外科医生对子宫切除术质量指标自我反思的准确性
该研究为2016至2019年加拿大八家医院84名妇科外科医生的横断面队列研究,通过在线调查让医生估计6个月内子宫切除术的手术量、微创率和并发症率,并与实际值比较。结果显示手术量和微创率的估计与实际中等相关,并发症率弱相关;医生总体低估并发症率,且低估者实际并发症率更高。
要点
- 手术量估计与实际中等相关(τ=0.46,P<.001),微创率中等相关(τ=0.52,P<.001),并发症率弱相关(τ=0.14,P=.080)。
- 医生总体低估并发症率(中位差值-7.0%,95%CI -11.0%至-3.5%,P<.001),手术量和微创率估计准确。
- 低估并发症率的医生平均并发症率33.7%,高于估计准确者12.1%和高估者7.7%(均P<.001),且更可能接受过专科培训(P<.001)。
核心结论
- 主治妇科外科医生对自身并发症率的反思不准确,低估并发症率最严重的医生实际并发症率高于同行。
研究设计与样本
- 2016至2019年加拿大八家医院妇科外科医生的横断面队列研究,共纳入84名外科医生,通过在线调查估计6个月内子宫切除术的手术量、微创率和并发症率。
主要发现
- 手术量估计与实际中等相关(τ=0.46,P<.001),微创率中等相关(τ=0.52,P<.001),并发症率弱相关(τ=0.14,P=.080)。
- 医生低估并发症率(中位差值-7.0%,95%CI -11.0%至-3.5%,P<.001),手术量估计准确(中位差值1.0,95%CI 0.0-2.5,P=.082),微创率估计准确(中位差值4.0%,95%CI -4.5%至10.0%,P=.337)。
- 低估并发症率的医生平均并发症率33.7%,高于估计准确者12.1%(P<.001)和高估者7.7%(P<.001),且更可能接受过专科培训(P<.001)。
关键数值与推荐
- 手术量估计与实际相关τ=0.46(P<.001),微创率τ=0.52(P<.001),并发症率τ=0.14(P=.080)。
- 并发症率中位差值-7.0%(95%CI -11.0%至-3.5%,P<.001),手术量中位差值1.0(95%CI 0.0-2.5,P=.082),微创率中位差值4.0%(95%CI -4.5%至10.0%,P=.337)。
- 低估并发症率组平均并发症率33.7%,估计准确组12.1%,高估组7.7%(组间比较均P<.001)。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the accuracy of gynecologic surgeons' self-reflection across hysterectomy case volume, proportion of cases performed using a minimally invasive approach (minimally invasive rate), and complication rate and to assess whether accuracy is associated with specific surgeon or practice characteristics. METHODS: This was a cross-sectional cohort study of gynecologic surgeons at eight Canadian hospitals between 2016 and 2019. Surgeons estimated case volume, minimally invasive rate, and complication rate for hysterectomies for a 6-month period using an online survey. Kendall's tau-beta correlation coefficient (τ) measured association between estimated and actual performance. Differences (delta) between each surgeon's estimated and actual performance were calculated. The central tendency of differences among the cohort was represented by a median (median delta) and compared with 0 (perfect accuracy) using the Wilcoxon signed rank test. Differences in characteristics between surgeons classified as underestimators, accurate estimators, and overestimators by tertile of delta were evaluated using analysis of variance and χ2 tests. RESULTS: Eighty-four surgeons across eight hospitals were included. Association between estimated and actual performance was moderate for case volume (τ=0.46, P<.001) and minimally invasive rate (τ=0.52, P<.001) and weak for complication rate (τ=0.14, P=.080). Surgeons underestimated their complication rate (median delta -7.0%, 95% CI -11.0% to -3.5%, P<.001) but accurately estimated case volume (median delta 1.0, 95% CI 0.0-2.5, P=.082) and minimally invasive rate (median delta 4.0%, 95% CI -4.5% to 10.0%, P=.337). Surgeons who underestimated their complication rates had higher average complication rates (33.7%) than those who estimated accurately (12.1%, P<.001) or overestimated (7.7%, P<.001) and were more likely to be fellowship-trained (P<.001). CONCLUSION: Attending gynecologic surgeons inaccurately reflect on their complication rates, and those who most underestimate their complication rates have higher rates than their peers.
引用
- Milman T, Murji A, Matelski J, et al. Accuracy of Surgeon Self-Reflection on Hysterectomy Quality Metrics. Obstet Gynecol. 2022. PMID: 35849454. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000004841
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。