异度等指标;两轮重复随访的HPV算法在灵敏度与特异度间平衡最佳,但所有HPV分流算法均较细胞学算法增加阴道镜转诊量与过度诊断。
要点
- HPV阳性直接转诊阴道镜灵敏度最高(94%)但特异度最低(93%)。
- 两次重复随访的HPV算法灵敏度84%、特异度98%,平衡最佳。
- 所有HPV分流算法均较细胞学算法增加阴道镜转诊量与过度诊断。
核心结论
- 灵敏度与特异度平衡最佳的是含两次重复随访检测的HPV算法。
- 所有含细胞学分流的HPV算法均较细胞学算法增加阴道镜转诊量并导致过度诊断。
研究设计与样本
- 基于芬兰随机HPV筛查试验数据的事后分析,构建五种HPV筛查联合细胞学分流算法、一种无分流HPV筛查算法和一种细胞学筛查算法。
- 计算所有算法在第一轮和第二轮筛查中检出CIN II+的灵敏度、特异度、阳性预测值、阴道镜转诊率和累积灵敏度。
主要发现
- 第一轮筛查中,HPV阳性直接转诊阴道镜的灵敏度为94%、特异度为93%。
- HPV阳性者一次重复筛查随访的灵敏度为86%、特异度为97%,两次重复筛查随访分别为84%和98%。
- 细胞学阴性HPV阳性者无随访的HPV算法灵敏度为65-82%、特异度为98-99%。
- 细胞学算法的灵敏度为69%、特异度为99%。
- 与第一轮相比,第二轮筛查灵敏度较低,特异度相似或更高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: Primary HPV screening programmes for cervical cancer have been implemented in many European countries using a cytology triage. Nonetheless, the optimal cytology triage strategy for minimizing the harms and maximizing the benefits is yet unclear. We identified key characteristics of different algorithms for HPV screening with cytology triage. METHODS: Using the Finnish randomized HPV screening trial data, we formulated five post-hoc algorithms for HPV screening with a cytology triage, one for HPV screening without a triage and one for cytology screening. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value, colposcopy referral rate and cumulative sensitivity for CIN II + s detected during the first and second screening rounds of the trial were calculated for all algorithms. RESULTS: In the first screening round, direct referral of HPV positives to colposcopy led to the highest sensitivity (94%) accompanied by the lowest specificity (93%). Following HPV positives up with one repeat screen showed 86% sensitivity and 97% specificity. The corresponding figures with two repeat screens were 84% and 98%. In HPV algorithms, where cytology negative HPV positive individuals had no follow-up, the sensitivities were 65-82% and the specificities 98-99%. The Cytology algorithm had a low sensitivity (69%) with a high specificity (99%). Compared to the first round, the second-round sensitivities were lower and specificities similar or higher. CONCLUSIONS: The best balance between sensitivity and specificity was achieved by an HPV algorithm with two repeated follow-up tests. However, all HPV algorithms with cytology triage increased colposcopy volume more than the cytology algorithm and thus provoked overdiagnosis.
引用
- Vahteristo M, Heinävaara S, Anttila A, et al. Alternative cytology triage strategies for primary HPV screening. Gynecol Oncol. 2022. PMID: 35963790. doi:10.1016/j.ygyno.2022.07.023
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。