虚拟现实模拟与受训者机器人辅助腹腔镜子宫切除术整体表现呈弱相关
本研究为随机对照试验的回顾性子组分析,纳入21名妇科受训者,在机器人辅助腹腔镜子宫切除术(RALH)术前行da Vinci技能模拟器训练,术中由主治医师用GEARS评估整体表现及阴道残端缝合步骤。结果显示模拟器总分与术中GEARS双手机敏度(ρ=-0.46)和力度敏感性(ρ=-0.39)呈负相关,与阴道残端缝合GEARS总分无相关性。
要点
- 受训者术中GEARS中位总分18.5/30,模拟器总分中位84.4/100。
- 更高级住院医师模拟器表现更差(中位86.6 vs 78.8,p=.03)。
- 模拟器总分与GEARS双手机敏度(ρ=-0.46,p=.02)和力度敏感性(ρ=-0.39,p=.05)负相关。
核心结论
- 模拟器评分指标与受训者整体术中表现相关性有限,GEARS评分无法区分相似技能水平,需开发能更好区分相似技能水平的术中评估工具。
研究设计与样本
- 随机对照试验的回顾性子组分析,学术医院,RALH患者N=29,妇科受训者N=21,术前行da Vinci技能模拟器训练,术中及视频回顾用GEARS评估。
主要发现
- 受训者术中GEARS中位总分18.5/30(四分位距17-22),模拟器总分中位84.4/100(四分位距78.1-87.5)。
- 更高级住院医师模拟器表现更差(中位86.6/100 vs 78.8/100,p=.03),整体RALH及阴道残端缝合术中GEARS评分与经验较少受训者相似。
- 模拟器总分与GEARS双手机敏度(ρ=-0.46,p=.02)和力度敏感性(ρ=-0.39,p=.05)呈负相关。
- 术中阴道残端缝合GEARS总分与模拟器整体表现无相关性;模拟器Tubes总分与更高GEARS力度敏感性亚分相关(ρ=0.73,p=.05)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: Both simulator practice and intraoperative performance serve to inform surgical trainee training, but the skill transfer from simulation to the intraoperative setting remains unclear. This study evaluates the correlation between trainee performance on virtual reality simulation and (1) overall intraoperative performance during robotic-assisted laparoscopic hysterectomy (RALH) procedures and (2) suturing performance during vaginal cuff closure portion of the case. DESIGN: Retrospective subgroup analysis of randomized controlled trial. SETTING: Academic hospital. PATIENTS: Patients with RALH (N = 29). INTERVENTIONS: Gynecological trainees (N = 21) performed simulation tasks using the da Vinci skills simulator on the day of surgery before performing RALH. Attending surgeons assessed participants' intraoperative performance using Global Evaluative Assessment of Robotic Skills (GEARS). Performance of the vaginal cuff closure step was subsequently assessed using GEARS scoring of anonymized videos. Spearman's correlation was used to quantify the relationship between simulation and intraoperative performances. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: Trainees achieved a median intraoperative GEARS score of 18.5/30 (interquartile range: 17-22) and a median total simulator score of 84.4/100 (interquartile range: 78.1-87.5). More advanced residents exhibited worse overall simulator performance (median score 86.6/100 compared with 78.8/100, p = .03) and similar intraoperative GEARS scores during overall RALH and vaginal cuff closure compared with less experienced trainees. Total simulation performance score was negatively correlated with GEARS Bimanual Dexterity (ρ = -0.46, p = .02) and Force Sensitivity subscores (ρ = -0.39, p = .05). There was no correlation between total GEARS intraoperative vaginal cuff closure scores and overall simulation performances; however, total Tubes simulation score was correlated with higher GEARS Force Sensitivity subscore (ρ = 0.73, p = .05). CONCLUSIONS: In this study, there was limited correlation between simulation score metrics and trainees' overall intraoperative performance. Furthermore, we identified that GEARS scores could not distinguish between similar trainee skill levels. These findings underscore the need to develop intraoperative assessment tools that can better discriminate different but similar skill levels.
引用
- Berges AJ, Vedula SS, Malpani A, et al. Virtual Reality Simulation Has Weak Correlation with Overall Trainee Robot-Assisted Laparoscopic Hysterectomy Performance. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 34896658. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2021.12.002
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。