文献速递妇科

外科科学-辛比奥尼克斯机器人子宫切除术模拟器:验证一种新工具

Surgical Science-Simbionix Robotic Hysterectomy Simulator: Validating a New Tool.
PubMed 文献 · J Minim Invasive Gynecol · 2022-02-03

这项前瞻性教育研究在3家学术医疗机构纳入10名新手、10名有经验和14名专家妇科医生,使用达芬奇Xi console模拟系统完成4个子宫切除术模块。多数参与者认为模拟真实(64.7%),反馈优于既往模拟器(88.2%)但不如手术室反馈(73.5%)。膀胱瓣和输尿管识别模块的模拟器指标与GEARS评分相关,膀胱瓣模块GEARS总分与经验水平相关。

要点

  • 64.7%参与者认为模拟器真实模拟机器人子宫切除术。
  • 88.2%认为模拟器反馈不劣于既往模拟器,73.5%认为不如手术室反馈。
  • 膀胱瓣模块GEARS总分与经验水平相关,其他模块未一致相关。

核心结论

  • 各经验水平参与者对该模拟器模块接受度良好。
  • 单个模拟模块在区分新手与有经验/专家用户方面似乎优于整体模拟器表现。
  • 基于这些数据和参与者反馈,在住院医师早期教育中使用单个模块可能有助于提供反馈,并可能最终作为判断是否准备好执行机器人子宫切除术的一个组成部分。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性教育研究,采用Messick效度框架,在3家学术医疗机构开展。
  • 共纳入10名新手(子宫切除术少于10例)、10名有经验(10至50例)和14名专家(超过50例)妇产科住院医师、专科培训医师和教员。

主要发现

  • 大多数参与者认为模拟器真实模拟机器人子宫切除术(64.7%)。
  • 88.2%参与者认为模拟器反馈与既往模拟器相当或更有帮助,但73.5%认为不如手术室反馈有帮助。
  • 参与者认为该模拟器有助于教学低年资住院医师。
  • 模拟器生成的指标在膀胱瓣和输尿管识别模块的多个领域(包括总移动次数和完成总时间)与GEARS表现相关。
  • 膀胱瓣模块的GEARS表现在兴趣领域和总分上与经验水平(新手 vs 有经验/专家)相关,但在其他手术模块中未一致相关;膀胱瓣模块各GEARS领域和总分评估了表现基准。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

STUDY OBJECTIVE: To gather validity evidence for and determine acceptability of Surgical Science-Simbionix Hysterectomy Modules for the DaVinci Xi console simulation system (software; 3D Systems by Simbionix [now Surgical Science-Simbionix], Littleton, CO, and hardware; Intuitive Surgical, Inc., Sunnyvale, CA) and evaluate performance benchmarks between novice and experienced or expert surgeons. DESIGN: Prospective education study (Messick validity framework). SETTING: Multicenter, academic medical institutions. PARTICIPANTS: Residents, fellows, and faculty in obstetrics and gynecology were invited to participate at 3 institutions. Participants were categorized by experience level: fewer than 10 hysterectomies (novice), 10 to 50 hysterectomies (experienced), and more than 50 hysterectomies (expert). A total of 10 novice, 10 experienced, and 14 expert surgeons were included. INTERVENTIONS: Participants completed 4 simulator modules (ureter identification, bladder flap development, colpotomy, complete hysterectomy) and a qualitative survey. Simulator recordings were reviewed in duplicate by educators in minimally invasive gynecologic surgery using the Modified Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Skills (GEARS) rating scale. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Most participants felt that the simulator realistically simulated robotic hysterectomy (64.7%) and that feedback provided by the simulator was as or more helpful than feedback from previous simulators (88.2%) but less helpful than feedback provided in the operating room (73.5%). Participants felt that this simulator would be helpful for teaching junior residents. Simulator-generated metrics correlated with GEARS performance for the bladder flap and ureter identification modules in multiple domains including total movements and total time for completion. GEARS performance for the bladder flap module correlated with experience level (novice vs experienced/expert) in the domains of interest and total score but did not consistently correlate for the other procedural modules. Performance benchmarks were evaluated for the bladder flap module for each GEARS domain and total score. CONCLUSION: The modules were well received by participants of all experience levels. Individual simulation modules appear to better discriminate between novice and experienced/expert users than overall simulator performance. Based on these data and participant feedback, the use of individual modules in early residency education may be helpful for providing feedback and may ultimately serve as 1 component of determining readiness to perform robotic hysterectomy.

来源:J Minim Invasive Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Cope AG, Lazaro-Weiss JJ, Willborg BE, et al. Surgical Science-Simbionix Robotic Hysterectomy Simulator: Validating a New Tool. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2022. PMID: 35123040. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2022.01.016

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。