[论著] 一项在坦桑尼亚大规模预防儿童性暴力、性剥削和虐待的混合式数字育儿干预:整群随机对照试验
完整摘要 · 中文译文
背景:儿童期性暴力、躯体暴力和言语暴力是全球公共卫生优先事项,每年影响10亿儿童。ParentApp将性暴力预防整合到世界卫生组织-联合国儿童基金会(WHO-UNICEF)的开放获取“终身健康育儿”项目中,采用创新的混合数字交付方式。我们旨在检验ParentApp在预防针对青春期年龄儿童的性暴力和虐待以及改善预防机制(如家庭心理健康和青少年-照护者关系)方面的有效性。 方法:本整群随机对照试验在坦桑尼亚的80个次区开展。参与者为年龄18岁及以上的主要照护者及其青少年子女(10-17岁)。各次区按1:1随机分配,接受ParentApp(干预组)或对照WASHApp项目。整群按每组6个随机分配,并依据城市与农村地点进行分层。实施随机化的统计人员和数据分析人员设盲;但无法对参与者或研究人员设盲。干预组获得一部安装有ParentApp的低成本安卓手机,该应用为包含12个模块的离线优先应用,并提供一次面对面指导课程及通过WhatsApp群聊提供的远程支持,规模化实施时每户交付成本为6美元,或在提供20%智能手机的情况下为10美元。对照组获得一部安装有WASHApp的低成本安卓手机,该应用为包含12个模块的离线优先应用,内容涉及水、环境卫生和个人卫生,并提供一次面对面指导课程。主要结局为青少年性暴力受害和虐待以及性暴力高风险情境,在基线后5个月和18个月时对所有参与者进行评估,不论其是否接受或参与干预。该试验于2023年3月14日在OSF注册(https://osf.io/t9fxz),现已完成。 研究结果:2023年5月11日至10月9日期间,共筛选了2692对照顾者-青少年组合以确定研究资格;共招募2396名青少年(1217名[50.8%]女性,1179名[49.2%]男性)和2396名照顾者(1795名[74.9%]女性,601名[25.1%]男性)。2145名(89.5%)青少年和2252名(94.0%)照顾者留在研究中并纳入18个月时的分析。与对照集群相比,ParentApp集群中的青少年女孩过去一个月性暴力受害情况大幅减少(发病率比[IRR] 0.43 [95% CI 0.21-0.86];p=0.018),对男孩无效果(1.21 [0.59-2.43];p=0.60)。ParentApp集群过去一个月的虐待(躯体虐待、言语虐待和忽视)低于对照集群(青少年报告IRR 0.92 [0.88-0.96];p<0.0001,照顾者报告0.87 [0.82-0.92];p<0.0001)。ParentApp集群过去一个月暴露于性暴力高风险情境的情况低于对照集群(青少年女孩IRR 0.87 [0.77-0.97];p=0.012,青少年男孩0.85 [0.79-0.91];p<0.0001,照顾者报告0.81 [0.75-0.88];p<0.0001)。未报告不良事件。 解读:在坦桑尼亚等国家实施的低成本混合数字养育项目可同时减少儿童期性暴力(对女孩)以及虐待和性暴力风险情境(对女孩和男孩)。 资助:英国研究与创新署全球挑战研究基金、橡树基金会、乐高基金会、欧洲研究理事会及一位匿名捐赠者。
完整摘要 · 英文原文
BACKGROUND: Childhood sexual, physical, and verbal violence are global public health priorities, affecting 1 billion children each year. ParentApp integrates sexual violence prevention into WHO-UNICEF's open-access Parenting for Lifelong Health programme, using innovative blended digital delivery. We aimed to test the efficacy of ParentApp in preventing sexual violence and maltreatment against adolescent-aged children and improving preventive mechanisms such as family mental health and adolescent-caregiver relationships. METHODS: This cluster-randomised, controlled trial was conducted in 80 Tanzanian sub-wards. Participants were primary caregivers aged 18 years and older and their adolescents (aged 10-17 years). Sub-wards were randomly assigned (1:1) to receive either ParentApp (intervention group) or a control WASHApp programme. Clusters were randomly assigned in blocks of six, stratified by urban versus rural location. Statisticians carrying out randomisation and data analysts were masked; it was not possible to mask participants or researchers. Intervention groups received a low-cost Android phone installed with ParentApp, a 12-module offline-first app, with one in-person orientation session and remote support via WhatsApp group chats, at a delivery cost of US$6 per family at scale, or $10 with 20% smartphone provision. Control groups received a low-cost Android phone installed with WASHApp, a 12-module offline-first app for water, sanitation, and hygiene, with one in-person orientation session. The primary outcomes were adolescent sexual violence victimisation and maltreatment and high-risk situations for sexual violence, assessed in all participants irrespective of uptake and engagement at 5 months and 18 months post-baseline. The trial was registered on March 14, 2023, with OSF (https://osf.io/t9fxz) and is completed. FINDINGS: Between May 11 and Oct 9, 2023, 2692 caregiver-adolescent dyads were screened for study eligibility; 2396 adolescents (1217 [50·8%] female and 1179 [49·2%] male) and 2396 caregivers (1795 [74·9%] female and 601 [25·1%] male) were recruited. 2145 (89·5%) adolescents and 2252 (94·0%) caregivers were retained in the study and included in analyses at 18 months. Adolescent girls in ParentApp clusters had a substantial reduction in past-month sexual violence victimisation compared with those in control clusters (incidence rate ratio [IRR] 0·43 [95% CI 0·21-0·86]; p=0·018), with no effect for boys (1·21 [0·59-2·43]; p=0·60). Past-month maltreatment (physical abuse, verbal abuse, and neglect) was lower in ParentApp clusters than in control clusters (adolescent report IRR 0·92 [0·88-0·96]; p<0·0001, caregiver report 0·87 [0·82-0·92]; p<0·0001). Past-month exposure to high-risk situations for sexual violence was lower in ParentApp clusters than in control clusters (adolescent girls IRR 0·87 [0·77-0·97]; p=0·012, adolescent boys 0·85 [0·79-0·91]; p<0·0001, caregiver report 0·81 [0·75-0·88]; p<0·0001). There were no reported adverse events. INTERPRETATION: A low-cost blended digital parenting programme in countries such as Tanzania could simultaneously reduce childhood sexual violence (for girls) and maltreatment and sexual violence risk situations (for girls and boys). FUNDING: UK Research and Innovation Global Challenges Research Fund, The Oak Foundation, The LEGO Foundation, The European Research Council, and an anonymous donor.