在绵羊模型中,胎儿脊柱裂修复的防水性改善了神经保护
在验证的胎儿绵羊脊柱裂模型中,与未修复组相比,防水性多层修复组在出生后1-2天MRI上后脑疝完全逆转比例更高(100% vs 14%),脑脊液漏更低(14% vs 100%),后肢运动功能和脑组织学更优;非防水修复组未达到同等神经保护水平。
要点
- 防水性修复组神经保护评分4/4者5/7,未修复组0/7,非防水修复组1/7。
- 防水修复组后脑疝完全逆转100%,非防水修复组86%但无统计学意义,未修复组14%。
- 术中皮肤修复质量评分≥2/3与结局改善相关,但与防水性测试结果不一致,不能互换使用。
核心结论
- 防水性多层胎儿脊柱裂修复在绵羊模型中通过改善脑和脊髓结构与功能而具有神经保护作用,作者认为所有胎儿中心应采用实现防水性的神经外科技术。
研究设计与样本
- 在验证的胎儿绵羊脊柱裂模型中进行的把握度充分的优效性研究,每组7只,比较防水性多层修复、非防水性多层修复与未修复绵羊(历史对照)的结局;在约75天诱导腰椎脊柱裂,约100天根据术中皮下荧光素注射防水性测试分组,足月为145天。
主要发现
- 主要结局:防水修复组后脑疝逆转100%(7/7)vs 未修复组14%,非防水修复组86%但差异无统计学意义。
- 脑脊液漏:防水修复组14% vs 未修复组100%;非防水修复组43% vs 未修复组100%。
- 后肢运动功能:防水修复组关节运动评分、运动分级和运动诱发电位曲线下面积及峰峰值幅度均高于未修复组;非防水修复组无改善。
- 组织学:防水修复组海马和胼胝体神经元密度更高,脊柱裂病灶中心反应性星形胶质增生更高;非防水修复组海马和胼胝体神经元计数低,病灶中心脊髓星形胶质细胞面积小。
- 神经保护评分(涵盖活产、后脑疝完全逆转、无脑脊液漏和关节运动评分≥9/15):防水修复组4/4者5/7 vs 未修复组0/7;非防水修复组1/7。
关键数值与推荐
- 防水性测试因有创无法临床使用,作者基于皮肤修复视觉评估开发术中三点评分皮肤修复质量量表(缝线间距≤3 mm、无撕裂、无缺血),高质量定义为评分≥2/3,低质量为<2/3。
- 防水性多层修复和术中皮肤修复质量高评分(≥2/3)均与结局改善相关。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为所有胎儿中心应采用实现防水性的神经外科技术以改善神经保护。
- 未来临床研究可评估高皮肤修复质量评分(≥2/3)是否与神经保护相关。
- 防水性测试和皮肤修复质量量表因结果不一致不能互换使用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVES: A contributing factor to unsuccessful prenatal spina bifida aperta (SBA) repair via an open approach may be incomplete neurosurgical repair causing persistent in-utero leakage of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and exposure of the fetal spinal cord to amniotic fluid. We aimed to investigate the neurostructural and neurofunctional efficacy of watertight prenatal SBA repair in a validated SBA fetal lamb model. METHODS: A well-powered superiority study was conducted in the validated SBA fetal lamb model (n = 7 per group). The outcomes of lambs which underwent watertight or non-watertight multilayer repair through an open approach were compared to those of unrepaired SBA lambs (historical controls) at delivery (term = 145 days). At ∼75 days, fetal lambs underwent standardized induction of lumbar SBA. At ∼100 days, they were assigned to an either watertight or non-watertight layered repair group based on an intraoperative watertightness test using subcutaneous fluorescein injection. At 1-2 days postnatally, as primary outcome, we assessed reversal of hindbrain herniation using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Secondary proxies of neuroprotection were: absence of CSF leakage at the repair site; hindlimb motor function based on joint-movement score, locomotor grade and Motor Evoked Potential (MEP); four-score neuroprotection scale, encompassing live birth, complete hindbrain herniation reversal, absence of CSF leakage and joint-movement score ≥ 9/15; and brain and spinal cord histology and immunohistochemistry. As the watertightness test cannot be used clinically due to its invasiveness, we developed a potential surrogate intraoperative three-score skin-repair-quality scale based on visual assessment of the quality of the skin repair (suture inter-run distance ≤ 3 mm, absence of tear and absence of ischemia), with high quality defined by a score ≥ 2/3 and low quality by a score < 2/3, and assessed its relationship with improved outcome. RESULTS: Compared with unrepaired lambs, lambs with watertight repair achieved a high level of neuroprotection (neuroprotection score of 4/4 in 5/7 vs 0/7 lambs) as evidenced by: a significant 100% (vs 14%) reversal of hindbrain herniation on MRI; low CSF leakage (14% vs 100%); better hindlimb motor function, with higher joint-movement score, locomotor grade and MEP area under the curve and peak-to-peak amplitude; higher neuronal density in the hippocampus and corpus callosum; and higher reactive astrogliosis at the SBA lesion epicenter. Conversely, lambs with non-watertight SBA repair did not achieve the same level of neuroprotection (score of 4/4 in 1/7 lambs) compared with unrepaired lambs, with: a non-significant 86% (vs 14%) reversal of hindbrain herniation; high CSF leakage (43% vs 100%); no improvement in motor function; low brain neuron count in both the hippocampus and corpus callosum; and small spinal astroglial cell area at the epicenter. Both watertight layered repair and high (≥ 2/3) intraoperative skin-repair-quality score were associated with improved outcome, but the watertightness test and skin-repair-quality scale could not be used interchangeably due to result discrepancies. CONCLUSIONS: Watertight layered fetal SBA repair is neuroprotective since it improves brain and spinal-cord structure and function in the fetal lamb model. This translational research has important clinical implications. A neurosurgical technique that achieves watertightness should be adopted in all fetal centers to improve neuroprotection. Future clinical studies could assess whether a high skin-repair-quality score (≥ 2/3) correlates with neuroprotection. © 2022 International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- Joyeux L, van der Merwe J, Aertsen M, et al. Neuroprotection is improved by watertightness of fetal spina bifida repair in the sheep model. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2023. PMID: 35353933. doi:10.1002/uog.24907
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。