多个IVF诊所间胚胎评级中心间可靠性有限:对胚胎选择的意义
研究评估65家诊所的胚胎学家按伊斯坦布尔共识对40枚第3天胚胎和40枚囊胚进行评级的中心内和中心间可靠性。36名胚胎学家参与,中心内可靠性一般为中等至相当好,中心间可靠性仅为尚可,互动培训后提升至中等。
要点
- 中心内可靠性:卵裂球对称性0.63、碎片0.72、囊胚扩张0.66为相当好;内细胞团0.59、滋养外胚层0.56为中等。
- 中心间可靠性从研究I期到III期整体从尚可(0.21-0.4)提升至中等(0.41-0.6),但高级胚胎学家碎片已为中等。
- 互动培训被认为有帮助,外部质量评估服务和人工智能可能进一步改善可靠性。
核心结论
- 中心内可靠性一般为中等至相当好,而中心间可靠性仅为尚可;互动培训将其提升至中等,该工作流程被认为有帮助。
研究设计与样本
- 研究拍摄40枚第3天胚胎和40枚囊胚各三个焦平面,邀请65家诊所的高级和初级胚胎学家按伊斯坦布尔共识评级(研究I期),随后所有参与者参加互动培训并由专家小组评级相同胚胎(研究II期),最后将第二组图片盲法发送给胚胎学家和专家评估(研究III期)。
- 36名来自18家中心的胚胎学家参与,参与率28%。
主要发现
- 中心内可靠性:卵裂球对称性Cohen's kappa 0.63(范围-0.02至1.0),碎片0.72(范围0.29-1.0),囊胚扩张0.66(范围0.19-1.0),内细胞团质量0.59(范围0.07-0.92),滋养外胚层质量0.56(范围0.01-0.97)。
- 中心间可靠性从研究I期到III期整体改善,所有分析参数从尚可(0.21-0.4)提升至中等(0.41-0.6),但高级胚胎学家的卵裂球碎片在培训前已为中等。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为互动培训工作流程有帮助,可提升中心间可靠性至中等;建立外部质量评估服务(如UK NEQAS)和人工智能可能进一步改善胚胎选择实践的可靠性。
局限性
- 参与率为28%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
RESEARCH QUESTION: What is the intra- and inter-centre reliability in embryo grading performed according to the Istanbul Consensus across several IVF clinics? DESIGN: Forty Day 3 embryos and 40 blastocysts were photographed on three focal planes. Senior and junior embryologists from 65 clinics were invited to grade them according to the Istanbul Consensus (Study Phase I). All participants then attended interactive training where a panel of experts graded the same embryos (Study Phase II). Finally, a second set of pictures was sent to both embryologists and experts for a blinded evaluation (Study Phase III). Intra-centre reliability was reported for Study Phase I as Cohen's kappa between senior and junior embryologists; inter-centre reliability was instead calculated between senior/junior embryologists and experts in Study Phase I versus III to outline improvements after training (i.e. upgrade of Cohen's kappa category according to Landis and Koch). RESULTS: Thirty-six embryologists from 18 centres participated (28% participation rate). The intra-centre reliability was (i) substantial (0.63) for blastomere symmetry (range -0.02 to 1.0), (ii) substantial (0.72) for fragmentation (range 0.29-1.0), (iii) substantial (0.66) for blastocyst expansion (range 0.19-1.0), (iv) moderate (0.59) for inner cell mass quality (range 0.07-0.92), (v) moderate (0.56) for trophectoderm quality (range 0.01-0.97). The inter-centre reliability showed an overall improvement from Study Phase I to III, from fair (0.21-0.4) to moderate (0.41-0.6) for all parameters under analysis, except for blastomere fragmentation among senior embryologists, which was already moderate before training. CONCLUSIONS: Intra-centre reliability was generally moderate/substantial, while inter-centre reliability was just fair. The interactive training improved it to moderate, hence this workflow was deemed helpful. The establishment of external quality assessment services (e.g. UK NEQAS) and the avant-garde of artificial intelligence might further improve the reliability of this key practice for embryo selection.
引用
- Cimadomo D, Sosa Fernandez L, Soscia D, et al. Inter-centre reliability in embryo grading across several IVF clinics is limited: implications for embryo selection. Reprod Biomed Online. 2021. PMID: 34819249. doi:10.1016/j.rbmo.2021.09.022
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。