文献速递产科母胎医学

转诊系统中不同转诊时机对重度子痫前期妊娠结局的影响

[Impact of different referral timing on the pregnancy outcomes of severe pre-eclampsia in the referral system].
PubMed 文献 · Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi · 2022-01-01

该临床观察研究分析2020年1月至2021年10月北京大学第三医院接受转诊并治疗后终止妊娠的159例重度子痫前期孕妇,按转诊时临床阶段及五色系风险分类分组比较母儿结局。结果发现转诊临床阶段越晚,重度子痫前期严重并发症发生率越高、转诊至终止妊娠间隔越短;发现子痫前期预警因素后转诊是延缓重度子痫前期严重并发症发生的独立保护因素,发现预警因素及诊断子痫前期后转诊均为延缓重度子痫前期发生和减少早发子痫前期的保护因素。

要点

  • 转诊临床阶段越晚,重度子痫前期严重并发症发生率越高,转诊至终止妊娠间隔越短。
  • 发现子痫前期预警因素后转诊是延缓重度子痫前期严重并发症发生的独立保护因素。
  • 发现预警因素及诊断子痫前期后转诊均为延缓重度子痫前期发生和减少早发子痫前期的保护因素。

核心结论

  • 转诊系统中不同转诊时机是影响重度子痫前期母儿结局的关键因素之一。
  • 发现子痫前期预警因素或诊断子痫前期后及时转诊可以减少早发子痫前期,延缓重度子痫前期发生时间及减少其严重并发症。
  • 子痫前期临床发展衍变复杂,转诊时机以临床具体情形为主优于模式化的限定性转诊。

研究设计与样本

  • 临床观察研究,纳入2020年1月至2021年10月北京大学第三医院接受转诊并治疗后终止妊娠的159例重度子痫前期孕妇。
  • 按转诊时临床阶段分为SPE-C组38例、a-SPE组72例、a-PE组15例、Warn-s组34例。
  • 按高危孕产妇专案管理五色系风险分类分为红橙组113例、黄色组46例。

主要发现

  • SPE-C组严重并发症发生率显著高于其他3组,转诊至终止妊娠间隔显著短于其他3组(P均<0.05)。
  • Warn-s组转诊孕周早于其他3组(P均<0.05),其重度子痫前期发生孕周、妊娠终止孕周、严重并发症发生孕周均在妊娠34周以后,晚于a-SPE组及SPE-C组(P均<0.05)。
  • Warn-s组孕34周前重度子痫前期发生率、孕34周前严重并发症发生率、孕34周前妊娠终止率、新生儿重症监护病房入住率、新生儿重症监护病房入住时长、孕28周前妊娠放弃率均显著低于a-SPE组和SPE-C组,活婴出院率为100%,显著高于a-SPE组和SPE-C组(P均<0.05)。
  • 黄色组重度子痫前期发生孕周、严重并发症发生孕周、妊娠终止孕周均晚于红橙组,其孕34周前重度子痫前期发生率、严重并发症发生率、孕34周前严重并发症发生率、孕34周前妊娠终止率均低于红橙组,新生儿重症监护病房入住率、入住时长、孕28周前妊娠放弃率均少于红橙组,活婴出院率高于红橙组(P均<0.05)。
  • 多因素回归分析显示,发现子痫前期预警因素后转诊是延缓重度子痫前期严重并发症发生的独立保护因素(P<0.05);发现预警因素后转诊及诊断子痫前期后转诊均为延缓重度子痫前期发生和减少早发子痫前期的保护因素(P均<0.05)。

关键数值与推荐

  • 159例中红橙组113例(71.1%,113/159),黄色组46例(28.9%,46/159)。
  • 黄色组46例中6例发生重度子痫前期严重并发症(Warn-s组4例、a-PE组2例),17例(37.0%,17/46)在孕34周前终止妊娠(Warn-s组12例、a-PE组5例),23例(50.0%,23/46)在孕34周前发生重度子痫前期(Warn-s组17例、a-PE组6例)。

