文献速递产科母胎医学

扭转医生对孕妇推荐新冠疫苗接种的犹豫

Reversing physician hesitancy to recommend COVID-19 vaccination for pregnant patients.
PubMed 文献 · Am J Obstet Gynecol · 2021-11-08

本文指出医生犹豫是孕妇新冠疫苗接种率低的重要原因,并将其归因于治疗虚无主义、共享决策和尊重患者自主性三个专业伦理要点的临床误用。作者主张在已有明确净临床获益时医生应推荐而非仅提供接种,扭转这种犹豫是紧迫的患者安全问题。

要点

  • 医生犹豫指医生不推荐新冠疫苗接种,是孕妇接种率低的促成因素。
  • 治疗虚无主义在已有明确净临床获益且无临床伤害证据时属于误用。
  • 共享决策不适用于存在净临床获益的情形,此时应推荐而非仅提供临床处理。

核心结论

  • 医生犹豫已成为产科医疗质量与安全中一个重大且未被解决的问题。
  • 医生应通过扭转治疗虚无主义、共享决策和尊重患者自主性这三个根本原因,终结对孕妇新冠疫苗接种的犹豫。
  • 扭转医生犹豫的根本原因是紧迫的患者安全问题。

研究设计与样本

  • 本文为专业伦理分析文章,识别医生犹豫的3个根本原因并说明产科专业伦理应如何指导扭转这些原因。

主要发现

  • 医生犹豫是孕妇新冠疫苗接种率低的促成因素。
  • 治疗虚无主义指示产科医生避免孕期任何临床干预,以防可能未知的致畸效应。
  • 当存在有记录的净临床获益且无临床伤害证据时,治疗虚无主义属于误用。
  • 共享决策在临床判断存在不确定性时起主要作用,但作为普遍模式时属于误用。
  • 有证据表明产科医生关于孕期管理的推荐是孕妇决策中最重要的因素。

关键数值与推荐

  • 存在净临床获益时,应推荐临床处理,而非仅提供。
  • 共享决策不适用于存在净临床获益的情形。
  • 尊重患者自主性被误用于假定尊重自主性要求医生不做推荐且无条件遵从并执行患者决定。

临床怎么用

  • 产科医生必须通过扭转三个根本原因来终结对孕妇新冠疫苗接种的犹豫。
  • 医生犹豫持续越久、孕妇疫苗接受率低迷越久,未接种妇女可预防的严重疾病、死亡、重症监护病房入住、死胎及其他母胎并发症将持续发生。
  • 不应允许医生犹豫影响对未来大流行的应对。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Physician hesitancy is said to occur when physicians do not recommend COVID-19 vaccination, and it is a contributing factor for the low vaccination rate for COVID-19 in pregnant women. Physician hesitancy has become a major, unaddressed problem with regard to the quality and safety of obstetrical care. We identify 3 root causes of physician hesitancy and describe how professional ethics in obstetrics should guide in reversing these root causes. They are clinical misapplications of key components of professionally responsible obstetrical practice: therapeutic nihilism, shared decision-making, and respect for patient autonomy. Therapeutic nihilism directs the obstetrician to avoid any clinical interventions during pregnancy to prevent teratogenic effects that might be unknown. Therapeutic nihilism is misapplied when there is a documented net clinical benefit with no evidence of clinical harm. Shared decision directs the obstetrician to only offer but not recommend clinical management. Shared decision-making plays a major role when there is uncertainty in clinical judgment but is misapplied when it becomes a universal model. It does not apply when there is a net clinical benefit. When there is a net clinical benefit, clinical management should be recommended, not simply offered. The ethical principle of respect for patient autonomy plays an indispensable role in decision-making with patients. It is misapplied when it is assumed that respect for autonomy requires physicians not to make recommendations and to defer to and implement patients' decisions without exception. There is evidence that the obstetrician's recommendations about the management of pregnancy are the most important factor in a pregnant woman's decision-making. Simply deferring to the patient's decisions makes for misapplied respect for patient autonomy. Obstetricians must end physician hesitancy about COVID-19 vaccination of pregnant women by reversing these 3 root causes of physician hesitancy. Reversing the root causes of physician hesitancy is an urgent matter of patient safety. The longer physician hesitancy continues and the longer the low vaccine acceptance rate of pregnant women lasts, preventable serious diseases, deaths of pregnant women, intensive care unit admissions, stillbirths, and other maternal and fetal complications of unvaccinated women will continue to occur. Physician hesitancy should not be permitted to influence the response to future pandemics.

来源:Am J Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chervenak FA, McCullough LB, Grünebaum A, et al. Reversing physician hesitancy to recommend COVID-19 vaccination for pregnant patients. Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2021. PMID: 34762864. doi:10.1016/j.ajog.2021.11.017

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。