文献速递妇科

基于单张图像与两分钟时间序列阴道镜图像的阴道镜印象准确性和可重复性比较

Comparison of accuracy and reproducibility of colposcopic impression based on a single image versus a two-minute time series of colposcopic images.
PubMed 文献 · Gynecol Oncol · 2022-08-23

该研究比较了醋酸应用后1分钟单张图像与2分钟内17张连续时间序列图像对阴道镜印象的准确性和可重复性。在4640例图像合格患者中,仅24.4%被单张图像视觉评估正确分类,个体阴道镜医师准确度低,Youden指数范围0.07至0.24。使用时间序列增加了被分类为正常的图像比例,无论组织学结果如何。

要点

  • 单张图像视觉评估仅正确分类24.4%的患者(64例癌症中11%;605例CIN3中31%;558例CIN2中22.4%;3412例<CIN2中23.9%)。
  • 个体阴道镜医师准确度低,Youden指数范围为0.07至0.24。
  • 使用时间序列增加了被分类为正常的图像比例,无论组织学结果如何。

核心结论

  • 即使呈现显示两分钟醋酸白过程的17张图像时间序列,阴道镜图像的视觉评估仍存在显著差异。
  • 研究者目前正在评估深度学习图像评估是否能辅助分类。

研究设计与样本

  • 约5000例使用DYSIS阴道镜系统进行的阴道镜检查被分为10个随机组,每组分配给一位独立专家阴道镜医师。
  • 阴道镜医师首先对1分钟时的单张二维图像进行分类,然后对2分钟内17张连续图像的时间序列进行分类,类别为「正常」、「不确定」、「高级别」或「癌症」。
  • 评分与组织学诊断进行比较;此外,5位阴道镜医师回顾了200张单张图像和200个时间序列的子集,以评估评分者内和评分者间信度。

主要发现

  • 在4640例图像合格的患者中,仅24.4%被单张图像视觉评估正确分类(64例癌症中11%;605例CIN3中31%;558例CIN2中22.4%;3412例<CIN2中23.9%)。
  • 个体阴道镜医师准确度低;Youden指数(敏感度加特异度减一)范围为0.07至0.24。
  • 使用时间序列增加了被分类为正常的图像比例,无论组织学结果如何。
  • 评分者内信度为中等(加权kappa=0.64);评分者间信度为一般(加权kappa=0.26)。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: Colposcopy is an important part of cervical screening/management programs. Colposcopic appearance is often classified, for teaching and telemedicine, based on static images that do not reveal the dynamics of acetowhitening. We compared the accuracy and reproducibility of colposcopic impression based on a single image at one minute after application of acetic acid versus a time-series of 17 sequential images over two minutes. METHODS: Approximately 5000 colposcopic examinations conducted with the DYSIS colposcopic system were divided into 10 random sets, each assigned to a separate expert colposcopist. Colposcopists first classified single two-dimensional images at one minute and then a time-series of 17 sequential images as 'normal,' 'indeterminate,' 'high grade,' or 'cancer'. Ratings were compared to histologic diagnoses. Additionally, 5 colposcopists reviewed a subset of 200 single images and 200 time series to estimate intra- and inter-rater reliability. RESULTS: Of 4640 patients with adequate images, only 24.4% were correctly categorized by single image visual assessment (11% of 64 cancers; 31% of 605 CIN3; 22.4% of 558 CIN2; 23.9% of 3412 < CIN2). Individual colposcopist accuracy was low; Youden indices (sensitivity plus specificity minus one) ranged from 0.07 to 0.24. Use of the time-series increased the proportion of images classified as normal, regardless of histology. Intra-rater reliability was substantial (weighted kappa = 0.64); inter-rater reliability was fair ( weighted kappa = 0.26). CONCLUSION: Substantial variation exists in visual assessment of colposcopic images, even when a 17-image time series showing the two-minute process of acetowhitening is presented. We are currently evaluating whether deep-learning image evaluation can assist classification.

来源:Gynecol Oncol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Perkins R, Jeronimo J, Hammer A, et al. Comparison of accuracy and reproducibility of colposcopic impression based on a single image versus a two-minute time series of colposcopic images. Gynecol Oncol. 2022. PMID: 36008184. doi:10.1016/j.ygyno.2022.08.001

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。