虚拟与门诊经阴道超声评估卵巢储备功能的比较
单中心头对头交叉试验纳入56名女性,居家在远程认证超声技师引导下自行完成虚拟经阴道超声,随后在门诊由另一技师完成经阴道超声。虚拟与门诊图像达到「临床质量」的比例分别为96%和98%,差值-2.4%(97.5%CI下限-5.5%)在18%非劣效界值内;窦卵泡计数等效,虚拟检查净推荐值更优(58.1分,97.5%CI 37.3-79.0,P<.01)。
要点
- 虚拟经阴道超声在产出临床质量图像方面非劣效于门诊经阴道超声。
- 两种模式下窦卵泡计数等效,差值0.23(95%CI -0.36至0.82)在等效界值2.65内。
- 虚拟检查净推荐值更优(58.1分,97.5%CI 37.3-79.0,P<.01),患者满意度更高。
核心结论
- 由超声技师远程引导的虚拟经阴道超声在产出临床质量图像方面非劣效于门诊经阴道超声,在估计窦卵泡计数方面等效。
- 虚拟经阴道超声患者满意度更优,有潜力显著扩大患者获得生育照护的机会。
研究设计与样本
- 单中心头对头交叉试验,于2020年12月至2021年5月纳入56名来自大波士顿地区、有意评估卵巢储备的女性。
- 受试者先居家在远程认证超声技师引导下自行完成虚拟经阴道超声,随后在门诊由另一名超声技师完成经阴道超声。
- 子宫和卵巢采集矢状面和横切面视图,随机录像由两或三名独立、盲法生殖内分泌学家审阅。
- 主要结局为居家与门诊所产临床质量图像率的非劣效性,样本量按18%非劣效界值下大于90%把握度选择。
- 次要结局包括窦卵泡计数等效性和净推荐值优效性。
主要发现
- 虚拟图像96%达到「临床质量」,门诊图像98%达到「临床质量」,差值-2.4%(97.5%CI下限-5.5%)在18%非劣效界值内。
- 两种模式下窦卵泡计数等效,卵泡数差值0.23(95%CI -0.36至0.82)在等效界值2.65内。
- 虚拟检查净推荐值更优(58.1分,97.5%CI差值37.3-79.0,P<.01),提示对虚拟体验满意度更高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To evaluate noninferiority of virtual transvaginal ultrasonography compared with in-clinic ultrasonography for ovarian reserve assessment. METHODS: We conducted a single-site, head-to-head crossover trial. Participants performed self-administered virtual transvaginal ultrasonography at home, guided by a remote-certified ultrasound technologist, then underwent transvaginal ultrasonography in-clinic with another ultrasound technologist. Participants were women in the greater Boston area interested in evaluating ovarian reserve and recruited through social media, health care referrals, and professional networks. The uterus and ovaries were captured in sagittal and transverse views. These randomized recordings were reviewed by two or three independent, blinded reproductive endocrinologists. The primary outcome was noninferiority of the rate of clinical quality imaging produced at home compared with in clinic. Sample size was selected for greater than 90% power, given the 18% noninferiority margin. Secondary outcomes included antral follicle count equivalency and net promoter score superiority. RESULTS: Fifty-six women were enrolled from December 2020 to May 2021. Participants varied in age (19-35 years), BMI (19.5-33.9), and occupation. Ninety-six percent of virtual and 98% of in-clinic images met "clinical quality." The difference of -2.4% (97.5% CI lower bound -5.5%) was within the noninferiority margin (18%). Antral follicle counts were equivalent across settings, with a difference in follicles (0.23, 95% CI -0.36 to 0.82) within the equivalence margin (2.65). Virtual examinations had superior net promoter scores (58.1 points, 97.5% CI of difference 37.3-79.0, P<.01), indicating greater satisfaction with the virtual experience. CONCLUSION: Virtual transvaginal ultrasonography remotely guided by an ultrasonography technologist is noninferior to in-clinic transvaginal ultrasonography for producing clinical quality images and is equivalent for estimating antral follicle count. Virtual transvaginal ultrasonography had superior patient satisfaction and has potential to significantly expand patient access to fertility care. FUNDING SOURCE: This study was sponsored by Turtle Health. CLINICAL TRIAL REGISTRATION: ClinicalTrials.gov, NCT04687189.
引用
- Chung EH, Petishnok LC, Conyers JM, et al. Virtual Compared With In-Clinic Transvaginal Ultrasonography for Ovarian Reserve Assessment. Obstet Gynecol. 2022. PMID: 35271530. doi:10.1097/AOG.0000000000004698
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。