双胎妊娠胎儿生长评估是否应采用双胎特异性生长曲线?
本综述探讨双胎与单胎妊娠胎儿生长差异的机制,并评估双胎特异性生长曲线与单胎生长曲线在诊断双胎胎儿宫内生长受限中的准确性。证据显示双胎曲线可使疑似宫内生长受限的比例降低达8倍,且所诊断的宫内生长受限与不良围产结局及高血压疾病的关联更强,同时不降低对胎盘功能不全所致高危胎儿的检出。现有数据主要来自观察性研究且存在明显局限,需足够把握度的试验证实双胎曲线的获益后方可被专业学会采纳。
要点
- 双胎妊娠孕晚期胎儿生长速度较单胎慢,其机制及是否为病理状态尚不明确。
- 使用双胎曲线可使疑似宫内生长受限的胎儿比例降低达8倍,且诊断与不良围产结局关联更强。
- 现有证据主要来自观察性研究且存在明显局限,需足够把握度的试验证实获益后方可被专业学会采纳。
核心结论
- 基于现有证据,使用双胎生长曲线是合理的,在监测双胎胎儿生长时可能优于单胎生长曲线。
- 现有数据存在明显局限且主要来自观察性研究,需足够把握度的试验证实双胎曲线的获益后方可被专业学会采纳。
研究设计与样本
- 本综述描述了双胎与单胎妊娠胎儿生长的差异,回顾了双胎胎儿生长较慢机制的现有认识,总结了两种生长曲线诊断双胎妊娠宫内生长受限准确性的现有实证证据,并探讨了无并发症双绒双胎胎儿死亡风险是否较单胎胎儿增加。
主要发现
- 使用双胎曲线可使疑似宫内生长受限的双胎胎儿比例降低达8倍。
- 基于双胎曲线诊断的宫内生长受限与不良围产结局及高血压疾病的关联强于基于单胎曲线的诊断,且不降低对胎盘功能不全所致高危双胎胎儿的检出。
- 小于胎龄的双胎胎儿发生不良围产结局或存在胎盘功能不全证据的可能性低于小于胎龄的单胎胎儿。
- 近期数据对无并发症双绒双胎因胎盘功能不全导致胎儿死亡风险增加这一长期观点提出质疑。
临床怎么用
- 基于现有证据,监测双胎胎儿生长时使用双胎曲线是合理的,可能优于单胎曲线。
- 现有数据存在明显局限且主要来自观察性研究,需足够把握度的试验证实双胎曲线的获益后方可被专业学会采纳。
局限性
- 现有数据存在明显局限,且主要来自观察性研究。
- 需足够把握度的试验证实双胎曲线的获益后方可被专业学会采纳。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
One of the hallmarks of twin pregnancies is the slower rate of fetal growth when compared with singleton pregnancies during the third trimester. The mechanisms underlying this phenomenon and whether it represents pathology or benign physiological adaptation are currently unclear. One important implication of these questions relates to the type growth charts that should be used by care providers to monitor growth of twin fetuses. If the slower growth represents pathology (ie, intrauterine growth restriction caused uteroplacental insufficiency), it would be preferable to use a singleton growth chart to identify a small twin fetus that is at risk for perinatal mortality and morbidity. If, however, the relative smallness of twins is the result of benign adaptive mechanisms, it is likely preferable to use a twin-based charts to avoid overdiagnosis of intrauterine growth restriction in twin pregnancies. In the current review, we addressed this question by describing the differences in fetal growth between twin and singleton pregnancies, reviewing the current knowledge regarding the mechanisms responsible for slower fetal growth in twins, summarizing available empirical evidence on the diagnostic accuracy of the 2 types of charts for intrauterine growth restriction in twin pregnancies, and addressing the question of whether uncomplicated dichorionic twins are at an increased risk for fetal death when compared with singleton fetuses. We identified a growing body of evidence that shows that the use of twin charts can reduce the proportion of twin fetuses identified with suspected intrauterine growth restriction by up to 8-fold and can lead to a diagnosis of intrauterine growth restriction that is more strongly associated with adverse perinatal outcomes and hypertensive disorders than a diagnosis of intrauterine growth restriction based on a singleton-based chart without compromising the detection of twin fetuses at risk for adverse outcomes caused by uteroplacental insufficiency. We further found that small for gestational age twins are less likely to experience adverse perinatal outcomes or to have evidence of uteroplacental insufficiency than small for gestational age singletons and that recent data question the longstanding view that uncomplicated dichorionic twins are at an increased risk for fetal death caused by placental insufficiency. Overall, it seems that, based on existing evidence, the of use twin charts is reasonable and may be preferred over the use of singleton charts when monitoring the growth of twin fetuses. Still, it is important to note that the available data have considerable limitations and are primarily derived from observational studies. Therefore, adequately-powered trials are likely needed to confirm the benefit of twin charts before their use is adopted by professional societies.
引用
- Hiersch L, Barrett J, Fox NS, et al. Should twin-specific growth charts be used to assess fetal growth in twin pregnancies? Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2022. PMID: 35114185. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2022.01.027
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。