临床怎么用

  • 原文结论认为发现子痫前期预警因素或诊断子痫前期后及时转诊可减少早发子痫前期、延缓重度子痫前期发生及减少严重并发症。
  • 原文结论认为转诊时机以临床具体情形为主优于模式化的限定性转诊。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Objective: To explore the impact of different referral timing on postponing early-onset pre-eclampsia (PE), postponing severe pre-eclampsia (SPE), reducing SPE severe complications and improving maternal and neonatal outcomes by analyzing the pregnancy outcomes of SPE patients who were referred from primary hospitals to tertiary referral center in the referral system. Methods: The clinical data of 159 SPE patients who were referred from primary hospitals, treated and then terminated their pregnancy in Peking University Third Hospital from January 2020 to October 2021, were observed and analyzed in this clinical observational study. According to the clinical stage of PE at the time of referral, they were divided into four groups: 38 cases were referred after onset of SPE severe complications (SPE-C group), 72 cases were referred after onset of SPE (a-SPE group), 15 cases were referred after onset of PE (a-PE group) and 34 cases were referred after detection of PE early warning-signs (Warn-s group). And then these 159 cases were divided into different color groups according to the project management system for high-risk pregnant women. Patients of Red color (highest risk) and Orange color (higher risk) were required to be referred to tertiary hospitals (Red-Orange group, 113 cases), and patients of Yellow color (high risk) could be treated under tertiary hospitals (Yellow group, 46 cases). The maternal and neonatal outcomes of different referral timings were analyzed and compared. Results: (1) Pregnancy outcomes of different referral timings grouped by PE clinical stage at the time of referral: the later the referral timing, the higher the rate of SPE severe complications, the shorter the interval from referral to termination of pregnancy. The rate of SPE severe complications in the SPE-C group was significantly higher than those of the other three groups, and the interval from referral to termination of pregnancy in the SPE-C group was significantly shorter than those of the other three groups (all P<0.05). The referral gestational age of Warn-s group was earlier than those of the other three groups (all P<0.05). The average gestational ages for onset of SPE, termination of pregnancy, and onset of SPE severe complications were all after 34 gestational weeks, and were later than those of a-SPE group and SPE-C group; the rates of SPE onset before 34 gestational weeks, SPE severe complications onset before 34 gestational weeks, terminating pregnancy before 34 gestational weeks, neonatal intensive care unit (NICU) hospitalization, and pregnancy giving up before 28 gestational weeks were lower than those of a-SPE group and SPE-C group, the length of NICU stay was shorter than those of a-SPE group and SPE-C group, and its rate of take-home-babies was 100%, significantly higher than those in a-SPE group and SPE-C group (all P<0.05). The gestational ages for onset of SPE and termination of pregnancy in a-PE group were later than those in a-SPE group and SPE-C group, the rates of SPE onset before 34 gestational weeks, terminating pregnancy before 34 gestational weeks, and NICU hospitalization were lower than those of a-SPE group and SPE-C group, the length of NICU stay was shorter than those of a-SPE group and SPE-C group (all P<0.05). (2) Pregnancy outcomes of different referral timings grouped by the color classification of PE clinical characteristics: among the 159 cases of SPE, 113 cases (71.1%, 113/159) were in the Red-Orange group which were required to be referred to tertiary hospitals, and 46 cases (28.9%, 46/159) were in the Yellow group,which were not in the range of referral requirements, but actually referred to the tertiary hospital and eventually developed SPE. Gestational ages