IVF患者的高期望:性别、倾向性乐观与共享IVF预后的作用
这项前瞻性调查纳入148名有伴侣的IVF患者,在取卵后和胚胎移植时评估其对IVF成功率的期望、倾向性乐观和焦虑。患者期望的成功率均值59.1%,仅接受低于平均预后的患者会下调期望,且女性出现焦虑反应。
要点
- 患者取卵后即刻期望的IVF成功率均值为59.1%(±20.0),不因性别而异(P=0.077)。
- IVF成功期望与参与者自身倾向性乐观正相关(P<0.001),与伴侣乐观、女性年龄及既往IVF经历无关。
- 接受低于平均预后(n=70)者将期望从55%降至46%(交互效应P<0.001),女性出现焦虑反应(交互效应P=0.011)。
核心结论
- 男女IVF患者均持有不切实际的高期望,该期望与自身倾向性乐观正相关,仅接受低于平均预后的患者会重新考虑期望,并导致女性更焦虑。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性调查,2019-2020年两个治疗时点(取卵后T1和胚胎移植时T2)纳入148名有伴侣的个体,参与率85%。
- 妇科医生在胚胎移植时使用Adapted van Loendersloot模型向夫妇提供其IVF预后。
- 女性和男性伴侣在取卵后和胚胎移植后独立完成问卷。
主要发现
- 患者取卵后即刻期望的IVF成功率均值为59.1%(±20.0),不因性别而异(P=0.077)。
- 伴侣间IVF成功期望呈中度相关(r=0.483;P<0.001)。
- IVF成功期望与参与者自身倾向性乐观正相关(P<0.001),与伴侣倾向性乐观、女性年龄及既往(不)成功IVF经历无关。
- 妇科医生给出的计算IVF预后范围为4.8%至69.2%(均值30.9%)。
- 接受低于平均预后的亚组(n=70)将IVF成功期望从55%降至46%(交互效应P<0.001),而接受至少平均预后的亚组(n=78)未重新考虑期望。
临床怎么用
- 作者建议诊所应向患者提供获得其IVF预后的机会。
- 作者认为提供预后符合患者偏好,并能缓和低于平均预后夫妇双方不切实际的高期望。
- 作者指出需要敏感的沟通方式,因为较低预后与女性轻度焦虑反应相关。
局限性
- 研究设计和样本量对于检验患者IVF成功期望的假设决定因素,比对研究共享预后对患者的影响更为优化。
- 重新考虑期望是否影响IVF中断率和活产率尚待随访。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Which success rates do female and male IVF patients expect, what determines their expectations and do patients reconsider their expectations after receiving a personal IVF prognosis at the expense of anxious reactions? SUMMARY ANSWER: Female and male IVF patients have unrealistic high expectations which are positively associated with their dispositional optimism, and which are only reconsidered by patients receiving a less than average IVF prognosis, which leads to more anxious reactions in females. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Female patients undergoing IVF are known to have unrealistic expectations of the success of their own IVF cycle. The available evidence suggests women expect above average performance of their fertility clinic and (family) reproductive systems. The association of gender and personality trait dispositional optimism, with expectations of IVF success and the impact of providing couples with their IVF prognosis have not been studied previously. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: A total of 148 partnered individuals participated in this prospective survey at two separate points in treatment: following oocyte aspiration (T1) and embryo transfer (T2) (2019-2020, participation rate = 85%). At the time of embryo transfer, gynaecologists provided couples with their IVF prognosis, calculated with the Adapted van Loendersloot model. Women and their male partners completed questionnaires independently and immediately following oocyte aspiration and embryo transfer. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Dispositional optimism ('LOT-R' questionnaire) and expectations of IVF success (numerical rating scale) were assessed in eligible couples commencing a 2nd-6th IVF cycle on T1. Expectations of IVF success and anxiety ('Spielberger State-Anxiety Inventory') were (re)assessed on T2. The inter-partner correlation of expectations of IVF success was examined. Linear mixed models examined hypothesized determinants of expectations of IVF success (T1) and explored (determinants of) whether participants reconsidered their expectations after receiving their IVF prognosis (T1-T2) and whether couple's IVF prognosis was associated with anxious reactions (T2). MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: The mean of the IVF success rates expected by patients immediately after oocyte aspiration was 59.1% (±20.0), irrespective of gender (P = 0.077). Partners expectations of IVF success were moderately correlated (r = 0.483; P < 0.001). Expectations of IVF success were positively associated with the participant's dispositional optimism (P < 0.001) but were not associated with their partner's dispositional optimism, women's age and their previous (un)successful IVF experiences. Gynaecologists gave couples their calculated IVF prognosis ranging from 4.8% to 69.2% (mean = 30.9%) at the time of embryo transfer. Gender did not influence whether participants reconsidered their expectations after receiving their prognosis. In contrast to the subgroup (n = 78), who received at least an average IVF prognosis and that did not reconsider their expectations of IVF success, the subgroup (n = 70) receiving a below average IVF prognosis lowered their expectations of IVF success (interaction effect: P < 0.001) from 55% to 46%. A below average IVF prognosis was associated with anxious reactions in women but not in men (interaction effect: P = 0.011). LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: The study design and sample size were more optimal for examining hypothesized determinants of patient's expectations of IVF success than for studying the impact of sharing prognoses with patients. Whether (reconsidering) expectations influences IVF discontinuation rates and achieved live birth rates has yet to be followed-up. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Clinics are advised to offer patients the opportunity of receiving their IVF prognosis. Providing prognoses is in line with patient preferences and tempers the unrealistic high expectations of both partners in couples with a less than average prognosis. A sensitive communication style is indicated, as lower prognoses are associated with mild anxious reactions in women. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): E.A.F.D. holds a postdoctoral fellowship of the Research Foundation-Flanders (12H9819N) and this study was funded by the Research Council of the KU Leuven (C14/18/106; project of J.V., K.P. and E.A.F.D.) and as an investigator sponsored study of K.P. and E.A.F.D. by Merck nv/sa Belgium, an affiliate of Merck KGaA, Darmstadt, Germany. The authors declare no conflict of interest related to this study. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.
引用
- Devroe J, Peeraer K, D'Hooghe TM, et al. Great expectations of IVF patients: the role of gender, dispositional optimism and shared IVF prognoses. Hum Reprod. 2022. PMID: 35213695. doi:10.1093/humrep/deac038
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。