《早产临床诊断与治疗指南(2014)》执行现状调查与分析
该研究采用横断面问卷调查328名产科医师对《早产临床诊断与治疗指南(2014)》的执行情况,以指南推荐为标准答案计算执行率。结果显示总体执行良好,但医院等级和职称是独立影响因素,二级医院和初级职称者执行较差,未来需加强基层医院和初级职称医师培训。
要点
- 328名产科医师问卷得分为(7.6±1.6)分,高执行力组占76.2%(250/328),低执行力组占23.8%(78/328)。
- 二级医院比三级医院得分低、执行力差(OR=0.42,95%CI 0.23~0.77),正高职称比初级职称得分高、执行力好(OR=5.33,95%CI 2.35~12.07)。
- 回答所在医院早产儿能够存活孕周为22周者仅占3.4%(11/328),回答28周者占比最高,为44.5%(146/328)。
核心结论
- 产科医师对《指南》总体执行情况良好,对部分指南推荐条款的认识还有待提高。
- 未来需加强对基层医院和初级职称医师的培训。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为横断面研究,于2021年10—11月采用自行设计的结构式调查问卷,对产科医师(包括江苏省医学会围产医学分会委员、中华医学会妇产科学分会产科学组成员)就《指南》执行现状进行调查。
- 共回收有效问卷328份,问卷总分为12分,以得分7分为界值分为低执行力组(<7分)和高执行力组(≥7分)。
主要发现
- 328例产科医师的得分为(7.6±1.6)分,其中高执行力组250例(76.2%,250/328),低执行力组78例(23.8%,78/328)。
- 宫缩抑制剂短疗程使用执行率为97.0%(318/328),早产儿出生后晚断脐执行率为87.8%(288/328),胎膜完整的早产患者是否使用抗生素执行率为86.6%(284/328),均超过80%。
- 多因素logistic回归分析显示,医院等级、职称是《指南》执行优劣的独立影响因素(P均<0.05);二级医院比三级医院得分低、执行力差(OR=0.42,95%CI 0.23~0.77,P=0.005),正高职称比初级职称得分高、执行力好(OR=5.33,95%CI 2.35~12.07,P<0.001)。
- 回答「您所在医院早产儿能够存活的孕周」时,回答22周能存活者仅占3.4%(11/328),回答28周能存活者占比最高,为44.5%(146/328);三级医院能存活的早产儿孕周早于二级医院(P<0.05),正高职称者回答能存活的早产儿孕周早于低级职称者(P<0.05)。
关键数值与推荐
- 宫缩抑制剂短疗程使用执行率为97.0%(318/328)。
- 早产儿出生后晚断脐执行率为87.8%(288/328)。
- 胎膜完整的早产患者是否使用抗生素执行率为86.6%(284/328)。
- 以问卷得分7分为界值,<7分为低执行力组,≥7分为高执行力组。
临床怎么用
- 产科医师对《指南》总体执行情况良好。
- 未来需加强对基层医院和初级职称医师的培训。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Objective: To understand the actual situation of the implementation of "Diagnosis and therapy guideline of preterm birth(2014)", "Guideline" for short, by front-line obstetricians, and to provide reference for the further update and supplement of the "Guideline". Methods: This study designed a structured questionnaire for the prominent problems in the prevention and treatment of preterm birth, which was determined by the expert team drafting the "Guideline". In October to November 2021, a cross-sectional survey was conducted among obstetricians, including members of the Perinatal Medicine Branch of Jiangsu Medical Association and the Obstetrics Subgroup,Chinese society of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Chinese Medical Association, on the implementation status of the "Guideline". The recommendations of the "Guideline" were used as standard answers to determine the implementation rate. A total of 328 valid questionnaires were collected. The total score of the questionnaire was 12 points. The questionnaire was divided into low executive ability group (<7 points) and high executive ability group (≥7 points) with a score of 7 as the threshold value, and the differences in baseline information such as hospital grade and professional title between the two groups were compared. Results: The score of 328 obstetricians was (7.6±1.6) points, including 250 (76.2%, 250/328) in the high execution group and 78 (23.8%, 78/328) in the low execution group. The execution rates of "the use of uterine contraction inhibitors for short courses"[97.0% (318/328)], "late umbilical cord breakage after birth of premature infants"[87.8% (288/328)] and "should preterm patients with intact membranes be treated with antibiotics"[86.6% (284/328)] were all over 80%, indicating good implementation. Multiple logistic regression analysis showed that hospital grade and professional title were independent factors influencing the performance of the "Guideline"(all P<0.05), and secondary hospitals had lower scores and worse execution than tertiary hospitals (OR=0.42, 95%CI: 0.23-0.77; P=0.005). Senior titles had higher scores and better execution than junior titles (OR=5.33, 95%CI: 2.35-12.07; P<0.001). When answering the question "gestational week at which premature infants could survive in your hospital", only 3.4% (11/328) answered 22 weeks, and 44.5% (146/328) answered 28 weeks, accounted for the highest proportion. The gestational week of surviving premature infants in tertiary hospitals was earlier than that in secondary hospitals (P<0.05). The gestational week of surviving premature infants answered by senior titles was earlier than that of junior titles (P<0.05). Conclusions: Obstetricians generally have a good implementation of the "Guideline", and their understanding of some recommended clauses in the guidelines needs to be improved. In the future, training of primary hospitals and physicians with junior titles should be strengthened. 目的: 了解一线产科医师执行《早产临床诊断与治疗指南(2014)》(简称《指南》)的实际情况,为《指南》的进一步更新、补充提供参考。 方法: 本研究围绕早产防治的突出问题,自行设计结构式调查问卷,并由《指南》起草专家团队确定,于2021年10—11月采用横断面研究方法对产科医师,包括江苏省医学会围产医学分会委员、中华医学会妇产科学分会产科学组成员,就《指南》执行现状进行问卷调查,以《指南》推荐作为标准答案计算执行率,共回收有效问卷328份。问卷总分为12分,以得分7分为界值,分为低执行力组(<7分)和高执行力组(≥7分),比较两组在医院等级、医师职称等基线信息方面的差异。 结果: 328例产科医师的得分为(7.6±1.6)分,其中,高执行力组250例(76.2%,250/328),低执行力组78例(23.8%,78/328)。对宫缩抑制剂短疗程使用[执行率为97.0%(318/328)]、早产儿出生后晚断脐[执行率为87.8%(288/328)]、胎膜完整的早产患者是否使用抗生素[执行率为86.6%(284/328)]回答正确率均超过80%,执行率良好。多因素logistic回归分析显示,医院等级、职称是《指南》执行优劣的独立影响因素(P均<0.05),二级医院比三级医院得分低、执行力差(OR值=0.42,95%CI为0.23~0.77),正高职称比初级职称得分高、执行力好(OR值=5.33,95%CI为2.35~12.07)。在回答“您所在医院早产儿能够存活的孕周”问题时,回答22周能存活者仅占3.4%(11/328),回答28周能存活者占比最高,为44.5%(146/328);三级医院能存活的早产儿孕周早于二级医院(P<0.05),正高职称者回答能存活的早产儿孕周早于低级职称者(P<0.05)。 结论: 产科医师对《指南》总体执行情况良好,对部分指南推荐条款的认识还有待提高,未来需加强对基层医院和初级职称医师的培训。.
引用
- Li TS, Liu Z, Yang HX, et al. [Investigation and analysis of the implementation status of "Diagnosis and therapy guideline of preterm birth (2014)"]. Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi. 2022. PMID: 35775253. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112141-20211203-00714
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。