Geri时差成像系统半自动标注可靠性的研究
本研究评估Geri® Assess 2.0时差成像软件标注胚胎动力学事件和识别异常表型的可靠性。对34名女性的513个卵母细胞进行标注,比较软件与人工标注的胚胎评分。结果显示12个事件的不一致率均有显著差异,软件仅在42.1%的胚胎中给出与人工标注相同的评分,人工校正后一致性升至66.0%。
要点
- Assess 2.0对12个动力学事件的检出率范围为0%至94.4%,与人工标注不一致率均有显著差异。
- Assess 2.0对55.2%的卵母细胞至少一个事件需胚胎学家验证。
- 297个胚胎中仅125个(42.1%)评分与人工标注一致,校正后为66.0%。
核心结论
- Assess 2.0与人工标注在动力学标注上存在显著差异,未能检测直接分裂事件且反裂检出率低,强调临床实施前验证时差成像标注软件的重要性,人工验证Assess 2.0输出对准确数据解读仍必不可少。
研究设计与样本
- 使用Assess 2.0对胚胎进行原核出现与消失、进展至2、3、4、5、6细胞阶段及三个囊胚阶段的标注,并记录反裂和直接分裂表型,随后以盲法进行人工标注,比较Assess 2.0与人工标注的胚胎评分。
- 共纳入34名女性的513个卵母细胞。
主要发现
- Assess 2.0与人工标注在10个动力学事件及直接分裂和反裂共12个事件中的检出率范围为0%至94.4%。
- 所有12个事件的不一致对百分比均有显著差异(P值范围0.036至<0.0001)。
- Assess 2.0的敏感度范围为68.2%至94.4%,特异度范围为63.8%至97.3%。
- Assess 2.0对55.2%的评估卵母细胞至少一个事件要求胚胎学家验证。
- 人工标注评分的297个胚胎中,Assess 2.0仅125个(42.1%)评分相同,人工校正后与人工标注评分的一致性升至66.0%。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为这些发现强调临床实施前验证时差成像标注软件的重要性。
- 作者认为人工验证Assess 2.0输出对准确数据解读仍必不可少。
局限性
- Assess 2.0未能检测直接分裂事件且反裂检出率低是进一步局限。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: What is the reliability of Geri® Assess 2.0 software time-lapse technology for annotating kinetic events and identifying abnormal phenotypes in preimplantation human embryos? DESIGN: Embryos were annotated using Assess 2.0 for the appearance and fading of pronuclei, and for progression to the 2-, 3-, 4-, 5- and 6-cell stages and to three blastocyst stages. Identification of reverse cleavage and direct cleavage phenotypes was also recorded. Manual annotation was undertaken after these events in a blinded fashion. Embryo scores were compared between Assess 2.0 and manual annotation. RESULTS: A total of 513 oocytes from 34 women were included. Detection rates for Assess 2.0 versus manual annotation among the 10 kinetic events and including direct cleavage and reverse cleavage ranged between 0% and 94.4%. The percentage of discordant pairs was significantly different for all 12 events analysed (P-value range 0.036 to <0.0001). The sensitivity of Assess 2.0 ranged from 68.2% to 94.4% and specificity ranged from 63.8% to 97.3%. Assess 2.0 called for verification by the embryologist for at least one event in 55.2% of oocytes assessed. Of the 297 embryos scored by manual annotation, Assess 2.0 assigned the same score for only 125 (42.1%), although after manual corrections, concordance with manual annotation scores was raised to 66.0%. CONCLUSIONS: The results reveal striking differences between Assess 2.0 and manual annotation for kinetic annotations. Failure of Assess 2.0 to detect direct cleavage events and the low detection rate of reverse cleavage are further limitations. These collective findings highlight the importance of validating time-lapse annotation software before clinical implementation. Manual verification of Assess 2.0 outputs remains essential for accurate data interpretation.
引用
- Vandame J, Fossard C, Filali M, et al. Investigation of the reliability of semi-automatic annotation by the Geri time-lapse system. Reprod Biomed Online. 2022. PMID: 35570177. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2022.02.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。