母胎医学专科培训医师对产科超声和产前诊断的认知与操作舒适度
该研究对美国114名注册参加年度超声培训课程的PGY-6母胎医学专科培训医师进行问卷调查,72人完成(应答率96%)。结果显示,尽管全美超声培训结构已标准化,但不同地区培训医师在颈项透明层检查、详细解剖扫查和绒毛膜绒毛取样等操作上的自报舒适度仍存在区域异质性;床边教学参与度未影响自报舒适度。
要点
- 南部地区培训医师对颈项透明层和详细解剖扫查的自报舒适度低于其他地区(P=.046和P=.011)。
- 多数受访者对生长评估(78%)和脐动脉多普勒(58%)感到舒适,对三维超声、神经超声和胎儿超声心动图感到不舒适。
- 东北部受访者更可能对绒毛膜绒毛取样感到舒适(P=.001)。
核心结论
- 尽管全美超声培训结构已标准化,但母胎医学专科培训医师在培训中期对特定超声技术和绒毛膜绒毛取样的自报舒适度仍存在区域异质性。
- 母胎医学主治医师参与床边教学未影响培训医师对超声扫查的自报舒适度。
- 本研究强调需要进一步优化母胎医学专科培训的超声培训,尤其是先进超声和诊断性操作方面。
研究设计与样本
- 对美国114名注册参加年度超声培训课程的PGY-6母胎医学专科培训医师发放问卷,对于有超过1名培训医师参会的项目(n=39),仅由1人代表项目完成问卷。
- 共72名PGY-6培训医师完成问卷,应答率96%;地理分布为西部10人(14%)、中西部16人(22%)、南部17人(24%)、东北部29人(40%)。
主要发现
- 南部地区培训医师报告对颈项透明层检查感到舒适的可能性低于其他地区(P=.046),对详细解剖扫查感到舒适的可能性也低于其他地区(P=.011)。
- 多数受访者报告对生长评估(78%)和脐动脉多普勒(58%)感到舒适,对三维超声、神经超声和胎儿超声心动图感到不舒适。
- 东北部受访者报告对绒毛膜绒毛取样感到舒适的可能性更高(P=.001)。
- 各专科培训项目在有无超声课程、床边教学、超声相关研究导师指导或超声培训月数方面无差异。
- 母胎医学主治医师参与床边教学未影响培训医师对超声扫查的自报舒适度。
关键数值与推荐
- 美国妇产科委员会目前要求,在18个月核心临床培训中至少3个月专门用于超声培训,方有资格获得专科认证。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Ultrasound training is a vital component of maternal-fetal medicine fellowships in the United States. Of the 18 months of core clinical training, the American Board of Obstetrics and Gynecology currently requires a minimum of 3 months to be dedicated to ultrasound to be eligible for board certification. However, the experience and degree of hands-on training differ among the fellowship programs and have not been reassessed for nearly a decade. OBJECTIVE: To assess regional heterogeneity in the ultrasound training experience during maternal-fetal medicine fellowship in the United States. STUDY DESIGN: A survey was distributed to postgraduate year (PGY)-6 maternal-fetal medicine fellows registered to attend an annual ultrasound training course before the conference (n=114). For programs with >1 fellow attending (n=39), only 1 of them completed the survey to represent the program. The questions included demographics of the program, ultrasound training structure, the fellows' self-perception of ultrasound capabilities, research, mentorship, and technical aspects of sonography. RESULTS: Seventy two postgraduate year 6 fellows with a wide geographic distribution as follows completed the survey (96% response rate): 10 (14%) from the West, 16 (22%) from the Midwest, 17 (24%) from the South, and 29 (40%) from the Northeast. Respondents undergoing training in the South were less likely to report feeling comfortable performing nuchal translucency and detailed anatomic surveys than those from other regions (nuchal translucency: P=.046; anatomy: P=.011). Most of the respondents reported feeling comfortable performing growth (78%) and umbilical artery Doppler (58%) and feeling uncomfortable with three-dimensional ultrasound, neurosonography, and fetal echocardiography. Respondents in the Northeast were more likely to report feeling comfortable performing chorionic villus sampling (P=.001). There was no difference among fellowship programs in the presence or absence of ultrasound curriculum, bedside teaching, ultrasound-focused research mentorship, or months of ultrasound training. CONCLUSION: Despite the standardization of ultrasound training structure across the United States, there remains regional heterogeneity in fellow self-reported comfort with specific ultrasound techniques and chorionic villus sampling at a midpoint in their fellowship training. The maternal-fetal medicine attending involvement at the bedside did not affect the fellow self-reported comfort with ultrasound surveys. This study highlights the need for further optimization of maternal-fetal medicine fellowship ultrasound training, especially in advanced sonography and diagnostic procedures.
引用
- Holliman K, Pluym ID, Grechukhina O, et al. Maternal-fetal medicine fellows' perception and comfort with obstetrical ultrasound and prenatal diagnosis. Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2022. PMID: 35217235. doi:10.1016/j.ajogmf.2022.100601
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。