盆腔手术中骶棘韧带固定术创新手术导航系统的开发
2021年7月至8月一项为期两个月的实验性前瞻性先导研究,在类手术条件下验证基于动作捕捉的骶棘韧带固定术导航方法。29名参与者(9名妇科外科医生和20名无医学背景者)使用两种模拟模型完成训练与缝合任务。无医学背景者在两次实验间缝合时间(46±20秒 vs 37±18秒,p=.047)和距离(3.8±1.3毫米 vs 3.2±1.4毫米,p=10⁻⁵)均有改善,作者认为该方法在类手术条件下似乎准确有效。
要点
- 29名参与者中9名妇科外科医生和20名无医学背景者使用两种模拟模型完成训练与缝合任务。
- 第1次实验中医生的缝合尝试有14次(42%)准确(低于5毫米阈值),无医学背景者为63次(65%)。
- 无医学背景者两次实验间最后一次缝合练习的时间从46±20秒降至37±18秒(p=.047),距离从3.8±1.3毫米降至3.2±1.4毫米(p=10⁻⁵)。
核心结论
- 这种基于动作捕捉的骶棘韧带固定术导航方法在类手术条件下测试似乎准确且有效。
- 下一步将设计更适应骶棘韧带固定术约束的骨盆模型,并与当前技术比较验证该方法的益处。
研究设计与样本
- 2021年7月至8月为期两个月的实验性前瞻性先导研究,在生物力学实验室学术研究环境中进行。
- 共29名参与者,包括9名妇科外科医生和20名无医学背景者,所有参与者使用两种模拟模型。
主要发现
- 第1次实验中工具总体舒适度评分为10分中的7.2分。
- 第1次实验中医生缝合尝试14次(42%)准确(低于5毫米阈值),无医学背景者63次(65%)准确。
- 第1次实验中医生缝合尝试22次(67%)快速(位于持续时间数据集前两个四分位数),无医学背景者28次(34%)快速。
- 无医学背景者两次实验间最后一次缝合练习的时间从46±20秒降至37±18秒(p=.047),距离从3.8±1.3毫米降至3.2±1.4毫米(p=10⁻⁵)。
局限性
- 下一步将设计更适应骶棘韧带固定术约束的骨盆模型,并与当前技术比较验证该方法的益处。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY OBJECTIVE: To validate the use of an innovative navigation method for sacrospinous fixation in surgery-like conditions as a new teaching tool and surgical method. DESIGN: Two-month experimental prospective pilot study between July and August 2021. SETTING: Biomechanics laboratory academic research. PATIENTS: A total of 29 participants took part in the study: 9 gynecological surgeons and 20 participants with no medical background. INTERVENTIONS: All participants used the 2 mocks-up. MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS: The experiment was composed of 2 training phases dedicated to improving the hand-eye coordination and suture skills on a training mock-up and of a suturing phase on a pelvic mock-up designed to recreate the surgery-like conditions of a sacrospinous fixation. The surgeons provided qualitative feedback on the bio-accuracy of the mock-ups and evaluated the ease of use of the navigation software. Nonsurgeons were included to assess the progression of the suture performance between 2 experiments performed 1 week apart (session 1 and 2). The main objective for participants was to reach a virtual target and to stitch sacrospinous ligaments. For session 1, an overall comfort score of 7.2 of 10 was attributed to the tool; 14 (42%) surgeon suture attempts and 63 (65%) nonsurgeon suture attempts were accurate (i.e., below the 5-mm threshold). Twenty-two (67%) surgeon suture attempts and 28 (34%) nonsurgeon suture attempts were fast (i.e., in the first 2 quantiles of the duration dataset). An improvement in the nonsurgeon performance was observed between the 2 sessions in terms of duration (session 1: 46 ± 20 s; session 2: 37 ± 18 s; p = .047) and distance (session 1: 3.8 ± 1.3 mm; session 2: 3.2 ± 1.4 mm; p = 10-5) for the last suturing exercise. CONCLUSION: This new motion capture-based navigation method for sacrospinous fixation tested under surgery-like conditions seemed to be accurate and effective. The next step will be to design a pelvis model more adapted to the constraints of a sacrospinous fixation and to validate the benefits of this method compared with current techniques.
引用
- Rozaire J, Naaim A, Dubuis L, et al. Development of an Innovative Surgical Navigation System for Sacrospinous Fixation in Pelvic Surgery. J Minim Invasive Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 34958953. doi:10.1016/j.jmig.2021.12.012
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。