心律失常复发分析:方法、基质特征描述与临床转化的系统综述。
完整摘要 · 中文译文
心律失常是发病和死亡的主要原因,导管消融依赖于对潜在基质的准确识别。心脏信号是非线性且非平稳的,这限制了基于傅里叶的分析。递归量化分析(RQA)及相关递归方法所作的假设较少,但其在心律失常研究中的应用尚未被系统综合。本综述考察递归分析已证明了什么、其方法应用的一致性如何,以及在能够支持临床基质表征之前还有哪些问题有待解决。从四个数据库检索到的309条记录中(去重后207条),48项研究符合纳入标准,引文检索新增1项,共计49项。每项研究均进行全文审查,考察其信号、队列、嵌入参数、阈值选择、指标和结果,并归入六个方法学类别之一。三项将递归分析与替代或 shuffled 数据检验的研究均发现,颤动信号中存在匹配的随机替代数据无法重现的结构。递归指标与主频相关性较弱,且在基质表征中存在分歧,因此二者不可互换。阈值选择是最具影响的未控制变量:在使用中有五种策略,35项应用阈值的研究中有10项未报告选择规则,仅3项考察了其结果对阈值的依赖程度。确定性和层流性虽然是最常报告的指标,但并非始终是最强的判别 判别因素。临床就绪状态尚未确立:仅有一项研究前瞻性地使用复发标测来指导消融,纳入10例患者且未进行随机化。需要统一的阈值选择标准和前瞻性多中心验证。
完整摘要 · 英文原文
Cardiac arrhythmias are a major cause of morbidity and mortality, and catheter ablation depends on accurate identification of the underlying substrate. Cardiac signals are nonlinear and non-stationary, which limits Fourier-based analysis. Recurrence quantification analysis (RQA) and related recurrence methods make fewer assumptions, but their use in arrhythmia research has not been systematically synthesised. This review examines what recurrence analysis has demonstrated, how consistently its methods have been applied, and what remains before it can support clinical substrate characterisation. Of 309 records retrieved from four databases (207 after deduplication), 48 studies met the eligibility criteria and citation searching added one, giving 49. Each study was examined in full text for its signals, cohorts, embedding parameters, threshold selection, metrics and results, and assigned to one of six methodological categories. The three studies that tested recurrence against surrogate or shuffled data each found structure in fibrillatory signals that matched stochastic surrogates did not reproduce. Recurrence metrics and dominant frequency were weakly correlated and diverged in substrate characterisation, so they are not interchangeable. Threshold selection was the most consequential uncontrolled variable: five strategies were in use, ten of the 35 studies that apply a threshold reported no selection rule, and only three examined how their results depended on it. Determinism and laminarity, although the most frequently reported metrics, were not consistently the strongest discriminators. Clinical readiness is not established: only one study used recurrence mapping prospectively to guide ablation, in ten patients without randomisation. A shared threshold-selection standard and prospective multicentre validation are needed.