用于人胚胎培养的商品化油品牌的特征描述与比较
研究比较了13种商品化油品牌,分析其粘度、密度、过氧化值和氧化潜力,并评估其稳定培养条件的能力及小鼠胚胎实验中的胚胎毒性。发现不同油品牌在渗透压升高、pH平衡与稳定性上存在显著差异,其中2种商品化油被鉴定为胚胎毒性;油品牌选择对胚胎培养成功重要。
要点
- 13种商品化油品牌在稳定培养条件及对胚胎发育和活力的直接影响上存在重要差异。
- 2种已上市商品化油在小鼠胚胎实验中被鉴定为胚胎毒性。
- 油品牌选择对体外胚胎培养成功重要,敏感小鼠胚胎实验有助于检测油中毒性。
核心结论
- 商品化油在物理特性和维持体外胚胎培养条件稳定性方面存在差异,油品牌选择对胚胎培养成功重要。
- 已释放至人IVF市场的2种油品牌被小鼠胚胎实验鉴定为胚胎毒性,凸显应用敏感小鼠胚胎实验检测此类样本毒性的重要性。
研究设计与样本
- 研究比较了13种不同商品化油品牌,每品牌使用单一批次油,并纳入同批多瓶以考虑批内变异。
- 首先分析各油的粘度、密度、过氧化值和潜在氧化;其次比较各油在胚胎培养和操作中减少pH、渗透压和温度波动的能力;最后采用先前优化的敏感小鼠胚胎实验比较各品牌至囊胚阶段的胚胎发育率,并对囊胚进行三重标记分析Oct4+细胞、凋亡细胞和总细胞数。
主要发现
- 不同油之间在渗透压升高和pH平衡与稳定性方面检测到显著差异,可能与其理化特征相关。
- 粘度较高的油样本倾向于对培养条件波动提供额外保护,但油间温度稳定性差异较小。
- 13种油样本中2种商品化油在小鼠胚胎实验中被鉴定为胚胎毒性。
- 油组间所得囊胚的总细胞数和内细胞团细胞数也检测到实质性差异。
局限性
- 每品牌仅使用单一批次油,因此无法确定油品质的批间变异;但纳入同批多瓶以考虑潜在批内变异。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
STUDY QUESTION: Are there significant differences between the available commercial oil brands used for human IVF? SUMMARY ANSWER: Important differences have been detected among the tested oil brands in their potential to stabilize culture conditions and, more importantly, in their direct effect on embryo development and viability. WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY: Mineral oil is a critical component of the human culture system due to its protective and stabilizing roles during in vitro embryo development. Many different oils are available on the market, with differences in their viscosity, density and overall quality. STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION: Thirteen different commercial oil brands were compared. PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS: Each oil was firstly analyzed to assess its viscosity, density, peroxide value and potential oxidation. Secondly, the capacity of each oil to reduce pH, osmolality and temperature fluctuations during embryo culture and manipulation was compared. Lastly, a sensitive mouse embryo assay (MEA) protocol, previously optimized to detect toxicity in oils samples, was used to compare the overall quality of the different brands in terms of embryo developmental rates up to the blastocyst stage. At the end of the MEAs, a triple labeling protocol was applied to analyze Oct4+ cells, apoptotic cells and total cell counts in the blastocysts obtained by fluorescence microscopy. MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE: Significant divergences were detected in the rise of osmolality and the equilibration and stability of pH between different oils, which could be correlated to their physico-chemical characteristics. In particular, oil samples with a higher viscosity tended to offer an additional protection against fluctuations in the culture conditions, however, the differences in temperature stability between oils were minor. Two out of the 13 oil samples, which were commercially available, were identified as embryo-toxic by applying the MEA protocol with increased sensitivity for toxicity detection. Additionally, substantial differences in the total number of cells and the number of cells in the inner cell mass of the obtained blastocysts were also detected between oil groups. LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION: A single lot of oil was used for each brand and, thus, lot-to-lot variations in oil quality could not be determined. However, several bottles from the same oil were included to account for potential intra-lot variability. WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS: Commercial oils differ in both their physical characteristics and their performance in maintaining the stability of the culture conditions during in vitro embryo culture. Oil selection is important for embryo culture success. Additionally, the detection of embryo-toxic oils which had already been released to the human IVF market showcases the importance of applying sensitive MEA protocols for a better detection of toxicity in this type of samples. STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S): This study was privately funded. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: N/A.
引用
- Mestres E, Matia-Algué Q, Villamar A, et al. Characterization and comparison of commercial oils used for human embryo culture. Hum Reprod. 2022. PMID: 34791223. doi:10.1093/humrep/deab245
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。