for onset of SPE, termination of pregnancy, and onset of SPE severe complications in the Yellow group were later than those of the Red-Orange group, while the rates of SPE onset before 34 gestational weeks, SPE severe complications onset before 34 gestational weeks, terminating pregnancy before 34 gestational weeks, NICU hospitalization, and pregnancy giving up before 28 gestational weeks were lower than those of the Red-Orange group, the length of NICU stay was shorter than that of the Red-Orange group, and its rate of take-home-babies was higher than that in the Red-Orange group (all P<0.05). (3) Analysis of different clinical referral timings in the Yellow group: among these 159 SPE patients, 46 cases (28.9%, 46/159) would be excluded from the range of referral requirements which belonged to the Yellow color grade, but 6 cases still developed SPE severe complications (4 cases in Warn-s group and 2 cases in a-PE group), 17 cases were terminated pregnancy before 34 weeks of gestation (12 cases in Warn-s group and 5 cases in a-PE group), and 23 cases developed SPE before 34 weeks of gestation (17 cases in Warn-s group and 6 cases in a-PE group). (4) Multivariate analysis: referral after detection of PE early warning signs was the independent protective factor for postponing the onset of SPE severe complications (P<0.05). Referral after detection of PE early warning signs and referral after onset of PE were both protective factors for postponing the onset of SPE and early-onset PE (all P<0.05). Conclusions: Different referral timing in the referral system is one of the key points that affect the maternal and neonatal outcomes of SPE. Referral after detection of PE early warning signs and timely referral after onset of PE would reduce early-onset PE, postpone the onset of SPE and reduce the severe complications of SPE. The clinical development and evolution of PE is really complicated, and referral based on specific clinical situations is better than referral based on fixed mode. 目的: 分析转诊系统内不同临床转诊时机由基层医院转诊至三级医疗中心的重度子痫前期(SPE)孕妇的母儿结局,探讨转诊时机对延缓早发子痫前期、减少SPE及其严重并发症发生和改善母儿结局的影响。 方法: 通过临床观察研究,对2020年1月至2021年10月北京大学第三医院接受转诊并治疗后终止妊娠的159例SPE孕妇的临床资料进行分析。按转诊时的临床阶段分为发生SPE严重并发症后转诊38例(SPE-C组)、诊断SPE后转诊72例(a-SPE组)、诊断子痫前期后转诊15例(a-PE组)以及发现PE预警因素后转诊34例(Warn-s组)。再根据“高危孕产妇专案管理制度”五色系风险分类将159例转诊孕妇进行五色系分组,红色(高风险)及橙色(较高风险)为要求转诊至三级医院诊疗(红橙组,113例),黄色(一般风险)可在三级以下医院诊疗(黄色组,46例)。分析比较不同转诊时机的母儿结局及转诊时机对妊娠结局的影响。 结果: (1)临床阶段分组:159例转诊孕妇中,转诊临床阶段越晚,SPE严重并发症的发生率越高,转诊至终止妊娠间隔越短。SPE-C组的严重并发症发生率显著高于其他3组,转诊至终止妊娠间隔显著短于其他3组(P均<0.05)。Warn-s组的转诊孕周早于其他3组(P均<0.05),SPE发生孕周、妊娠终止孕周、SPE严重并发症发生孕周均在妊娠34周以后,显著晚于a-SPE组及SPE-C组(P均<0.05);并且孕34周前SPE发生率、孕34周前SPE严重并发症发生率、孕34周前妊娠终止率、新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)入住率、NICU入住时长、孕28周前妊娠放弃率均显著低于a-SPE组和SPE-C组;活婴出院率为100%,显著高于a-SPE组和SPE-C组(P均<0.05)。a-PE组的SPE发生孕周和妊娠终止孕周也显著晚于a-SPE组及SPE-C组(P均<0.05);孕34周前SPE发生率、孕34周前妊娠终止率、NICU入住率、NICU入住时长显著低于a-SPE组及SPE-C组(P均<0.05)。(2)五色系风险分组:按照妊娠风险五色系分类转诊要求,黄色组不在转诊范围内,但实际转诊后最终发生SPE。黄色组的SPE发生孕周、严重并发症发生孕周、妊娠终止孕周均晚于红橙组(P均<0.05),其孕34周前SPE发生率、SPE严重并发症发生率、孕34周前SPE严重并发症发生率、孕34周前妊娠终止率均低于红橙组,NICU入住率、NICU入住时长、孕28周前妊娠放弃率均少于红橙组,活婴出院率高于红橙组(P均<0.05)。(3)黄色组临床转诊时机分析:159例转诊孕妇中有46例(28.9%,46/159)可能排除在转诊范围外,属于五色系黄色风险分类,其中有6例发生严重并发症,其中4例在Warn-s组,2例在a-PE组;17例(37.0%,17/46)在孕34周前终止妊娠,其中12例在Warn-s组,5例在a-PE组;23例(50.0%,23/46)在孕34周前发生SPE,其中17例在Warn-s组,6例在a-PE组。(4)多因素回归分析:发现子痫前期预警因素后转诊是延缓SPE严重并发症发生的独立保护因素(P<0.05);发现子痫前期预警因素后转诊以及诊断子痫前期后转诊均为延缓SPE发生和减少早发子痫前期发生的保护因素(P均<0.05)。 结论: 转诊系统中不同转诊时机是影响母儿结局的关键因素之一;发现子痫前期预警因素或诊断子痫前期后及时转诊可以减少早发子痫前期,可以延缓SPE发生时间及减少SPE严重并发症;子痫前期临床发展衍变复杂,转诊时机以临床具体情形为主优于模式化的限定性转诊。.

来源:Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Lin XY, Yang Z, Shi FQ, et al. [Impact of different referral timing on the pregnancy outcomes of severe pre-eclampsia in the referral system]. Zhonghua Fu Chan Ke Za Zhi. 2022. PMID: 35385953. doi:10.3760/cma.j.cn112141-20211211-00729

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。