未成年人生育力保存中亲子分歧的应对:范围综述与伦理考量
该范围综述检索多个数据库,最终纳入35项研究,探讨性腺毒性治疗前生育力保存中亲子分歧的存在、原因及处理建议。主题分析识别出青少年参与决策意愿、部分家长不愿让子女参与、未成年人比家长更倾向生育力保存、跨性别未成年人有独特分歧原因四个主题,以及未成年人最佳利益、开放未来权、未成年人自主权和父母自主权四项伦理原则。
要点
- 性腺毒性治疗前提供生育力保存已被视为标准照护。
- 青少年通常希望参与生育力保存决策,部分家长不愿让子女参与。
- 未成年人可能比家长更倾向于生育力保存。
核心结论
- 亲子关于生育力保存的分歧在临床实践中确实存在,但目前缺乏明确的解决指南。
- 综述识别出与分歧相关的四个一般主题和四项伦理原则,可指导临床医生应对此类分歧。
研究设计与样本
- 范围综述,检索PubMed/Medline、Embase和Cochrane Library,检索于2021年2月进行并于2021年8月更新。
- 共筛选755篇文献,118项研究进行全文审查,最终纳入35项研究。
- 纳入研究设计包括定量和定性研究、病例研究、伦理分析和评论。
主要发现
- 7项研究讨论家长或儿童希望其意见如何被纳入,11项研究提供亲子分歧存在的证据,4项研究讨论特定病例中分歧的处理,21项研究提供处理亲子分歧的一般建议。
- 青少年通常希望参与生育力保存决策;部分家长不愿让子女参与;未成年人可能比家长更倾向于生育力保存;跨性别未成年人及其家长可能有独特的分歧原因。
- 识别出的伦理原则为:未成年人最佳利益、开放未来权、未成年人自主权和父母自主权。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Offering fertility preservation (FP) prior to gonadotoxic therapy, including cancer care and gender-affirming treatment, is now considered standard of care. Periodically, parents and children disagree about whether to pursue FP. However, it is unknown how often this occurs and how disagreement is handled when it arises. Moreover, there is no clear guidance on how to resolve these difficult situations. OBJECTIVE AND RATIONALE: The purpose of this scoping review is to provide an overview of available research evidence about parent-child disagreement regarding FP in order to establish that disagreement occurs in practice, understand the basis for disagreement and explore suggestions for how such disputes could be resolved. Based on our findings, we offer a discussion of the ethical principles at stake when disagreement occurs, which can be used to guide clinicians' approaches when these challenging scenarios present. SEARCH METHODS: A comprehensive literature search was run in several databases, including PubMed/Medline, Embase and the Cochrane Library. The search was performed in February 2021 and updated in August 2021. Articles were included in the final review if they discussed how parents or children wanted their views on FP taken into account, presented evidence that parent-child discordance regarding FP exists, discussed how to handle disagreement in a particular case or offered general suggestions for how to approach parent-child discordance about FP. Studies were excluded if the patients were adult only (age 18 years and older), pertained to fertility-sparing treatments (e.g. gonad shielding, gonadopexy) rather than fertility-preserving treatments (e.g. testicular tissue cryopreservation, ovarian tissue cryopreservation, oocyte cryopreservation or sperm cryopreservation) or explored the views of clinicians but not patients or parents. Meta-synthesis was used to synthesize and interpret data across included studies and thematic analysis was used to identify common patterns and themes. OUTCOMES: In total, 755 publications were screened, 118 studies underwent full-text review and 35 studies were included in the final review. Of these studies, 7 discussed how parents or children wanted their opinions to be incorporated, 11 presented evidence that discordance exists between parents and children regarding FP, 4 discussed how disagreement was handled in a particular case and 21 offered general suggestions for how to approach parent-child disagreement. There was a range of study designs, including quantitative and qualitative studies, case studies, ethical analyses and commentaries. From the thematic analysis, four general themes regarding FP disagreement emerged, and four themes relating to the ethical principles at stake in parent-child disagreement were identified. The general themes were: adolescents typically desire to participate in FP decision-making; some parents prefer not to involve their children; minors may feel more favorably about FP than their parents; and transgender minors and their parents may have unique reasons for disagreement. The ethical principles that were identified were: minor's best interest; right to an open future; minor's autonomy; and parental autonomy. WIDER IMPLICATIONS: This study offers an overview of available research on the topic of parent-child disagreement regarding FP and discusses the ethical considerations at stake when disagreement occurs. The findings can be used to inform guidance for clinicians presented with FP disagreement in practice.
引用
- Bayefsky M, Vieira D, Caplan A, et al. Navigating parent-child disagreement about fertility preservation in minors: scoping review and ethical considerations. Hum Reprod Update. 2022. PMID: 35468184. doi:10.1093/humupd/dmac019
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。